Jump to content
RVAOsFan

Ryan Mountcastle 2019

Recommended Posts

On 7/5/2019 at 6:07 AM, RZNJ said:

This idea that Mountcastle is "mashing" in AAA is laughable.  He was 35th in OPS last time I checked.  No comparison to another player is going to determine his future.  School actually had similar BB:K ratio in AAA but he played at 21.  He also had 1:2 ratio overall as opposed to 1:4 (1:7 this year) for RM.  School has a .740 career OPS but also added some defensive value which RM is unlikely to. How about Adam Jones who played AAA at 21/22 and put up a 967 OPS good for 4th in the PCL.  His ratio was 1:3 that year.  His career OPS is .780 but he also played a key defensive position.  Schoop and Jones plate discipline numbers didn't noticeably improve in the majors.  Just because Mountcastle is hitting .300 in AAA this year is no reason to suspect he'll hit .300 in the majors.  On the contrary, I think you'll see his BA take a significant nosedive and his OPS and OBP along with it.   His home run and RBI numbers are nice but if you look a little deeper it doesn't bode well.

Thank you. I don't want to see Mountcastle at all in 2019. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like the conversation about Mountcastle is almost too binary. My concern isn't that he'll come to the majors and be a scrub, it's just that I don't think he'll come to the majors and become an all-league player. I don't know how the scouting types characterize what I'm thinking, but I'm basically predicting he'll be a C+/B- type of player. He won't have a ton of positional value. His hit tool will be advanced, but his strike zone management will limit his OPS upside. I'll be happy to have in on the field, but don't expect any top 10 MVP seasons even at his peak. He'll essentially be Renato Nunez with a higher BA and maybe a little higher OBP, as driven by BA.

I like that player, but I'm not going to over value it. That's why I'm not bullish on him in prospect rankings even though I do like his production. If you use Tony's criteria of who I'd rather have in the org, I think it would actually sink him even farther because I think his profile is relatively easy to replace. Just see Mancini, Nunez and Trumbo, when healthy for somewhat comparable guys.

 

[Edit: I should add that his profile really does improve for me if he can be an above average OFer. In that case, you start to compare him to a guy like Diaz and weigh the pros/cons of each w/r/t rankings.]

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, MurphDogg said:

Mountcastle hit his 17th homer today, but no walks and he struck out once so we should probably release him. 😂

 

I can't wait for OH to complain that he doesn't take walks just like they did with AJ. 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, MDtransplant757 said:

I can't wait for OH to complain that he doesn't take walks just like they did with AJ. 

The complaints about Mountcastle’s walk rate started on page two of this thread, and were in conjunction with his being named the International League Player of the Week. I’d bet drachmas to Danish pastries that you can find critiques of his walk rate in plenty of prior threads besides.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will point out his walk rate forever. It’s the difference between a #2/3 hitter and a #6/7 on a good team. I’ll take a home grown #6/7 hitter any day and twice on Sunday, but that and his lack of position temper enthusiasm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, MDtransplant757 said:

I can't wait for OH to complain that he doesn't take walks just like they did with AJ. 

They’re already doing it.    

Truth is, Mountcastle walks less than AJ did, and he’s got less room  than AJ for those kinds of flaws since he doesn’t play a premium defensive position.    

  • Upvote 1
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Frobby said:

They’re already doing it.    

Truth is, Mountcastle walks less than AJ did, and he’s got less room  than AJ for those kinds of flaws since he doesn’t play a premium defensive position.    

Adam Jones was a six time all star.  I don’t think Mountcastle has to be as good as Adam Jones to be a productive player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, atomic said:

Adam Jones was a six time all star.  I don’t think Mountcastle has to be as good as Adam Jones to be a productive player.

My point is, an .800ish CF is an all star.   An .800ish 1B/DH is a guy who’s just a so-so player.    And I’m hoping for more than that from Mountcastle, but his lack of plate discipline may limit him to that.    

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Frobby said:

My point is, an .800ish CF is an all star.   An .800ish 1B/DH is a guy who’s just a so-so player.    And I’m hoping for more than that from Mountcastle, but his lack of plate discipline may limit him to that.    

I know this is the standard line that you really need to mash to be an important contributor at first base, but there are very few players who can be viewed in that way. Just checked the 2019 first basemen and there are only 6-7 guys I’d call real difference makers (Bell, Freeman, Alonso, Hoskins, Rizzo, Santana, Muncy) who are all OPSing north of .880. The next group of guys are Vogelbach, Voit and Christian Walker, all of whom two years ago you’d assume were nothing more than filler and could just as easily disappear into obscurity next season. 

After that, the rest of the league has what we’d then call a so-so player. This isn’t a golden age of power hitting first basemen maulers. If Mountcastle produces 6-8 years of .800-.850 OPS, he’d be in the top 10 first basemen in baseball and I’d happily sign on for that. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys are always looking for perfect players. There are only a few truly complete players. I think it’s fine to discuss prospects and their flaws but some posters take it way too far and constantly beat them up. I usually just ignore their posts. I am very much looking forward to seeing RM succeed in ML

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/19/2019 at 10:01 AM, Frobby said:

They’re already doing it.    

