4 years? 1+option remaining years on rookie deal plus 2 franchise tags? IMO franchising him twice is a non starter. Thats a cap hit the size of mount everest. If you want to keep him that long you might as well just extend him now. I think you're looking at something like 3/90+ with a full cap hit each year for the option year + 2 franchise years.
Its just the nature of the Rule 5, but I feel like the fact he didn't get to try to be Eastern League MVP in 2017, or International League MVP in 2018 is nothing about him.
As we're feeling good this week about an international class finally, Santander's bio hits me adjacent to that. I don't know all his details inside and out but imagine he must have been signed around 16 or 17 if by the end of Age 21 season he was already Rule 5 eligible. Its like we have a winner from the J2 class 8-9 years ago.
Here's hoping in four years we don't have roster space for some Carolina League All-Star from this week.
I think people are going too far on the “plus defense” aspect of things personally.
But sure, if he can play plus defense and slug 480-520, he is definitely valuable. Him being valuable isn’t really the question. It’s how valuable is he.