Unless you are a doctor or can cite any studies ruling out any long term effect of chemo on high level athletes I would say that question is not settled at all. We know that he was able to come back and put up a 1 WAR season at the low end of his career floor/ceiling, nothing more.
So most of the post mortem in this thread is talking about the Humphrey injury, the defense giving up points late, Lamar struggling. ALL true.
But there's not a single word about the fact that this game was lost at the line of scrimmage. They had 7 sacks, about 15 QB hurries.
I'm not making excuses for Lamar, he has made some terrible throws and decisions. But we are getting destroyed up front and he is under constant pressure. Chris Wormley had more sacks for Pittsburgh yesterday than he did in his entire Raven career.
You can't talk about this game for 9 pages without at least mentioning the fact that the biggest factor is that we can't create a pocket for our QB.
But that information doesn't speak to things such as age and overall health. Mancini, I'm assuming, would be in the 99th percentile for someone who's overall health would help him in a fight against cancer.
55+ and overweight? Yes, I'd believe those numbers. But for someone who's in 29 and excellent physical condition to start with, I think Mancini's odds are better.
I have a lot of experience with loved ones having cancer. Once it gets to the lymph system it is very dangerous and unpredictable. Here is what a quick search on the internet says:
Stage III colon cancers have spread to nearby lymph nodes, but they have not yet spread to other parts of the body. Surgery to remove the section of the colon with the cancer (partial colectomy) along with nearby lymph nodes, followed by adjuvant chemo is the standard treatment for this stage.
A stage III colon cancer has about a 40 percent chance of cure.
What Frobby has done twice is ignore Trey's cancer. I don't think any GM can do that.
Losing Humphrey might be one too many injuries to overcome, but honestly, I thought he took a step back this year. He's looked a step slow most of the year and we all know he's not a play maker when it comes to interceptions. Still, he was the guy they really could not afford to lose due to the thin amount of talent at corner this year for the Ravens after all the injuries.
Tony Lombardi at RSR is on point in his wrap of yesterday's game.
Harbaugh brought up a good point about going over zero and blitzing too much ("going to the well one too many times") and that's a good point. When you look at the Diontae Johnson 29 yard TD reception, it was a simple rub crossing play but with no safety out there, it was a simple run and catch. What in the world Brandon Stephens was doing on this play is beyond me. Also, why blitz a QB that has traditionally been very good against the blitz?