Truth is, Mountcastle walks less than AJ did, and he’s got less room  than AJ for those kinds of flaws since he doesn’t play a premium defensive position.    

Adam Jones had a 7.1% walk rate and Jonathan Schoop had a 7.8% walk rate in the minors. Mountcastle has a career walk rate of 4.4%. Jones and Schoop are two of the more impatient hitters the Orioles have had in recent years yet their walk rate in the minors was still significantly higher than Mountcastle's current walk rate. Plus Mountcastle has a 20% strikeout rate for his career. How many players struck out four and a half times as often as they walked in the minors and went on to be a successful major league hitter? i bet that list is very short. There are a lot of red signs about his offensive skills translating to the majors. 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, WalkWithElias said:

I know this is the standard line that you really need to mash to be an important contributor at first base, but there are very few players who can be viewed in that way. Just checked the 2019 first basemen and there are only 6-7 guys I’d call real difference makers (Bell, Freeman, Alonso, Hoskins, Rizzo, Santana, Muncy) who are all OPSing north of .880. The next group of guys are Vogelbach, Voit and Christian Walker, all of whom two years ago you’d assume were nothing more than filler and could just as easily disappear into obscurity next season. 

After that, the rest of the league has what we’d then call a so-so player. This isn’t a golden age of power hitting first basemen maulers. If Mountcastle produces 6-8 years of .800-.850 OPS, he’d be in the top 10 first basemen in baseball and I’d happily sign on for that. 

 

I would sign up for that as well.  I think we need to see significant improvement before I would expect those kinds of results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, TINSTAAPP said:

Adam Jones had a 7.1% walk rate and Jonathan Schoop had a 7.8% walk rate in the minors. Mountcastle has a career walk rate of 4.4%. Jones and Schoop are two of the more impatient hitters the Orioles have had in recent years yet their walk rate in the minors was still significantly higher than Mountcastle's current walk rate. Plus Mountcastle has a 20% strikeout rate for his career. How many players struck out four and a half times as often as they walked in the minors and went on to be a successful major league hitter? i bet that list is very short. There are a lot of red signs about his offensive skills translating to the majors. 

Two of the most impatient hitters are future Oriole HOFers, all stars, and centerpieces to the most successful teams the franchise has put forward in two decades. 

Its so weird we’ve moved from bashing some of our best players for not being perfect to bashing our best prospects by comparing them to our former best players. Very meta. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 105 Guests (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores
News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2018 End of Season Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2019 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats






