Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Frobby

SI ranks the O’s the 4th most hopeless team

Recommended Posts

23 minutes ago, Frobby said:

Having now read the full article, SI took the average between BA (8) and Fangraphs (14).     Seems reasonable to me.    

Never been a big fan of Fangraphs.   Didn't like their defensive metrics for years and now Mejdal is telling us they were never that actuate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, wildcard said:

Never been a big fan of Fangraphs.   Didn't like their defensive metrics for years and now Mejdal is telling us they were never that actuate.

Neither are BB-ref’s.    So I guess I’ll stop using those two sites.    🙄

In any event, advanced defensive metrics aren’t part of Fangraphs’ farm rankings, so it’s irrelevant.   The rankings are done by two guys who do the scouting for Fangraphs, one of whom is a former scout for the Orioles, Braves and other teams.    And their methodology for ranking them is much more systematic than BA’s.    I’m not saying I put more credence in their rankings than BA’s, just that I consider them a credible source and have no problem with SI’s methodology of taking the average of the two.    I’ll just add that the couple of other midseason rankings I’ve seen were not as high as BA’s and not as low as Fangraphs’.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regardless of the outlet, I can't see where they are wrong.

I'm not an expert, but I would take a wager that 2022 will not be their year for October baseball unless MLB drags regular season games out until then. 

I think they will have to trade some of the current younger MiL players in a few years to continue rebuilding. I hope my opinion is proven wrong and things go smoothly but I don't see it.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, maybenxtyr said:

Regardless of the outlet, I can't see where they are wrong.

I'm not an expert, but I would take a wager that 2022 will not be their year for October baseball unless MLB drags regular season games out until then. 

I think they will have to trade some of the current younger MiL players in a few years to continue rebuilding. I hope my opinion is proven wrong and things go smoothly but I don't see it.

I agree it will be tough to reach the postseason by then.    I think we’ll have a better idea at the end of next season how far away we really are.    

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Frobby said:

And others have ranked it 14.    The article says their average ranking is 11.    That’s in the middle third which is fairly called middling.    Even if you prefer the BA ranking, they’re in the second quartile, which is good not great.    Combine that with a 50ish win big league team and that still leaves them with a long way to go and needing a lot of things to go right.   

You’re all sunshine and roses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, maybenxtyr said:

Regardless of the outlet, I can't see where they are wrong.

I'm not an expert, but I would take a wager that 2022 will not be their year for October baseball unless MLB drags regular season games out until then. 

I think they will have to trade some of the current younger MiL players in a few years to continue rebuilding. I hope my opinion is proven wrong and things go smoothly but I don't see it.

I don't think the Os are a lock for 2022 post-season, but I think folks simply look mostly at the minor league system and can't figure out a playoff team from those parts.  Our payroll will have reset payroll at a very low base after 2021 and there is plenty of free agent opportunity to ramp up payroll to get several strong plus pitchers or a strong plus pitcher and a big time hitter.  I think that between Hall, Lowther, Akin, Baumann, Wells, Kremer and Zimmerman plus Means would have we could have a 2, 4, and 5 for the starting rotation at cheap prices and GrayRod on the verge of the majors.  Trade for or sign a top pitcher and suddenly a large portion of the SP looks league average or better.

On the hitting side, I also think we have perhaps several quality cheap players in AR, Mountcastle, Hays, Diaz plus we shall see how Stewart, Hall might complement Mancini, Santander and others.  

I think the core of a competitive team could be in place at the major level if supplemented by some key free agent signings to make a plus offense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, wildcard said:

Never been a big fan of Fangraphs.   Didn't like their defensive metrics for years and now Mejdal is telling us they were never that actuate.

All sources of information are flawed.  That's why I rely solely on witchcraft.

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, hoosiers said:

I don't think the Os are a lock for 2022 post-season, but I think folks simply look mostly at the minor league system and can't figure out a playoff team from those parts. 

