Jump to content
Diehard_O's_Fan

MLB and Union talk major rule changes

Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, atomic said:

The rules need to be changed so the plan doesn't work anymore.  It is bad for the game.  Attendance is down around the league and will keep going down with more teams doing this.  And if half the league tries to lose  on purpose the Astro's plan won't even work anymore. 

What team’s coaches are actively trying to lose in baseball? What you’re talking about is changes at the organizational level and I’m against any change that limits a team’s self-determination.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Manfred.  Seems to have ruining the game as his number one goal. Almost everything he has proposed has made the game worse, and there are a lot of things we could do that would make the game better.  Among other things, we have become accustomed to challenges, but I think we’re still aware of how ridiculous they are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Ripken said:

I certainly think they should unify the DH rule to both leagues or neither.  26th man makes a lot of sense.  Single trade deadline would be better.  20 second pitch clock is good.

I wouldn't change the mound.  I would not change the draft as suggested though I support allowing the trade of draft picks (like every other sport).  You really can't have a min batter rule IMO.  For what it's worth I don't care where the 7 fielders stand either, i.e., learn to adjust to the shift.

Yeah I am against outlawing the shift.  The guys bothered by the shift are the same guys who make the game incredibly boring.  These are the same guys who strike out close to 200 times a season.

One change that would make the game a lot more interesting but would never happen.  Make it a foul ball when you hit the ball over the fence in fair territory.  No more home runs.  It would eliminate guys like Trumbo and Davis.  And you would have more hits and less strike outs. Like I said they would never let that happen but really there should be some way to get rid of the guys who strike out constantly have no speed and try for a home run at every at bat. I think WAR over values such players and I think analytic departments are getting wise to the overvaluation of them. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Diehard_O's_Fan said:

I absolutely love the thought of having a DH in the National League. That sure would make inter league play more fair for American League teams. It is also a safety thing when you have a pitcher batting for the first time in a year. There have been countless pitchers that have got hurt during inter league play.

On paper I do too, but I really hate what the DH position has become. In the AL it's basically a wasteland for aging veterans and players who can't play the field. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, wildbillhiccup said:

On paper I do too, but I really hate what the DH position has become. In the AL it's basically a wasteland for aging veterans and players who can't play the field. 

The DH was an abortion when it was introduced and continues today.  

  • Downvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, ExileAngelos said:

The DH was an abortion when it was introduced and continues today.  

They should eliminate the DH.  If you aren't good enough to play the field you shouldn't be playing the game.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, atomic said:

Yeah I am against outlawing the shift.  The guys bothered by the shift are the same guys who make the game incredibly boring.  These are the same guys who strike out close to 200 times a season.

One change that would make the game a lot more interesting but would never happen.  Make it a foul ball when you hit the ball over the fence in fair territory.  No more home runs.  It would eliminate guys like Trumbo and Davis.  And you would have more hits and less strike outs. Like I said they would never let that happen but really there should be some way to get rid of the guys who strike out constantly have no speed and try for a home run at every at bat. I think WAR over values such players and I think analytic departments are getting wise to the overvaluation of them. 

As you said though, if the goal is to get rid of one trick ponies like Davis, teams adjust their thinking and stop overvaluing (or valuing at all) those guys.  The problems solves itself.  The though ties in with the DH discussion too, since the DH is a big reason to have those guys in the first place

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, atomic said:

They should eliminate the DH.  If you aren't good enough to play the field you shouldn't be playing the game.  

So you are okay with great pitchers that can only pitch and field, and bat something like .118 at the plate?

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, wildbillhiccup said:

On paper I do too, but I really hate what the DH position has become. In the AL it's basically a wasteland for aging veterans and players who can't play the field. 

Yeah I don't understand the DH at all. If you don't want the pitcher to bat why not just have only 8 batters. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never liked the DH.  Further, if all pitchers have to hit, you would probably see a little more time given to that skill and might get their collective value at the plate up some.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Ripken said:

As you said though, if the goal is to get rid of one trick ponies like Davis, teams adjust their thinking and stop overvaluing (or valuing at all) those guys.  The problems solves itself.  The though ties in with the DH discussion too, since the DH is a big reason to have those guys in the first place

When Davis was an all-star, he was far from a one trick pony.

He played plus defense at first and could really stretch out to catch the incoming throw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Redskins Rick said:

When Davis was an all-star, he was far from a one trick pony.

He played plus defense at first and could really stretch out to catch the incoming throw.

Talking about Davis now and the other all-or-nothing guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Redskins Rick said:

So you are okay with great pitchers that can only pitch and field, and bat something like .118 at the plate?

That is the trade-off.   And that's a team decisions.  There are some good hitting pitchers.  I think if pitchers batted in the minor leagues they probably would hit a little bit better in the majors.  But there is no reason you can't play your poor defending, good hitting player in the field.  It will cost you in the defense category and you will have to decide if it is worth it to your team.  

