Jump to content
Frobby

Favorite all-time Orioles utility player?

Recommended Posts

Roch wrote a piece on Stevie Wilkerson today, and at the end he asked who is your all-time favorite Orioles utility player.   https://www.masnsports.com/school-of-roch/2019/10/wilkerson-prepared-to-work-with-new-outfield-instructor.html

I’m leaving Melvin Mora out of this, since he eventually settled in as the regular 3B for quite a few years.    But he was a helluva utility player while in that role.   
 

My vote would go to Chico Salmon.   I’m not saying he was the best utility guy we ever had, just that I liked him the best.    He was a high energy guy who always had a smile on his face.   He had a great year in 1969, batting .297/.375/.451 while starting 3 games at 1B, 8 at 2B, 6 at SS, and 1 at 3B.    He also subbed in 20 games and pinch hit in 16 (with some overlap there).    His career went downhill after that, with his OPS and playing time dropping significantly each year, but I still remember him fondly.   

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jeff Reboulet.

Maybe was not the best utility man the Birds have had in my lifetime, but definitely my favorite. I will always remember how he used to own Randy Johnson.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, Redskins Rick said:

Lynn Sakata for catching that famous game back in Orioles History. :)

Ryan Flaherty was for me a pretty good super utility player

Has to be Sakata.

If we expand it to bench players, I think Geronimo Berroa was an extremely underrated piece of the '98 club.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Aristotelian said:

Has to be Sakata.

If we expand it to bench players, I think Geronimo Berroa was an extremely underrated piece of the '98 club.

I also very fond of Floyd "Sugar Bear" Rayford back in his time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, JourneyFan said:

Would Jeff Conine be too much of a stretch? If not, him. Otherwise, Flaherty.

Way too much of a stretch, he played over 100 games every season he was here. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, Redskins Rick said:

Way too much of a stretch, he played over 100 games every season he was here. 

I didn't take games played into consideration, just the fact that he manned a few different positions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, JourneyFan said:

I didn't take games played into consideration, just the fact that he manned a few different positions.

In my mind, you have to play some 2B or SS to be considered a utility guy.   

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

o

 

Merv Rettenmund.

My Orioles fandom began when I was a 6 year-old boy, in first grade in October of 1971. Growing up in Brewster, NY, it was pretty unusual for a kid to adapt the Orioles as his favorite team, but I did. The Orioles were playing the Pirates in the World Series. I remember the last two games of the series (Game 6 and Game 7.) My whole family was rooting for the Pirates because they liked Roberto Clemente, so naturally, I rooted for the Orioles. After the final groundout to end Game Seven which give the Pirates the series, my whole family whooped it up in the living room, and I went outside, put my face in my hands, and pouted on the swing-set in our back yard up here in Brewster, NY.

I later found out that the player who grounded out for that final out of Game Seven (and I remember it vividly) was Merv Rettenmund.

 

o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, OFFNY said:

o

 

Merv Rettenmund.

My Orioles fandom began when I was a 6 year-old boy, in first grade in October of 1971. Growing up in Brewster, NY, it was pretty unusual for a kid to adapt the Orioles as his favorite team, but I did. The Orioles were playing the Pirates in the World Series. I remember the last two games of the series (Game 6 and Game 7.) My whole family was rooting for the Pirates because they liked Roberto Clemente, so naturally, I rooted for the Orioles. After the final groundout to end Game Seven which give the Pirates the series, my whole family whooped it up in the living room, and I went outside, put my face in my hands, and pouted on the swing-set in our back yard up here in Brewster, NY.

I later found out that the player who grounded out for that final out of Game Seven (and I remember it vividly) was Merv Rettenmund.

 

o

Good choice.  Merv was a pure hitter - though not much of an OFer. 

Clemente blew me away as a RFer in that WS when I was 10.  Here's a clip of the best way to run the bases against Roberto:  https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=Roberto+Clemente+Greatest+Plays&&view=detail&mid=A14ACCF8E842A4606D25A14ACCF8E842A4606D25&rvsmid=13F38E1CB16C586FDD8013F38E1CB16C586FDD80&FORM=VDQVAP

Don't ever test his arm.  He was simply the best. 

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores
News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2018 End of Season Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2019 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats






  • Posts

    • The Orioles will have no issues with the 40 man as most of their players don't belong on it in the first place. So if you lose a player big deal by putting him through the 40 man it is no big deal. And you can put guys on the 45 day IL easily enough.  The season is only 60 games. So if anyone gets injured 45 day IL here they come. 
    • I am not going to load 100 pages to see them all. But seems the guy was just using stats to define who is bad.  Defensive stats aren't that accurate.  I would say guys like Mark Reynolds and David Kingman belong on that list.  I hated the way Kingman would play but he seems the norm of a lot of players these days.  Sad the way the sport has become.   
    • For the Orioles and I am sure for other teams. Because its hard to know how many COVID cases there will be along with how many injuries, I think teams will want to hold on to as many players as they can.   Not DFAing very many players at least to begin the season.   Each team being able to hold onto 60 players makes that easier.   This also is reenforce by the fact that players that are taken off the 60 man roster must be DFA'd.  Its easier to add then subtract players from that stand point. The O's will probably add LeBlanc and Milone to the 40 man roster before the season begins.   The open 40 man spot and Mancini going on the 45 day IL will be spots used that make that possible. Passed that the only player I see now that may be DFA'd is Urias.  He has not been added to the 60 man roster yet and there are several utility infielders ahead of him.  So adding one more player to the 40 man roster will be fairly easy if that happens. Passed that the O's have to lose a player from the 40 to add a player to the 40. That makes it harder for the O's to add Eshelman, Hanhold, Shepherd, Kline, Valdez, Blach, Zastryzny, Holaday, Herrera, Valaika, or Wilkerson because they are not on the 40 man roster.  This will be true  of  several of the 15 players that are add to the 60 man roster. Catchers, I think are particularly precious commodities.   They will be close to the batters, the umpires and will touch the balls thrown by the pitchers.  Their risk of contracting COVID may be higher than other players.   Therefore DFAing Wynns to make room on the roster seems unlikely. Currently the only outfielders on the 40 that are active and on the 60 man roster are Hays and Stewart.   Velazquez is  likely to see time in the outfield to begin the season if Santander and Smith are not cleared to play.   Mullins, who is probably one of the 15 players added  and may also see time  initially because he is on the 40 man roster.    Wilkerson is not. The O's focus on the future probably keeps Mountcastle off the 30 man roster for a week or two.  But I would think because he is on the 40 man roster he is likely to see a lot of time in the outfield after that if Santander and Smith are not available. As the season moves on I would expect to see the 45 day IL to be used quite a bit because players moved to that list do not count against the 40 man roster. That will open spots to look at other players.   Those a some of my thoughts about player movement.   What do you think?   
    • From the pages of the Baltimore American on July 8th, 1894: INKS STOPPED THE REDS __________________________ HIS SLOW DROPS MYSTIFIED COMISKEY'S BRAVES __________________________ Meanwhile the Orioles Hammered Pitcher Parrett, Winning Out Quite Easily - Another Sensational Catch by Keeler, Boston Again Defeats Cleveland - Pittsburg Shut Out by Phillies __________________________ [Special to the American] Cincinnati, O., July 7. - Baltimore broke the Reds' winning streak today, stopping them at eleven straight victories.  The Orioles flitted from base to base with great rapidity during the greater part of the game, to the merry accompaniment of rattling hits.  Most of the Cincinnati's roosted disconsolately on first, while they watched the Monumental City gentlemen wading knee deep in the gore of slaughtered hits. Smith was spiked last Thursday, and today his foot was swollen so badly that he could not leave his bed.  Farmer Vaughn was put in at short, and played his position in true agricultural style.  He was not alone, however.  Latham wallowed in errors, while McPhee and Murphy each contributed his mite towards welling the total of Baltimore's runs.  Three thousand eight hundred and thirty-two roosters looked gloomily on, and had never a chance to give vent to their bottled-up enthusiasm.  Keeler killed an incipient rally in the fifth inning by an even more wonderful catch than that of Thursday.  That catch cut short a certain home run, and disheartened the Reds.  Inks had no speed at all, and the Reds, who have been pounding swift pitchers for the past fortnight, could not gauge the Baltimorean's leisurely incurves. ... (Later on in the fifth) Parrott waited for a good ball, and when it came he smote it on the nose.  The crowd rose and cheered as the ball whistled through the air on a bee-line for the right-field seats.  Just as it was about to go over the fence Keeler flung himself into the air and stuck up one paw, which, to the eye of the startled spectators, looked about as large as a ham.  When he came down he had the ball. ...   Lineups: Baltimore McGraw, 3b Keeler, rf Brodie, cf Brouthers, 1b Kelley, lf Reitz, 2b Jennings, ss Clarke, c Inks, p Cincinnati Latham, 3b Hoy, cf Holliday, lf McPhee, 2b Vaughn, ss Canavan, rf Parrott, p Comiskey, 1b Murphy, c ______________ Baltimore... 2  2  1  3  1  0  0  1  1 - 11 Cincinnati...0  1  0  0  1  0  0  0  0 -  2
    • I know some will say the Orioles went cheap, but I think they had their eyes on a couple of guys that would have taken more to sign and then they got taken before their pick.  I haven't seen what the guys before Kjerstad signed for so it's hard for me to say what they could have had. Honestly, I like the idea of a left-handed power hitting right fielder and there was no better left-handed power (according to most draft experts) than Kjerstad.  I wanted Asa Lacy, but I did not do enough pre draft home work to really have a strong opinion one way or the other.
    • The Orioles had him at 175, but still, he's thin and could put on some good weight and perhaps throw harder.
    • What a horrific article.  If you want to call it that.  If you clicked all the way to the end you deserve some kind of perverse medal for enduring pain for no apparent reason. And it's interesting to note that there were no terrible defenders prior to about 1995.  Or at least not among the catchers and a few first basemen, which is as far as I got. (In reality almost all of the worst MLB defenders of all time would have played over 100 years ago.) Also, with any list of worst Major Leaguers there should be a huge caveat: these are the worst defensive players who were allowed to play this position in the major leagues after having been selected as one of the very best overall players in youth baseball, high school, college and the minors.  Except for maybe the guys at first and left field, they were all chosen by their teams to play this position despite the option of moving them down to an easier position or DHing them, meaning that their team's assessment of their abilities was that playing them there was better for the team than doing something else.  The teams that played Ed Taubensee or Ryan Doumit at catcher were doing so because they believed that was the most productive alignment of their teams. For example, Jason Giambi would have been dozens of runs worse than the worst actual shortstop per season, if he'd been allowed to play shortstop.  Jim Palmer would likely have been the worst fielding second baseman in baseball, far below anyone on this list.  Mark Trumbo is probably a -60 CFer.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...