Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Rojo13

If only Elias hadn't traded the 11th best player in baseball (Bundy) for next to nothing

Recommended Posts

12 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

And btw, no, Duq wasn’t a very good GM for us.

But his hands were also tied, so it’s tough to really grade him.

He wasn't Branch Rickey, but Oriole playoff appearances per GM since 1999:

Elias: 0
Duquette: 3
McPhail: 0
Beattie-Flanagan: 0
Thrift: 0
Wren: 0

I guess you could give them all F's, except Duquette a C and Elias an incomplete.  But I have a hard time being as down on Duquette (and Showalter) as others here are.  Under them the O's played the only meaningful games of the past 22 years.

  • Upvote 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/8/2020 at 3:21 AM, wildcard said:

Dan Duquette was a good GM for the O's.  There is that what you are looking for?   Dan had a tough job.   Peter Angelos was not easy to work for and did not give Dan a free hand to do what he wanted.   Peter sometimes directed player signings.  And Buck didn't not report to Dan.  Buck could go around Dan any time he wanted to the owner.   So the two butted heads at times.  It was a different time and a different organizational structure and in spite of that Dan was Executive of the Year in 2014 for getting the O's deep into the playoffs.

Elias acknowledges that many of the players now with the O's where drafted by Dan.  Elias is not trying to take credit for that.   However Dan never had the  player development system that Elias has built nor the analytics.    That is probably not Dan's fault because the money went for players not infrastructure under Peter Angelos.  But acknowledge what Elias is doing.

I am happy for Dylan Bundy but trading him was the right thing to do in a rebuild.  Dylan's fastball was 96+ in his early years.  Injuries took there toll.  His fastball now averages 90 now according to Brook Baseball.  He is not same pitcher he was and probably not good match for Camden Yards and its 318 down the right field line and 365 to left center.  Angels Park is 350 down the right field line and 390 to left center.  Most of the other parks in the AL East are small also.

Dylan pitched 5 times at home.  Twice in Oakland and once Seattle.  All much larger parks than in the AL East.  And in those 8 starts Dylan has given up 4 homers.   In 2018 for the O's Dylan gave up 41 homers in 31 games.  Its hard to win that way.

And I don't know how you can say that Dylan was traded for nothing.   Maybe your scouting ability is really good but three of the players received were 22 and 23 years old.  Elias puts them into his player development system and who knows how good they will be.  I think Elias probably scouted some of those players for the draft.

So Dan was good, Elias is good and Dylan is doing well.  And all is right with the world.

Excellent well thought out post. 

I wanted to highlight what I feel is the major difference in the Duquette regime (and use that loosely because of the things you mentioned in you post which were spot on) and Elias regime. The development system with the high speed cameras and analytics is already bearing fruit with guys like Akin, Kremer and Mountcastle and we also have to look at the improvements of guys like Severino. 

Akin and Kremer are both working in the upper portions of the strike zones with their high spin rate four seamers and although it's just one start, the Orioles looked like they took away Kremer's awful changeup and replaced it with a cutter. Akin looks like he ditched his curveball and has gone to just a three-pitch mix and his changeup has improved to the point it looks like his best offspeed pitch similar to Means.

I'm betting a lot of this is based off the information they were getting off those cameras and analytics and that is huge difference.

I'm on record that I think Duquette was good as certain aspects of being a GM and I think we also have to give some credit to Gary Rajsich who drafted a lot of this talent that we see arriving (Akin, Mountcastle, Harvey, Hays) and having success with more in the pipeline (Rodriguez, Hall, Lowther, Rom, AHall).

As for the Bundy trade, I think Elias took the gamble that Bundy was at his highest value with his price tag increasing. We obviously still don't know what the Orioles have really received in the 4 pitchers acquired for him, but I don't think I would have any in the top 20 prospects and that's a little disappointing. 

You brought up a good point about the parks he's been pitching in and Anaheim is much better than Camden Yards for him as well, so it's doubtful he would be putting up the same numbers. 

