Jump to content

SABR Creates New "Henry Chadwick Award": James, Ritter, Palmer Among Honorees

Recommended Posts


For almost 40 years, the Society for American Baseball Research has painstakingly unearthed and saluted the accomplishments of long-forgotten contributors to the game. Now it will honor the stars of its own: by creating, in effect, the Baseball Historian Hall of Fame.

SABR announced on Monday the inaugural class of winners of its new Henry Chadwick Award -– (fittingly) nine people whose work is far better known, even among casual fans, than most realize.

Bill James

Lawrence Ritter

Bill Neft

Lee Allen

Pete Palmer

Bob Davids

Peter Morris*

Harold Seymour

Jules Tygiel

*I've already managed to mention But Didn't We Have Fun twice in a short period of time, but I have to mention it again because it's by Peter Morris, which I just realized as I looked him up.

I think it's very nice that SABR is honoring people who won't get the same attention from the actual Hall of Fame due to the BBWAA. Over time, though, it will be interesting to see if the two groups end up either switching situations, or combining forces in some way that brings SABR closer to the Hall.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I briefly glanced at the email I got from SABR on this the other day, but didn't pay a lot of attention. I don't know how much recognition this will get outside of the hardcore SABR community, but these are some huge, huge people. In the historian community all of these guy are like the initial HOF class of Ruth, Cobb, Young, Johnson, Wagner, Speaker.

I guess you can't go wrong with any of them. James is James, and his influence can hardly be overstated - he's probably caused more people to get interested in baseball analysis/history/research than anyone, ever. And, of course, he's written dozens of volumes of his own.

Harold Seymour is arguably even more important. He, along with Dorothy Seymour, wrote the series of books beginning with Baseball, The Early Years, which were the first serious, scholarly looks at baseball history. Quite literally, before that book came out there was no decent source for the history of early baseball. It took until the 70s or 80s for most of the big players of the 1800s to get into the Hall because, more-or-less, nobody knew a thing about them until Seymour.

Among the others I'm most familiar with the works of Palmer and Allen, but all of these guys have made a thousand imprints on the game, large and small. For example, without Lee Allen we just wouldn't know the birth and death dates of thousands of players. I think he actually had a column in the Sporting News in the 40s and 50s enlisting people to go out and find information on hundreds of forgotten old players.

And Davids founded SABR. The baseball world would be very, very different without him.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

If I'd just read the original email from SABR or the link in the original post here I could have saved myself typing out my prior response. Most of what I said and more is on SABR's announcement.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Orioles Information

Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores


Tony's Takes

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2018 End of Season Top 30 Prospects List

Prospect Scouting Reports


2019 Orioles Stats

2019 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats

  • Posts

    • I know about the AAA phase, it's the protected players I don't know about.
    • Looks like there's more activity in the AAA phase than the MLB phase: Major League phase Round 1 1. Orioles: SS Richie Martin (A's No. 12 prospect) 2. Royals: RHP Sam McWilliams (Rays) 3. White Sox: RHP Jordan Romano (Blue Jays No. 28) -- traded to Rangers 4. Marlins: RHP Riley Ferrell (Astros No. 17) 5. Tigers: RHP Reed Garrett (Rangers) 6. Reds:  1B/3B Connor Joe (Dodgers) 7. Rangers: RHP Chris Ellis (Cardinals) -- traded to Royals 8. Giants: LHP Travis Bergen (Blue Jays) 9. Blue Jays: RHP Elvis Luciano (Royals No. 23) 10. Mets: RHP Kyle Dowdy (Indians) 11. Phillies: 2B/SS Drew Jackson (Dodgers No. 19) -- traded to Orioles 12. D-backs: RHP Nick Green (Yankees) 13. Mariners: RHP Brandon Brennan (Rockies) Round 2 14. Giants: OF Drew Ferguson (Astros) Triple-A phase Round 1 1. Orioles: RHP Taylor Grover (Reds) 2. Royals: C Chris Rabago (Yankees) 3. White Sox: 1B Jordan George (Pirates)  4. Tigers: CF Tyler Hill (Red Sox) 5. Padres:  RHP Cristofer Melendez (White Sox) -- traded to Pirates 6. Rangers: RHP Jeffeson Medina (Orioles) 7. Giants: 3B Peter Maris (Rays) 8. Blue Jays: RHP David Garner (Cubs)  9. Mets: LF Braxton Lee (Marlins No. 29) 10. Twins:  RHP Dusten Knight (Giants)  11. Phillies: RHP Gilmael Troya  (Yankees) 12. Angels: RHP Matt Esparza (Indians) 13. D-backs: OF Jeffrey Baez (Giants) 14. Nationals: CF Chuck Taylor (Mariners)  15. Pirates: OF Randolph Gassaway (Orioles) 16. Cardinals:  RHP John Fasola (Rangers)  17. Braves: RHP Jason Creasy (D-backs) 18. Rays: RHP Ryan Thompson (Astros) 19. Indians: LHP Yapson Gomez (Cubs)   20. Cubs: LHP Luis Lugo (Royals) 21. Brewers: SS Julio Garcia (Angels)  22. A's: 2B Corban Joseph (Orioles) 23. Yankees: RHP Adonis De La Cruz (Mariners)  24. Astros: C Alejandro Flores (Nationals) 25. Red Sox: RHP Anyelo Gómez (Yankees) Round 2 26. Giants: LHP Sam Moll (Blue Jays) 27. Mets: RHP Chris Mazza (Mariners) 28. Pirates: RHP Winston Nicacio (Cardinals)  29. Cardinals: SS Alberto Triunfel (Angels) 30. Braves:  RHP Rafael De Paula (Reds)  31. Rays: RHP Ian Gardeck (Giants) 32. Indians: 1B Wilson Garcia (Orioles) 33. Cubs: C Rafelin Lorenzo (Pirates)  34. Brewers: C Alexander Alvarez (Rays) 35. A's: CF Mark Payton (Yankees)  36. Red Sox: RHP Andrew Schwaab (Tigers) Round 3 37. Mets: C Mitch Ghelfi (Angels) 38. Braves: SS Riley Unroe (Angels) 39. Rays: RHP Cristofer Ogando (D-backs)  40. Cubs: RHP Alexander Vargas (Yankees) 41. A's: 1B Anthony Miller (Indians) Round 4 42. Rays: RHP Hector Figueroa (Indians)  https://www.mlb.com/news/2018-rule-5-draft-results-c301780782
    • Twins want an upgrade at 1B over Cron.  Could always have them include Javier in a Mancini trade package.  If he isn’t drafted by another team.  And, if we don’t take him, I doubt anyone else will.
    • I’m hoping that in 5 years I’ll look back and say 2017-18 were worth it because that collapse forced us to totally remake the organization into the winner we are today.   But right now I’m in the “hope” phase.   
    • Interesting. They don't usually reveal that information about who is protected. I guess that's why I've never heard of it.
    • I know the minor league phase has changed a little, but in the past teams could protect something like 38 players (in addition to the 40 man roster) from both the AAA and AA phases. I'd imagine it's still similar 
    • Aren’t there already enough horror movies released these days? That season was a complete kick to the crotch and I wanted to fast forward to the end by mid August.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...