Jump to content
LookinUp

Heyman: Braves kicking tires on Mancini

Recommended Posts

We got my son a Mancini jersey for Christmas, so it would check out that he would be traded prior to Opening Day.

I hope he stays with the club.  I get the cold-blooded nature of this, always have, but you couldn't ask for a better guy than Mancini to be a face of your franchise.  The return would probably need to be more than reasonable for me to want to trade him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, glenn__davis said:

We got my son a Mancini jersey for Christmas, so it would check out that he would be traded prior to Opening Day.

I hope he stays with the club.  I get the cold-blooded nature of this, always have, but you couldn't ask for a better guy than Mancini to be a face of your franchise.  The return would probably need to be more than reasonable for me to want to trade him.

I mean, objectively speaking I think Davis has the superior face.

chris-davis-orioles.png

9374abf5-6a8a-4543-adea-17766374e503-lar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I’m skeptical anything comes of this. The O’s are unlikely to just give him away yet the Braves are unlikely to give anything of value for a player coming off cancer. Probably just Braves seeing how desperate we are to cut costs. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we're punting 2022, getting Trey to a better team is a kindness.

I certainly picture him here working off the rust this year, and hopefully with health being back to some kind of plus for a better 2022 team.  

Kjerstad has some catching up to do, but it isn't inconceivable sometime NEXT summer RMC/Hays/Kjerstad/Santander/Diaz can all outplay him for that 5/9ths of the lineup.

Like Cruz/Ozuna, you kind of imagine his market value floats some depending how NL DH turns out.

Good Trey could get himself some numbers inheriting that Donaldson/Ozuna seat behind Acuna/Albies/Freeman, but then there's the whole getting non-tendered thing.

I think this and Santander is more teams trying to squeeze the Rosario, Pederson and DuValls of the world.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do think they should look to trade him at the deadline or next offseason if he has a bounceback year as he will be a free agent after 2022 and I don't think the O's will aim to be competitive until 2023. There is no way that they could get reasonable value at this point and the PR hit would be huge. Also it is better for him to get back to baseball here where he is comfortable and not have the added pressure of adjusting to a new team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Can_of_corn said:

Unless the plan is to keep AR in the minors until 2023.  😉

I hope not that would be moronic, you are just wasting his prime  years as a catcher. You know then he wouldn't come up until May at age 25 at that point, so his first full season would be 26. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, andrewochs615 said:

I hope not that would be moronic, you are just wasting his prime  years as a catcher. You know then he wouldn't come up until May at age 25 at that point, so his first full season would be 26. 

He shouldn't start his decline until after the O's trade him in his arb 2 season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

 

26UKf3q.jpg

I don’t see how I’m wrong? The Braves are going to try to use Mancini’s illness as a lever to give less than if he were healthy, regardless of whether it’s really an issue or not.

It may be stating the obvious, but nobody else had stated it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, wildcard said:

He not playing 1B for the Braves...Freddie Freeman.   There is no DH in the NL.   That puts him in the OF.    

Agreed, but he does play first base for us.  And it's not like he's an above average outfielder.  So his value is limited either way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Braves  have a bunch of young OFers that make more sense than Mancini - starting with Pache and Waters.  Braves probably don't trade for him unless O's basically give him away.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



Orioles Information


Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores
News

Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2021 Minor League Depth Chart

2021 Prospect Power Rankings

2020 Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports

Statistics

2020 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats






  • Posts

    • I was there. It’s hard for me to tell how he looked without the zoomed in camera from centerfield that we see on TV. There was a lot of hard hit contact. He was pretty lucky to get out of 3 innings with only 1 earned run, although the error that led to an unearned run was his own, on a pickoff attempt. I never take the rehab outings’ results too seriously unless there’s like obviously a command/velocity problem due to a lagging injury. 
    • Right..his bat isn’t good enough for the OF and we have a lot of options there long term.  He has zero future as a LFer.  He is either a second baseman or a UTI guy, if he’s anything.  
    • Yep, let's see what he can do.  His best position may be left field but by all accounts, he doesn't have the bat to carry him there so it looks like 2B or bust.  Let's find out. 
    • Yeah, he signed a 6 year deal there for $7 mil - rather than try again in the 2019 draft - must not have thought he'd be a first round pick again.   Man, that stinks for Rocker.  Hopefully he comes back 100% healthy.    
    • It doesn’t matter if Jones isn’t a second baseman right now.  You make him show you that he isn’t one at this level. If that is proven, so be it..right now, on a team that doesn’t care about winning and one that has horrendous options like Valaika getting a lot of playing time over there, you see what you have because, why not?
    • I think I know what SG would say.  Its because Eshelman is no good.   But that is not the reason that Elias made the move.  My guess is he is ready to activate Richie Martin from the 60 day IL and needs the 40 man roster spot.   Martin will probably be assigned to AAA for at least a month.   Then Elias will decide it he is ready for a promotion to the majors.   Speaking about the infield,  Baltimorebaseball.com has an article speculating that the O's are about ready to promote Jahmai Jones to the majors to play 2B. https://www.baltimorebaseball.com/2021/08/02/minor-monday-jahmai-jones-nearing-promotion-orioles/ To me this the Ryan Mountcastle position fiasco  all over again.  The O's trying to be a square pen in a round hole.   The O's tried Ryan at SS/3B/LF before finally realizing that he is first baseman.     All the reports I've read and what I have seen of Jones makes me feel he is not a 2B.   His best position is probably left field.     And while Hays will gets the majority of playing time at left field that does not change my belief that's Jones best position.   His bat is what gets him to the majors but it will not keep him at 2B IMO.   You can say what is the harm in playing Jones at 2B for the rest of the year and beside it probably being ugly you are probably right.  But let's not lose sight that there is probably a move to the outfield in Jones future again IMO. With Stowers arriving in the majors next year sometime and Neustrom probably ready by next spring the O's will soon have plenty of corner outfielders.  Hays and Santander get the playing time in the corners for the last third of this season trying  to show they can hit major league pitching and hold on to their spots but if you count Jones  and oft injured  Diaz in that outfield competition there are more outfielders than spots and a trade or two are likely next year. That traffic jam would seem to be a reason to trade Mancini from the DH/1B role but Mancini has something that none of those guys have.  A bat that produces 30 homers and 90+ RBI a season.    I am not saying how  all this turns out but the traffic jam is predictable.
    • Do you mean, median WAR/team from the draft?    I haven’t seen that exact calculation, but here’s an article that breaks things down a bit: https://community.fangraphs.com/analyzing-the-draft/ Finger to the wind, I’d say a median team draft produces about 20 rWAR.   I think the median may be considerably below the mean, and so an endless string of median-level drafts would not be a good result. I get there three different ways.   First, the article shows that the available WAR in a draft is roughly 600 on average.  600/30 = 20. Second, I did a study of the AL East drafts a while back and found that the drafts from 2000-09 had produced 1100 WAR.   1100 for 5 teams over 10 years = 22 WAR per year.   That number can rise a bit since some of those players are still playing, though most aren’t.    Third, we know that WAR is calibrated so that an average team will have 34 WAR in a year.   70-75% comes from drafted players, the rest from foreign players.  So figure 26 WAR/year from drafted players.   Logically, the draft should be supplying about that much talent every year for the system to be self-sustaining.   The reason I think the mean is probably significantly higher than the median is that one star player might produce enough WAR to cover 2-3 drafts.    FWIW, the Orioles’ 2000-2009 drafts had produced 153 WAR going into this season.    Clearly a below average total, which is not surprising.   
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...