His pitch selection has moved more slider heavy which started last year as well with the Orioles, but it's not like his stuff took a huge step forward.

I'm not going to say Elias gave Bundy away until we see how the pitchers he acquired develop and even if he did, there's not a ton of evidence that suggests he would put up the numbers he's putting up this year pitching in Camden Yards and against the AL and NL East teams.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

He wasn't Branch Rickey, but Oriole playoff appearances per GM since 1999:

Elias: 0
Duquette: 3
McPhail: 0
Beattie-Flanagan: 0
Thrift: 0
Wren: 0

I guess you could give them all F's, except Duquette a C and Elias an incomplete.  But I have a hard time being as down on Duquette (and Showalter) as others here are.  Under them the O's played the only meaningful games of the past 22 years.

This is about where I am.  DD wasn't perfect but he and Buck presided over the only good teams in this century.  

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

He wasn't Branch Rickey, but Oriole playoff appearances per GM since 1999:

Elias: 0
Duquette: 3
McPhail: 0
Beattie-Flanagan: 0
Thrift: 0
Wren: 0

I guess you could give them all F's, except Duquette a C and Elias an incomplete.  But I have a hard time being as down on Duquette (and Showalter) as others here are.  Under them the O's played the only meaningful games of the past 22 years.

As I always say "Actions speak louder than words." That can be twisted into "Results speak louder than opinions." 

Duquette had his hands tied in ways that no other Orioles GM has probably ever had when you add in Showalter and then the Brady situation. Before the Toronto situation basically neutered him, he was building a consistent winner. Who know what happens after the 2014 season and if that never goes down?

Saying that, I'm glad Elias is here now and has installed the technology and analytics while putting a new found emphasis on international scouting and signings that was never done under the Duquette regime.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

He wasn't Branch Rickey, but Oriole playoff appearances per GM since 1999:

Elias: 0
Duquette: 3
McPhail: 0
Beattie-Flanagan: 0
Thrift: 0
Wren: 0

I guess you could give them all F's, except Duquette a C and Elias an incomplete.  But I have a hard time being as down on Duquette (and Showalter) as others here are.  Under them the O's played the only meaningful games of the past 22 years.

I’m of the opinion that MacPhail and Buck had more to do with that run than Duq.

I don’t think Duq was bad..but I wouldn’t call him very good either.  I think he was ok but ok wasn’t that bad considering his hands were tied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

I’m of the opinion that MacPhail and Buck had more to do with that run than Duq.

I don’t think Duq was bad..but I wouldn’t call him very good either.  I think he was ok but ok wasn’t that bad considering his hands were tied.

You can have that opinion of course, but we've beaten this thing into the ground for years here. DD rebuilt the starting staff and brought in many players for the team to take that jump forward. Was Buck a big part of this, sure. Was MacPhail's trades, especially the Bedard trade that brought Adam Jones and Chris Tillman part of it, sure. 

Regardless, the guy in charge at the time gets the credit just like they take the blame when things go bad. Duquette had as much or more to do with the winning rosters than any of the other two. 

Regardless, that's all water under the bridge. I think we're all happy Elias is doing his thing here now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Natty said:

Wasn't it DD who let Nelson Cruz get away? 

The guy that let him walk in exchange for a first round pick?  Sure. 

Just wish he had done the same with Davis and Trumbo.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Natty said:

Wasn't it DD who let Nelson Cruz get away? 

Counterpoint, he was also the guy who signed Nelson Cruz when nobody else would take his agent's phone call. Stroke of genius and 2014 would not have happened without it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Tony-OH said:

You can have that opinion of course, but we've beaten this thing into the ground for years here. DD rebuilt the starting staff and brought in many players for the team to take that jump forward. Was Buck a big part of this, sure. Was MacPhail's trades, especially the Bedard trade that brought Adam Jones and Chris Tillman part of it, sure. 