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores

News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2018 End of Season Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2019 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats







  • Posts

    • Why not. Eddie started at DH. 
    • I'll make this simple.  Here's a list of everyone in MLB history who's caught at least 1500 games.  There's only 33 of them.  Name the 20 who you think are better than Gary Carter.                                                                                                                                                                                               Rk            Player    G From   To   Age    PA   AB    R    H  2B 3B  HR  RBI  BB IBB   SO HBP  SH  SF GDP  SB CS   BA  OBP  SLG  OPS         Pos                                          Tm 1     Ivan Rodriguez 2543 1991 2011 19-39 10270 9592 1354 2844 572 51 311 1332 513  67 1474  58  31  76 337 127 64 .296 .334 .464 .798     *2H/D34                     TEX-FLA-DET-NYY-HOU-WSN 2       Carlton Fisk 2499 1969 1993 21-45  9853 8756 1276 2356 421 47 376 1330 849 105 1386 143  26  79 204 128 58 .269 .341 .457 .797    *2DH/735                                     BOS-CHW 3        Ted Simmons 2456 1968 1988 18-38  9685 8680 1074 2472 483 47 248 1389 855 188  694  39  11 100 287  21 33 .285 .348 .437 .785   *2DH3/759                                 STL-MIL-ATL 4        Gary Carter 2296 1974 1992 20-38  9019 7971 1025 2092 371 31 324 1225 848 106  997  68  33  99 180  39 42 .262 .335 .439 .773    *2H9/375                             MON-NYM-SFG-LAD 5          Bob Boone 2264 1972 1990 24-42  8148 7245  679 1838 303 26 105  826 663  90  608  20 142  78 191  38 50 .254 .315 .346 .661    *2/H35D7                                 PHI-CAL-KCR 6       Johnny Bench 2158 1967 1983 19-35  8674 7658 1091 2048 381 24 389 1376 891 135 1278  19  11  90 201  68 43 .267 .342 .476 .817   *253H/798                                         CIN 7         Yogi Berra 2120 1946 1965 21-40  8359 7555 1175 2150 321 49 358 1430 704  91  414  52   9  44 146  30 26 .285 .348 .482 .830    *2H79/35                                     NYY-NYM 8      Jason Kendall 2085 1996 2010 22-36  8702 7627 1030 2195 394 35  75  744 721  51  686 254  36  63 176 189 89 .288 .366 .378 .744     *2/H79D                         PIT-OAK-CHC-MIL-KCR 9    A.J. Pierzynski 2059 1998 2016 21-39  7815 7290  807 2043 407 24 188  909 308  68  895 129  28  58 241  15 23 .280 .319 .420 .739       *2H/D                 MIN-SFG-CHW-TEX-STL-BOS-ATL 10    Gabby Hartnett 1990 1922 1941 21-40  7297 6432  867 1912 396 64 236 1179 703   1  697  35     127  93  28  8 .297 .370 .489 .858       *2H/3                                     CHC-NYG 11         Tony Pena 1988 1980 1997 23-40  7073 6489  667 1687 298 27 107  708 455  72  846  23  68  38 234  80 63 .260 .309 .364 .673    *2/H39D5                     PIT-STL-BOS-CLE-HOU-CHW 12     Lance Parrish 1988 1977 1995 21-39  7797 7067  856 1782 305 27 324 1070 612  62 1527  37  23  58 197  28 37 .252 .313 .440 .753    *2D/H397                 DET-PHI-CAL-SEA-CLE-PIT-TOR 13     Yadier Molina 1983 2004 2019 21-36  7655 6970  701 1963 379  7 156  916 507  49  782  66  42  70 254  66 37 .282 .333 .405 .738     *2/3HD5                                         STL 14   Benito Santiago 1978 1986 2005 21-40  7516 6951  755 1830 323 41 217  920 430  52 1270  38  26  70 204  91 69 .263 .307 .415 .722     *2H/37D         SDP-FLA-PHI-TOR-CHC-CIN-SFG-KCR-PIT 15       Brad Ausmus 1971 1993 2010 24-41  7102 6279  718 1579 270 34  80  607 634  69 1034  69  82  37 201 102 53 .251 .325 .344 .669    *2/H3456                             SDP-HOU-DET-LAD 16      Jim Sundberg 1962 1974 1989 23-38  6899 6021  621 1493 243 36  95  624 699  31  963  22 118  38 159  20 37 .248 .327 .348 .674      *2/H7D                             TEX-MIL-KCR-CHC 17          Al Lopez 1950 1928 1947 19-38  6608 5916  613 1547 206 43  51  652 556  55  538  14     121 137  46  9 .261 .326 .337 .663     *2/H543                             BRO-BSN-PIT-CLE 18       Mike Piazza 1912 1992 2007 23-38  7745 6911 1048 2127 344  8 427 1335 759 146 1113  30   0  45 229  17 20 .308 .377 .545 .922      *2DH/3                         LAD-FLA-NYM-SDP-OAK 19      Rick Ferrell 1884 1929 1947 23-41  7076 6028  687 1692 324 45  28  734 931  23  277  10     103  55  29 35 .281 .378 .363 .741        *2/H                                 SLB-BOS-WSH 20    Ernie Lombardi 1853 1931 1947 23-39  6352 5855  601 1792 277 27 190  990 430  50  262  46      18 261   8  4 .306 .358 .460 .818         *2H                             BRO-CIN-BSN-NYG 21      Jorge Posada 1829 1995 2011 23-39  7150 6092  900 1664 379 10 275 1065 936  78 1453  74   1  47 186  20 21 .273 .374 .474 .848     *2DH/34                                         NYY 22       Bill Dickey 1789 1928 1946 21-39  7065 6300  930 1969 343 72 202 1209 678  26  289  31      51  49  36 32 .313 .382 .486 .868         *2H                                         NYY 23    Darrell Porter 1782 1971 1987 19-35  6570 5539  765 1369 237 48 188  826 905 106 1025  45  18  63 102  39 37 .247 .354 .409 .763      *2HD/3                             MIL-KCR-STL-TEX 24    Deacon McGuire 1781 1884 1912 20-48  6938 6291  770 1750 300 79  45  840     515  442  84          47 118  0 .278 .341 .372 .713 *2/395678H1 TOL-DTN-PHI-CLE-ROC-WAS-WHS-BRO-DET-NYY-BOS 25      Bill Freehan 1774 1961 1976 19-34  6900 6073  706 1591 241 35 200  758 626  67  753 114  38  48 138  24 21 .262 .340 .412 .752    *23/HD79                                         DET 26      Rick Dempsey 1765 1969 1992 19-42  5407 4692  525 1093 223 12  96  471 592  13  736  18  63  42 131  20 19 .233 .319 .347 .666  *2H/D97315                     MIN-NYY-BAL-CLE-LAD-MIL 27        Ray Schalk 1762 1912 1929 19-36  6240 5306  579 1345 199 49  11  593     638  358  59         214 177 69 .253 .340 .316 .656        *2/H                                     CHW-NYG 28      Brian McCann 1755 2005 2019 21-35  6850 6067  742 1590 294  5 282 1018 640  71 1054  75   9  59 180  25  9 .262 .337 .452 .789      *2H/D3                                 NYY-HOU-ATL 29      Sherm Lollar 1752 1946 1963 21-38  6220 5351  623 1415 244 14 155  808 671  68  453 115  47  34 184  20 10 .264 .357 .402 .759      *2H/35                             CLE-NYY-SLB-CHW 30    Russell Martin 1693 2006 2019 23-36  6648 5701  803 1416 255  9 191  771 792  46 1211 107  12  36 190 101 51 .248 .349 .397 .746 *2/H5D41679                             LAD-NYY-PIT-TOR 31         Jim Hegan 1666 1941 1960 20-39  5321 4772  550 1087 187 46  92  525 456  79  742   4  72  14 113  15 24 .228 .295 .344 .639        *2/H                         CLE-DET-SFG-PHI-CHC 32       Luke Sewell 1630 1921 1942 20-41  6043 5383  653 1393 272 56  20  698 486   0  307  27     145   1  66 44 .259 .323 .341 .665   *2/H39745                             CLE-WSH-CHW-SLB 33      Steve ONeill 1590 1911 1928 19-36  5566 4795  448 1259 248 34  13  534     592  414  43         130  30 26 .263 .349 .337 .685       *2/H3                             CLE-BOS-NYY-SLB  
    • Yeah the WAR components are available, but it’s not like you can easily calculate those yourself.   I mean, the BB-ref player page will show you Rbat, Rpos, Rfield, Rbaser etc., but I certainly couldn’t derive those numbers.    
    • Frankly I don’t remember reading a single negative thing about his personality or any clubhouse issues during his stint with the Orioles.    I don’t see that as a risk at all.   We’re talking about bringing a guy in on a minor league deal to compete for a spot held by Stevie (.669 OPS, -0.8 rWAR) Wilkerson and for which Richard Urena also will compete.    It’s not like we’re expecting him to be a starting infielder, or paying him millions of dollars, or using a spot on our 40-man roster until such time, if any, as he makes the major league team.   It’s simply not a very big deal.      
    • I'm unconvinced.  He's taking one year's worth of data and not really doing any comparisons to anyone else.  He's inferring from the fact that the 2018 Red Sox hit well with runners on second that the entire sign stealing scheme was worth 50 runs.  That's a stretch.  Teams have varying performances in splits every single year.  From '11-14 the Orioles had a mid-700s OPS with runners on 2nd.  From '15-17 they were in the mid-800s.  Did they have a sign stealing scheme going starting in '15? What he should do is look at 10 years of data across all teams in the league and see if the 2018 Red Sox' variation in performance is a big outlier or unremarkable.  
    • There are plenty of athletes/high draft picks that never ban out. There's also a very fine line between confidence and arrogance. The Beckham quotes I've read paint him an arrogant ego maniac and "me first" type of player. Also, let's not forget his was also suspended for 50 games in 2012 for testing positive for marijuana. Why would we want to bring that kind of mojo into our clubhouse? 
    • If you swing at balls in the dirt and take pitches right down the middle , then this has to be one of the few cases where size does not in fact matter. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...