Even a team with ridiculous payroll constraints like the Rays doesn't develop all their talent.  They acquire a good bit from other sources.  No team just promotes their own minor leaguers and fully fills out the roster that way.  No matter how things go the 2022 Orioles roster will be at least half made up of players not currently in the organization.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isn't hopefulness about the future? What does our current record, roster, or stats have to do with hope? If they admit we have the #11 farm system we should certainly be at least top 20 in hopefulness for the future.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
55 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

Even a team with ridiculous payroll constraints like the Rays doesn't develop all their talent.  They acquire a good bit from other sources.  No team just promotes their own minor leaguers and fully fills out the roster that way.  No matter how things go the 2022 Orioles roster will be at least half made up of players not currently in the organization.

I agree there will be roster turnover and trades and players picked up from other organizations which is also why, given our respectable farm system and payroll capacity in 2022 and the likelihood of having top five or better available spend in the draft and internationally in 2020, I have to question those who think we will not be competitive entering 2022. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, hoosiers said:

I don't think the Os are a lock for 2022 post-season, but I think folks simply look mostly at the minor league system and can't figure out a playoff team from those parts.  Our payroll will have reset payroll at a very low base after 2021 and there is plenty of free agent opportunity to ramp up payroll to get several strong plus pitchers or a strong plus pitcher and a big time hitter.  I think that between Hall, Lowther, Akin, Baumann, Wells, Kremer and Zimmerman plus Means would have we could have a 2, 4, and 5 for the starting rotation at cheap prices and GrayRod on the verge of the majors.  Trade for or sign a top pitcher and suddenly a large portion of the SP looks league average or better.

On the hitting side, I also think we have perhaps several quality cheap players in AR, Mountcastle, Hays, Diaz plus we shall see how Stewart, Hall might complement Mancini, Santander and others.  

I think the core of a competitive team could be in place at the major level if supplemented by some key free agent signings to make a plus offense.

I agree with this.    It really boils down to how well and how quickly our prospects are developing.    If they are making big strides, then investing in some significant free agents by 2022 will make sense.    If they are either floundering or just moving up more slowly than hoped, it may be premature to spend a lot in the FA market.    We’ll just have to see.    

I think we’ll know a lot more about the players you mentioned at this time next year.    I think 2020 will be fascinating from a developmental perspective.   

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Frobby said:

Neither are BB-ref’s.    So I guess I’ll stop using those two sites.    🙄

In any event, advanced defensive metrics aren’t part of Fangraphs’ farm rankings, so it’s irrelevant.   The rankings are done by two guys who do the scouting for Fangraphs, one of whom is a former scout for the Orioles, Braves and other teams.    And their methodology for ranking them is much more systematic than BA’s.    I’m not saying I put more credence in their rankings than BA’s, just that I consider them a credible source and have no problem with SI’s methodology of taking the average of the two.    I’ll just add that the couple of other midseason rankings I’ve seen were not as high as BA’s and not as low as Fangraphs’.

I like both of those sites myself. I'd be very disappointed if today's "modern front office" only had the data supplied by this quasi crowd sourced projects. I suspect that the real data won't be in our hands to play with until it too is outmoded. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, hoosiers said:

I agree there will be roster turnover and trades and players picked up from other organizations which is also why, given our respectable farm system and payroll capacity in 2022 and the likelihood of having top five or better available spend in the draft and internationally in 2020, I have to question those who think we will not be competitive entering 2022. 