Regardless, the guy in charge at the time gets the credit just like they take the blame when things go bad. Duquette had as much or more to do with the winning rosters than any of the other two. 

Regardless, that's all water under the bridge. I think we're all happy Elias is doing his thing here now.

I think you win with Your core talent and that core talent was mostly brought in from AM.

But Duq did a good job of supplementing that talent with the limited resources he had to work with.  He put them over the top, talent wise...Buck molded and guided those teams and the culture around the team undoubtedly changed once Buck got here.  That was pretty huge.

I was never an AM fan and I’m still not but I do credit him for giving us many of the members of the core of those teams.

But yes, give me Elias over all of them.  He has going in the direction that I don’t believe any of them had us going in.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Natty said:

Wasn't it DD who let Nelson Cruz get away? 

 

2 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

The guy that let him walk in exchange for a first round pick?  Sure. 

Just wish he had done the same with Davis and Trumbo.

 

 

1 minute ago, Aristotelian said:

Counterpoint, he was also the guy who signed Nelson Cruz when nobody else would take his agent's phone call. Stroke of genius and 2014 would not have happened without it. 

Yes, this is another dead-horse convo here... but letting Cruz walk with a QO was viewed as the right move at the time and it's justifiable-at-worst even in retrospect.

Recent PED-user with a career year on the wrong side of 30 on a cheap 1-year deal... let someone else pay him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

I’m of the opinion that MacPhail and Buck had more to do with that run than Duq.

I don’t think Duq was bad..but I wouldn’t call him very good either.  I think he was ok but ok wasn’t that bad considering his hands were tied.

MacPhail gets some credit, but he was unwilling to do any number of things that Duquette did that pushed them over the top.  I think Duquette's strength was finding those Weaver-like underutilized assets, and getting Buck to properly deploy them.  They got the last good 500 at bats out of Nate McLouth, they got Steve Pearce and 100 solid ABs out of Jim Thome, and built an amazing bullpen out of random guys like Jim Johnson and Luis Ayala and O'Day and Strop and Patton and Britton.

MacPhail was very passive, not very creative.  His hands were tied like all the other GMs, and his reaction was to fall back on the draft and hope it worked out.  That's an over-simplification, but he was very conservative.  Right down to the sweater!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Natty said:

Wasn't it DD who let Nelson Cruz get away? 

That was an awesome move.  Nobody in their right mind would sign a 34-year-old DH to a four-year guaranteed contract.  Do you really want another Ryan Howard, Chris Davis, Pablo Sandoval situation?  That's what happens the vast majority of the time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, CallMeBrooksie said:

 

 

Yes, this is another dead-horse convo here... but letting Cruz walk with a QO was viewed as the right move at the time and it's justifiable-at-worst even in retrospect.

Recent PED-user with a career year on the wrong side of 30 on a cheap 1-year deal... let someone else pay him.

16.2 rWAR/15.2 fWAR to go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores
News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2020 Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2020 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats






