In a vacuum, Adley wouldn’t be the guy I most want to lock up, but he might be the easiest one and might be the cornerstone that allows others to decide they want in, too. So if he’s willing to play ball, I say go for it.
I realize most catchers don’t age that well, but Adley is a guy whose value to the team isn’t measured solely by offensive stats. He’s an important leader on the team, whose presence on the roster made an enormous difference the minute he stepped on the field. The rebuilding era ended the instant he joined the club. And everyone in the clubhouse knows it.
So, fine with me if Adley’s the first guy we lock up. It may make it easier to go after others. And I’ll bet on the guy earning his deal.