I think it's a possibility they'll be competitive in two years, but far from certain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores
News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2018 End of Season Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2019 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats






  • Posts

    • The latest mock from Jonathan Mayo... https://www.mlb.com/news/mlb-mock-draft-june-3?t=mlb-pipeline-coverage    
    • I'll be back because...well, I love baseball.  I love the Orioles.  I really can't imagine MLB being played and not paying attention on some dumb principle that I have against the players and the owners because they're both spoiled assholes.  You can't get mad at water for being wet.   That said... God #@$%ING DAMMIT.  @#%& every last one of them.  MLB just...never gets it right.  The most painful thing in all of this is that they had a chance to lead.  They had a chance to be the first pro sports league to get it together this summer, to come up with a plan to get back to playing and be the first ones on stage Nascar doesn't count, you can't prove me wrong with NO OTHER COMPETITION.  MLB, the sport with the oldest, fart-knockingist fanbase.  MLB, the sport that always seems to lag behind other sports in...just about everything.  MLB, the sport with the dumbest marketing where they try SO HARD TO BE COOL AND RELEVANT.  They had such a prime opportunity to be front stage and center.  No NBA, no NFL and no NHL.  They had an opportunity to be leaders, to show the other leagues how it's done and the opportunity for starved sports fan to see what a great game it can be.  THEY HAD A CHANCE TO HAVE A COMPLETELY CAPTIVE AUDIENCE. And they blew it.   The NBA made it back first, which is not surprising.  In the NBA, you get players that make a metric $%#*ton of money and are also hyper aware and concerned with defining their legacy.  LeBron James is chomping at the bit to get back on the court because he knows this might be the best/last time he can contend for a title and if he wins it, it'd add to his legacy.  You get a guy like Giannis who is obsessed with knocking him off.  Meanwhile, in the MLB you get guys like Snell and Harper who are sitting around bitching about money.  You get the feeling that if someone told Harper this year he would bat .400 but would have to play for free to do it, he wouldn't think twice about sitting out instead of doing something that hasn't been done since 1941 and might not ever happen again.  If someone told Snell he could break Bob Gibson's ERA record for a season or strike out 384 batters this year but not make any money doing so, he'd flip you the bird and sit around and play video games.  World Series?  Forget it, they would just view it as extra work.  I think LeBron would play for free the rest of this summer if he thought he had a chance at another title. I'm not sure where the NHL is in regards to restarting their season because it's...the NHL.  But it wouldn't surprise me if they got their act together and figured out a way to finish, it certainly looks like they're trying harder. And you know the NFL is going to play come hell or high water.  The NFL will not miss a week.  They will start on time.  Because they all know there's too much on the line and that by the end of this summer that people will look to their league as something that can bring people together and help them heal.  People will go ballistic if the NFL start date gets pushed back or if games are missed.  But baseball not happening is seemingly being met with apathy from the general sports fanbase.   @#$% you, MLB.  I'm not saying @#$% you forever, but for right now in this very moment, @#$% you.  @#$% you for being so far behind in everything.  @#$% you for being the last sport to make a statement on George Floyd, only doing so because people noticed you didn't and they called you out on it.  @#$% you players, @#$% you owners, @#$% you all.  @#$% you for not seizing a golden opportunity when you had one because you can't see past your stupid @#$%ing paychecks and your dumbass collective bargaining agreement.  @#$% you for not being able to put your differences aside to be able to play in a time where your fellow countrymen would love nothing more than to watch a game and forget about a pandemic and civil unrest.  @#$% you for not being there when we actually needed you.
    • This came up on my suggestions. Pretty good cover by some youngsters.  
    • Scores high as being personable and well spoken!   Was also interesting during the “Texas History Quiz”, when he and Millar were asked to name one of the seven Texas born Hall of Famers,  he quickly answered “ Nolan Ryan” (natch) but when neither he nor Millar came up with a second quickly, Chris Rose read the rest.   Frank Robinson was one of them, to which Lacy commented  “ I did not realize Frank Robinson was born in Texas”. (Almost like .... how did I miss that when studying up on the Orioles.... 🤔!)
    • This brings up a definitional question... is a five tool guy someone who is outstanding in each area or someone who is average-or-better (at MLB level). The latter may be more how it’s used for prospect evaluation, whereas the former is more from a historical look-back. 
    • Yes, but I would hardly call it a stadium. I can't believe that pro players played there. Its small for legion ball.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...