  • Posts

    • This is where we will track significant activity throughout spring training. This will be updated with cuts and additional players acquired throughout the spring. Starters John Means  (3/1) Will make his spring debut tomorrow against the Yankees and lines up for the Opening Day start on April 1st Keegan Akin (3/1) Healthy and will need to pitch himself off this team Dean Kremer (3/1) Healthy will need to pitch himself off this team Jorge López (3/1) Allowed two runs in two innings of work on five hits and walk. needed 47 pitches to get through two innings. For some reason though the Orioles are giving him every opportunity to win a spot in the rotation.  Felix Hernandez (NRI) (3/1) Reportedly looks a little heavy but is healthy and will be given every opportunity to win a spot in the rotation. Matt Harvey (NRI) (3/1) Hasn't pitched well in the majors since 2018 and was hammered last year in Kansas City. His lost spin on his stuff but will be given an opportunity to win a spot in the rotation or possibly in the pen. Wade LeBlanc (NRI) (3/1) Brought back despite tossing just one good start last year. Changeup pitcher who can provide some depth in the bullpen or as a swingman if needed. Bruce Zimmermann (3/1) If he pitches well he could be in the rotation. Ashton Goudeau (3/1) Reportedly has looked pretty good in camp so far but hasn't had any success over AAA. Thomas Eshelman (NRI) (2/28) Lunch bucket guy got the spring opener but allowed two runs, one earned on a hit and two walks.  Michael Baumann (3/1) Heading for AAA, Baumann could be one of the first starters brought up if needed assuming he's healthy and pitching well. Zac Lowther (3/1) Heading for AAA, but pitched out of some trouble in spring debut allowing two base runners but no runs. Fastball sat 88-91 and his threw five changeups out of his 14 pitches. Alexander Wells (2/28) Heading to AAA eventually, reportedly has an oblique injury for the second straight spring and will be held back Josh Rogers (NRI) (2/28) Allowed one run in one inning in spring debut. Mickey Jannis (NRI) Konner Wade (NRI) Spenser Watkins (NRI) (2/28) Tossed a scoreless 9th against minor leaguers. Relievers Hunter Harvey Tanner Scott Cesar Valdez Dillon Tate Paul Fry Shawn Armstrong (3/1) Down 1.3 MPH off his 2020 velocity, Armstrong allowed a two-run homer in his one inning of work.  Travis Lakins Sr. Cole Sulser Isaac Mattson (2/28) Allowed a home run and walked two in his Orioles spring debut. Mac Sceroler (3/1) Rule 5 pick made his spring debut and worked his way out of bases loaded jam. Walked two and allowed a single, needing 28 pitches to get through his frame against mostly minor leaguers. He sat 92-94 mph with fastball and showed a hard curve that he varied from 78-84 MPH but it didn't have a ton of break. Just one outing, but nothing stood out stuff wise as a guy you have to keep. Tyler Wells (3/1) Rule 5 pick made his debut as well tossing one scoreless innings allowing a walk. His fastball sat 93.7  to  95.4 MPH but didn't show a ton of life. He did get one swing and miss on his fastball up in the zone and recorded a strikeout on a curveball looking against a minor leaguer. With his size and fastball curveball combination he could be interesting in relief. Conner Greene (NRI) 2/28 - Struck out two of the three batters he faced and reportedly hit 97 MPH. That will open some eyes. Marcos Diplán (NRI)  2/28 - Tossed a scoreless innings of relief. Fernando Abad (NRI) (2/28) Brought in the game in the 2nd inning to face major leaguers, pitched his way out of a jam allowing two hits and walk but not a run. Cody Carroll (NRI) Evan Phillips (NRI) Eric Hanhold (NRI)  (2/28) Pitched the 3rd inning against major leaguers and allowed two runs, one earned on two hits including a home run in his innings of work. Jay Flaa (NRI) Zach Muckenhirn (NRI) Dusten Knight (NRI)   Catchers Pedro Severino (3/1) Odds on favorite to start most of the games at catcher this year. Chance Sisco (3/1) Typically a spring training phenom, he's looking to get more opportunities this season. Austin Wynns (NRI) (2/28) Needs an injury to make the team but is probably first up behind the dish. Taylor Davis (NRI) (3/1) Lunch bucket guy who can catch and play some first base Heading to AAA. Nick Ciuffo (NRI) (3/1) Former top prospect trying to refind it with the Orioles. Good defensive catcher who has never hit. Adley Rutschman (NRI) 3/1 Here to catch pitchers and soak in the majors until he's reassigned. Most likely will start in Aberdeen or Bowie. 