Jump to content

Toronto loses Michael Saunders until ASG


Enjoy Terror

Recommended Posts

http://hardballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/02/26/blue-jays-outfielder-michael-saunders-tore-a-meniscus-in-his-knee-is-out-until-the-all-star-break/

Freak injury stepping on a sprinkler head in the outfield. Obviously, you don't like to see stuff like that happen but what a break for the O's.

Michael Saunders isn't exactly a big deal. Yes, I am sorry for him, but I'd hardly say this fundamentally changes the Blue Jays' pennant chances.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Michael Saunders isn't exactly a big deal. Yes, I am sorry for him, but I'd hardly say this fundamentally changes the Blue Jays' pennant chances.

It does thin their outfield as they only have Batista, Pompey, and Pillar on their 40 man. They'll have to convert some IFers.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Or claim Hassan.

Yes, that would kind of stink.

I think the loss of Saunders is big. Bautista is already injury prone and if he goes down for a significant period, their outfield looks terrible. I understand Pompey is a good prospect but it's a gamble whether he produces in his rookie year or not. The Jays have basically lost Melky Cabrera's spot in the lineup with no replacement.

1) SS Reyes (B)

2) 3B Donaldson

3) RF Bautista

4) 1B Encarnacion

5) C Martin

6) DH Navarro (B)

7) LF Pillar

8) CF Pompey (B)

9) 2B Izturis (B)

Four switch hitters yes... but where is the lefty in the lineup? Other than Saunders, it's Josh Thole or Ryan Goins (yuck).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Michael Saunders isn't exactly a big deal. Yes, I am sorry for him, but I'd hardly say this fundamentally changes the Blue Jays' pennant chances.
His 128 OPS+ last year was a big deal.

I suppose. Even with that season (in which he played only 78 games due to injuries), his career OPS+ is only 94. I'm not saying he isn't a solid player, just that losing him for half a season isn't like losing Bautista and Encarnacion for large chunks of time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I suppose. Even with that season (in which he played only 78 games due to injuries), his career OPS+ is only 94. I'm not saying he isn't a solid player, just that losing him for half a season isn't like losing Bautista and Encarnacion for large chunks of time.

3 straight seasons of at least 106 OPS+ and an rWAR in that period of 5.6. He was lousy his first three big league seasons but he came up pretty young. Only 28 this year. Definitely not on the level of Bautista or Encarnacion, but it is rough to lose a regular contributor. Can't say I would easily brush it off if the same thing happened to De Aza or Snyder.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 straight seasons of at least 106 OPS+ and an rWAR in that period of 5.6. He was lousy his first three big league seasons but he came up pretty young. Only 28 this year. Definitely not on the level of Bautista or Encarnacion, but it is rough to lose a regular contributor. Can't say I would easily brush it off if the same thing happened to De Aza or Snyder.

Yes, and the difference is, the Orioles have the depth in the organization to replace them. The Blue Jays do not. Their 4th OF role is a complete vacancy at the moment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, and the difference is, the Orioles have the depth in the organization to replace them. The Blue Jays do not. Their 4th OF role is a complete vacancy at the moment.

I was thinking about this earlier. Toronto kept their stud outfielder and lost two others. Same with Baltimore. Toronto traded for Saunders. The Orioles traded for snider. Although we kind of lucked into Pearce, we were proactive to trade for Lough and De Aza last year. We also stocked the minors with Hassan (who may end up losing), Reimold, and Parmalee. This is a strong example of how DD has created depth in the org to put us in a better position.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Lower the bar to 400 PAs and there were 27.  Health and platoons?  Still less than 1 per team.  In the early going, there are 42 over .850.  Still wouldn't count on it, but crazier things have happened from lesser talent over the course of a season. As a team, O's team OPS is .780.  Sure a few mild surprises, but also a nothing burger from Holliday.
    • Today's guess: Gunnar - SS Adley - C O'Hearn - 1B Santander - DH Cowser - LF Mullins - CF Westburg - 3B Kjerstad - RF Holliday - 2B Stupid. Lol. 
    • Means has to pitch his way back into our rotation. Not impossible, but I think Akin or Tate will be optioned for him next week when his 30 days are up. 
    • They could go 0 for the season and they'd still be more fun than the singing group.
    • Reminds me of Miguel Gonzalez, who came out of nowhere to be a major contributor to some playoff runs.  I doubt he ends up as a rotation mainstay. But I was certain O'Hearn would turn into a pumpkin after a few weeks too and he still hasn't.
    • If it weren’t for the service time component I think Holliday would have a very long leash before being sent down. He’s still contributing positively on defense and AAA pitchers just were not challenging him anymore. The priority above all else should be what is best for his long term development, and he needs to struggle against MLB pitching for longer than this to get to a point where you feel it’s doing more harm than good. I do think there can be some merit to the idea that MLB time exposes some weakness, which then can be worked on in a lower-stress environment in AAA, but I don’t think that’s strictly necessary since he’d be working on the same things against MLB pitching. However, the Orioles are now in a tricky situation where if it becomes apparent that Holliday is not going to win ROY, they have a strong incentive to send him down for at least a short stint to get the extra year. How they navigate that without that being totally transparent is tough. They could definitely do it now and nobody would claim service time manipulation given his struggles, but I don’t think they want to yet for purely development purposes. If he’s still struggling with around 100 PAs that’s when I think they make the move. 
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...