  • Posts

    • Hey Tony, in the What-if dept., what about resigning Markakis and Cruz after 2014 to extend the window for real... Did you try that, or take the opposite course and rebuild for real, sooner than 2018? (Thus either way, avoiding that unspeakable alternate timeline that we witnessed in 2016)?
    • Rick Dempsey (claim to fame being a few doubles and a dinger, one October)
    • I “taped” that game due to work.  Turned it on when I got home, and thought, “Wow! That was masterful!”  Kept the tape for years, and watched it at least a half dozen times.  (I wouldn’t be surprised to find out I still have the tape somewhere.  Wonder how I would play it?). One for the ages!
    • I spent a decade listening to Chuck Thompson and three listening to Vin Scully.  No regrets.
    • From that thread Frobby brought back up with some additions since that was about the highest level: I was always a pretty good player through T-ball, Little league and Pony league (13-15) always making the year end all-star team for Riviera Beach. I do however have a few highlights that I remember. As a 12-year old, I was traded from the Yankees (i hated playing on the Yankees but that was team that "drafted me" outta 8-9 ball) to the Red Sox because I was mostly a catcher and the kid they trade me for was mostly a pitcher. The first time we face the Yankees was on a beautiful spring Saturday morning because my Dad always made my weekend games. The coach told me he wanted me to start against my former team and against the kid I was traded for. My Dad warmed me up and I went out to the mound. My issues with pitching had nothing to do with velocity since I always had a good arm, but had to do with throwing strikes. Well on this day, with the manager who traded me watching, I was going to throw the best game of my young life. From what I remember we got behind 2-0 going into the bottom of the 5th (we played 6 inning games) when we came up to bat. With two outs, I came to bat with two runners on. Using my Dan Ford closed stance, I connected with a fastball that sent the ball to deep left. As I looked out to left, I could see the ball sail over the fence and land a good 20 feet behind near the money bars. It was my only home run of the year and it was sweet. I crushed it. It didn't just land over the fence, it landed by the monkey bars and had to have been the longest ball I ever had hit in my 12 years on earth. As all the parents and my teammates erupted, I went into a home run trot. I enjoyed every step of that trot and when I got to third base, I shook my coaches hand and then picked up the manager who traded me. He sat there at the end of that bench with his scorecard in his hand not wanting to look up. He finally did and I smiled at him and for second there, I thought he even slightly smiled back. I ended up pitching the 6th without giving up a run and we won 3-2.  The next year, I was told I was drafted with the 1st overall pick outta 10-12 league by the Phillies because I was catcher and the Phillies had the best pitcher in the league Karl Breitenbacher. Everyone was scared to catch Karl because he could throw in the mid 80s as a 14-year old, but I wasn't, in fact, I loved the challenge. Though I had my successes including hitting about .600 as a 15-year old, probably my biggest moment had to do with catching Karl. Karl threw so hard that one of our umpires was scared of him and I was told he closed his eyes and then would see where I caught the ball. During one game, with two outs, the bases loaded, and a 3-2 count, Karl threw an 80MPH+ fastball that was so high I had to jump up and catch the ball above my head, but in the same movement I dropped back down and landed in my squat and presented a strike. The umpire opened his eyes, yelle strike 3, as the parents and coaches on the other team erupted in displeasure. I tossed the ball back to the mound and sprinted back to my bench where my coach high-fived me. In high school, I played for the great Harry Lentz and Al Kohlhafer at Northeast High school. I played JV my freshmen year, playing mostly catcher, but also some outfield and occasionally filled in at 3B or 2B if needed. I had always been able to play all the positions, but never had consistent enough hands to play the infield.  This reminds me of a funny story as a sophomore. That year I was competing for the CF job since there was a senior All-county catcher named Mark Rich. One day during practice before the season started, Coach Lents yelled out to CF, "Pente, where doe the best athlete on the team play?" I yelled back, "SS, coach". He responded with, "then what are you doing out there?" My assumption was he wanted to see me get more ground balls there as they were trying to see if I could help the varsity team in some role. So i went over to SS and made a couple of nice plays including some great throws, but then I started to boot balls left and right as my poor infield hands reared their ugly head. That's when Coach Yelled back out, "Pente, get your ass back in the outfield" "Ok, coach" And that was extent of my high school shortstop career. That year with a Freshman catcher (who ended up playing in the Braves farm system for a short period of time) coming up, I moved out to the outfield basically full-time. As a senior, I ended up getting 2nd team All-county (after a slow start) and earning a special pre draft workout with the Kansas City Royals after a game in which i went 3-4 with a double and home run while throwing two runners out at the plate from RF. Long story short on this, I accidentally missed the camp when I got my dates mixed up. After high school I joined the Army, but kept playing. I first played in a summer college league in Virginia (Hit well over .450 and played SS/CF/P) when I was 20 and ended up going to an Orioles tryout camp at Memorial Stadium. During that camp I made the cut from 90 outfielders to six that got to play in the mini game in front of the scouts. On the first pitch I saw in the game hit a ball into the front row of the outfield fence just next to the 309 ft foul pole, but unfortunately it was on the foul side. I ended up striking out when they replaced that pitcher with Mike Mussina's roommate from Stanford. I was asked to come back to a camp a few weeks later and was told if they liked me then they would offer me a contract, but I wasn't able to attend because the same day Saddam Hussein decided to invade Kuwait and I became very busy and couldn't get off. I then put together my own team for a Baltimore-area Men's League (MSBL) in which we won the championship in my one and only year of being a player-manager in that league. I then was stationed in Hawaii where I played in summer and winter leagues with winter leagues being a league where we played against college teams and minor leaguers in their offseason. The Hawaii armed forces decided to put together a baseball tournament and I made the All Army Hawaii team that lost to the all Air Force team in the finals. Funny thing was the All-Air Force team then put a team in that local winter league and they asked me to try out and gave me a waiver because I worked on an Air Force base. So I get to say I was the guy to ever be All-Army Hawaii and All Air-Force Hawaii.  Got stationed in NC and didn't play for almost four year when I was assigned back to Maryland and found an Anne Arundel Men's 25 and over team to play for. Played on two teams then got stationed back to Hawaii. Didn't have time to play right away, but after returning from Afghanistan, I played on two more teams (with my new PRK eyes that were fixed by the Army before deployment I could hit better than ever). I also started doing associate scouting from the Orioles out there at this time. Returned back to Maryland and after a year or two found a team in the 35 and over AA Men's League. After playing a year I put together my own team and we won the championship (that's two for two in managing championship teams if you are counting). Team broke up after the year (you have never seen politics until you deal with a men's baseball league) and I filled in some new players with the guys that stayed and we ended up making the playoffs again, but lost in the semi-finals (Making the first time I coached a team that I played on that we didn't win a championship). After that year, fed up with the politics, my hitting had fallen off to the point I was batting myself 8th (think I hit like .250 with wood bats), and I wanted to focus on coaching high school and doing associate scouting stuff for an American League team, I "retired from playing. Surprisingly, I don't miss it. I've come out of retirement two times to fill in for a team that needed a player so bad or they were going to forfeit, but after pulling my hamstring in my last game, it was clear father time had claimed another victim. And if read this far, now you know way to much history of my playing days! Haha
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...