1st Base Trey Mancini (2/28) Got a standing ovation before his first at bat and then singled sharply. Chris Davis (2/28) Got the start at DH, struck out in one his ABs and went 0-for-2. Tyler Nevin  (3/1) Got the start at 1B and went 0-for-2. Ryan Ripken (NRI)  (2/28) Lost his grandmother Vi. RIP to the Matriarch of the Ripken family. Went 0-for-2 with 2 Ks. 2nd Base Yolmer Sanchez (2/28) Got the start at 2B and went 0-for1 with a walk. Should get the bulk of playing time at 2B this year. Jamai Jones (2/28) Came in for Sanchez and went 0-for-2. Probably heading to AAA to play everyday. Ramón Urías (3/1) Got start at 2B, Went 0-for-3 but did hit the ball hard one time. Terrin Vavra (NRI) (3/1) May get a look in the outfield as well as 2B and SS. Heading to Bowie to start 2021. Adam Hall (NRI) (2/28) Will be heading to Aberdeen to start the year most likely though he cold get pushed to AA if he gets off to good start.   Shortstop Freddie Galvis (2/28) Went 0-for-1 with a walk, K, and made a fielding error. Pat Valaika (3/1) Started at SS and went 1-for-2 with a walk. Will most likely be the team's utility player filling in all over the infield. Richie Martin (2/28) Will get late start do to having surgery on a broken hamate bone in his left hand. Was heading to AAA anyways. Mason McCoy (NRI) (2/28) Heading to AAA most likely but will be added infield depth this spring. Jordan Westburg (NRI) (3/1) Will get a little taste and instruction before heading to the minors for his first minor league season. Gunnar Henderson (NRI) (3/1) The young star of the the alternate site last year gets his first taste of big league camp. Third Base Rio Ruiz (3/1) Goes in as the odds on favorite to win the 3B job. Went 0-for-3 with two Ks. Rylan Bannon (2/28) Got the opening day spring training start at 3B going 0-for-2 with a walk and a K. Seth Mejias-Brean (NRI) (2/28) With some major league experience in SD, he'll have an opportunity to win the 3B job with a good spring. Most likely heading to Norfolk unless he breaks out and Ruiz struggles badly. Outfield Ryan Mountcastle  (3/1) Going to be the opening day LF. Went 0-for-2 with a sac fly in his debut. Also lost a ball in the sun on the warning track that turned an out into a ground rule double. Austin Hays (3/1) Going to be the opening day CF most likely though in theory Cedric Mullins is his competition.  Went 2-for-2 in his spring debut. Anthony Santander (2/28) Going to be the opening day RF.  Went 0-for-2 with a K in his spring debut. Cedric Mullins (2/28) Most likely going to be the 4th outfielder on this team. Gave up batting right-handed to focus on batting left-handed. Should get some ABs against tough righties, spelling Hays and Mountcastle. Went 1-for-3 in his spring debut playing CF. Made a throwing error though. DJ Stewart (3/1) Has the inside track on being the everyday DH. Went 1-for-3 with a long home run to right field in his spring debut. Yusniel Diaz (2/28) Crushed a two-run home run  in the 6th and drew a walk going 1-for-3 overall. Heading to AAA but if he puts up numbers there don't be surprised to see him in Baltimore at some point in 2021. Ryan McKenna (2/28) Heading for AAA, in theory he's in the running for 4th outfielder but the Orioles probably want him to play everyday in AAA. Walked in his only PA in the spring opener. Chris Shaw (NRI) (2/28) Though he's also a 1B, word is the Orioles will try him mostly in the outfield at Norfolk. Steve Wilkerson (NRI) (3/1) More of a utility, his ability to play CF could make him a 4th outfielder at AAA Norfolk. Heston Kjerstad (NRI) (2/28) First round pick last year has yet to show up to camp. Mike Elias said Kjerstad was sidelined due to “an episode of myocarditis,” a viral infection that causes inflammation of the heart muscle and will report late.   
    • Ravens and Jackson far apart in negotiations?   https://www.bostonglobe.com/2021/02/27/sports/latest-buzz-nfl-quarterback-market/
    • Just wanted to bump this if anyone is interested. 
    • He'll still catch his share of games.
    • Is the book closed on him being a C?
    • Good thing they don’t play basketball.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...