Jump to content
Greg Pappas

Fixing Wieters Swing

Recommended Posts

I hate to say it, I REALLY do... but Matt Wieters inspires zero confidence in me that he's the feared hitter that I/we envisioned after he was so dominate in the minors. He was the top prospect in baseball, and a sure-fire superstar. What happened?

His defense is very good, and there is that for us... an important thing to remember certainly. But I am not focusing on that aspect here, but rather the almost pitiful flailing we so often see when he bats. There seems to be something terribly wrong with his swing. I am by no means an expert on swing mechanics, but he appears to have a slow bat and little force behind the ball after connecting. Maybe he'll start crushing the ball, and this thread will turn to dust... but my concerns seem valid. Can Pressley fix his swing, or is this the player we'll have for years to come?

Thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was very encouraged at the end of spring training when I read he was working on changing his swing. He had a decent last week and I thought he looked good at the plate the first game in Tampa with a notably faster swing. Since then it's been crap. Can't argue that he's been a rock behind the plate but his offense is awful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I try not to even think about this because I just get discouraged. Hopefully once the other bats get hot, he'll be able to ride on their coattails and gain some confidence. It seems like every other at bat he's starting out 0-2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We've talked about this a lot and I repeat what I have said before. He should go to a lighter bat. A slow bat is normally corrected this way. Maybe he needs to work in a weight room a little bit. He also appears to have the bat lower to his shoulder. He needs to get the bat more upright as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Every time I see him swing I want to scream, "Just swing hard!!!". It seems he is so tentative as his bat comes through the zone. It is almost like he is trying to catch the ball with the bat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So.....everyone thinks that instead of a Joe Mauer clone, we have a 6'-6" Rick Dempsey instead? IMO, I think that long term, we won't be disappointed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't understand why he wouldn't use a lighter bat or work on forearm strength. Doing a ton of wrist curls and stuff did wonders for my bat speed in high school. But I'd imagine that at this level they would already do this simple stuff, its puzzling.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know very little about scouting, but Wieters' problems don't seem to be mechanical to me. I think it's mostly mental, maybe lacking confidence or maybe thinking too much. Whatever it is, he has absolutely no conviction at the plate.

Edited by Scrat1
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Although it is early in his career, I see many comparisons to another firstt round pick, Jason Veritek. He came to the Majors with hype that was quite similar to Weiters. He was a solid Defensive Catcher with a career batting average of .258. I believe that Weiters woll provide better offensive numbers and will be solid on defense. A good everyday catcher with some pop in his bat is hard to find and if he continues to progress in all phases of his game, he will a vital part of this team for many years. With all of hype he came up with, many of us may have had unrealistic expections.

Edited by castleman
typos
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With our regular lineup, he is the biggest hole offensively. Although, I think his defense and calling of the game make him our most valuable player.

It sucks, because I root for him to succeed at the plate more than anyone else. I just don't think it's going to happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



Rumors and News






  • Posts

    • Notice that the O's have quietly gathered up an interesting stable of lefties:  Bishop, Lowther, Wells, DL Hall, Akin, and arguably Tanner Scott.  In past years, I'd have to reach and mention guys like Lee and Means - no longer - though I did kinda mention them right there.        
    • I would say that Bonds left a legacy in San Francisco.  He left Pittsburgh two years later than Manny.   When I think of the Braves.  Greg Maddox comes to mind though he came up with the Cubs.
    • Again, I don't think teams are going to drop his value because of what he did mostly at 19, but if he had that feather in his cap his value would be much more in my opinion. Basically he's a post season unknown. Of course his career .240/.296/.406/.702 slash line in 611 Sep/Oct PAs could be an indicator of a guy who either gets tired late in the year or who doesn't do well in pennant races (the Orioles have been in the mix in September for most of his career). If I'm giving a guy $300 million i want to make sure he's at his best when the lights are the brightest.
    • Perhaps, but I think a legacy is more than putting up a numbers. A legacy is being known as one of the best for a team, usually a team you were drafted and developed by. It does bring up an interesting thought on what a legacy really is. Did Reggie Jackson leave a legacy with the Yankees for his Mr. October heroics? Despite those heroics, I doubt many Yankees fans would name to their top Yankees team.  

      When I think legacy, I think of guys who when you name a team, you think of them. Obviously legacy Orioles would be Brooks, Palmer, Cal and Weaver. But some might argue that Frank Robinson and Eddie Murray left a legacy here as well. Now I'm partial to Eddie because he WAS the Orioles when I was growing up, but at the end of the day, the Orioles won only World Series during his time and he spent 8 season out of an Orioles uniform. So I guess I have to wonder can Machado still leave a legacy with another team? When I think about it, he does have time but it would probably have to be with a team without a long history of legacy players. In other words, could he become a legacy player with some team like the Diamondbacks or Rockies? Probably. But I doubt he would if he became a Red Sox, Yankee, or Dodger. 

      It's an interesting thought. But I do know is the Orioles are the only team in which he could end up one of the greatest players ever. The Orioles are really the only team in which he has a chance to one day be considered for the team's "Mt Rushmore". 
    • Baseball America had him in their top 20 NY/Penn league prospects over Lowther and Hanifee. So people like him. I’m not as high on him, and I’ll explain why in detail as I do my top prospect countdown. An interesting aside from the BA top 20 NY/Penn league list is they asked a scout about Hunter Harvey (who didn’t pitch enough to qualify for the list) and the scout said if he was eligible he’d be #1 (over McKay who is probably a top 100 guy).
    • Fair enough, and I suppose if Manny had a good postseason in 2012 it would be another feather in his cap.    But I’m much more likely to assign meaning to Adam Jones’ .155/.206/.207 line in 63 postseason PA in his age 26, 28 and 30 seasons, than to Manny’s .174/.240/.348 over 27 PA, almost all of which was accrued in his age 19 season.    I don’t think that teams pursuing Manny will give his postseason performance any serious weight.    
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×