Does a Yankee get plunked tomorrow?

[tywright]

the plunking was followed by a walk to rodriguez.

question: if the yankees had scored a run or two, would the plunking have been worth it?

(i personally don't think so)

This is always discussed...and the answer is always YES. A retaliatory plunk is more important than giving up a run because the retaliation goes a lot further than one run and one game.

[beaner]

And the inning ends without Jeter scoring. Message sent.

Exactly, and hopefully that's the end of it. No need to escalate any more.

[Mad Mark]

IF we were playing Clue:
Derek Christ, in the thigh, with a fastball, in the first...

Miss Pay Rod...youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuur'e next!

[RShack]

Where'd you hear this?

That is 100% my fabrication. My impression is that Bedard is not so inclined... my assumption is that DT had a little chat with him... I am making all of this up out of 100% whole cloth with zero facts behind it.

[sector7g]

Why didn't we just do it yesterday while leading 12-0?

[PaulFolk]

That is 100% my fabrication. My impression is that Bedard is not so inclined... my assumption is that DT had a little chat with him... I am making all of this up out of 100% whole cloth with zero facts behind it.

I disagree with this. It's completely within Bedard's nature to stick up for his teammates. From what I hear, he's always been known as a stand-up teammate and is well-liked in the clubhouse. He saw the same things we did last night, and he knew exactly what to do about it.

My bet is that Trembley didn't have to say a word to him.

[beaner]

Why didn't we just do it yesterday while leading 12-0?

I guess the idea was to get one of their stars, as opposed to Phillips or Betemit.

[hallmt18]

A retaliatory plunk...goes a lot further than one run and one game.

I'm not trying to be snarky at all, but what exactly does a retaliatory plunk accomplish to make it more valuable than giving up a run or losing a game?

Is this purely a matter of team morale? (i.e.- we got each other's back)

you may very well be right. this is just something i feel like i've never really understood.

[Sports Guy]

No question...It was understood, Jeter handled it fine, took it like a man. He probably knew it was coming with two out and none on.

Good...Hit the perfect guy.

[tywright]

Why didn't we just do it yesterday while leading 12-0?

Plunking someone in the 1st with 2 outs is a more powerful statement than hitting someone in the 9th when it's 12-0. Either the way, the message has been sent and we shouldn't see anything else happen from here on out.

[Sports Guy]

I disagree with this. It's completely within Bedard's nature to stick up for his teammates. From what I hear, he's always been known as a stand-up teammate and is well-liked in the clubhouse. He saw the same things we did last night, and he knew exactly what to do about it.

My bet is that Trembley didn't have to say a word to him.

Agree Paul but then again, we think he has heart and is a good teammate, so what do we know?

[tywright]

I'm not trying to be snarky at all, but what exactly does a retaliatory plunk accomplish to make it more valuable than giving up a run or losing a game?

Is this purely a matter of team morale? (i.e.- we got each other's back)

you may very well be right. this is just something i feel like i've never really understood.

It's for team morale, sticking up for your teammates, and letting the other team know that we aren't going to take it. All in all, it's about respect. This team is not going to break by losing one game, but it will if we lose team morale and support.

[RShack]

I disagree with this. It's completely within Bedard's nature to stick up for his teammates. From what I hear, he's always been known as a stand-up teammate and is well-liked in the clubhouse. He saw the same things we did last night, and he knew exactly what to do about it.

My bet is that Trembley didn't have to say a word to him.

You could be right. As I said, I was reading that into it.

I have no doubt that Erik is a stand-up teammate who is well-liked, and I never meant to imply otherwise. I was just unaware that this translated into him throwing at guys in such circumstances. Not saying it never happened, only that I don't know about it...

[Pedro Cerrano]

This should be over. Just to echo what everyone said, there was really no doubt about it. A fastball, right at the knee, to the Yankee superstar.

Hopefully they won't be plunking any of our guys (unless it's Bako -- PLEASE plunk Bako!) and this will be the end of it.

[beaner]

Good...Hit the perfect guy.

Agreed, A Rod's a baby and would have cried about it for days...Jeter understands he's the face of the team and he can handle it.