Proposed trade?

[EMoMoney]

I was given a trade proposal.
I get Tory Holt and Frank Gore
I give up Reggie Wayne and Joseph Addai.

Would anybody make this trade?

[Tank]

I would....

[DuffMan]

Gore is much better than Addai and you never know what you're going to get from Wideouts so I would take this trade in a heartbeat.

[Mackus]

Addai and Gore are pretty much equals, I had Gore ranked #3 overall and Addai #4 on draft day. Holt is probably a tad better than Wayne, although its close.

You're pretty much trading the #4 pick and a mid-second rounder for the #3 pick and a late-2nd or early 3rd round pick.

Pretty even trade, just depends on who you like better.

[Pedro Cerrano]

Addai and Gore are pretty much equals, I had Gore ranked #3 overall and Addai #4 on draft day. Holt is probably a tad better than Wayne, although its close.

You're pretty much trading the #4 pick and a mid-second rounder for the #3 pick and a late-2nd or early 3rd round pick.

Pretty even trade, just depends on who you like better.

Nahhh.

Especially when you consider injuries Wayne > Holt.

Gore is about equal to Addai I will agree with that.

Pass.