I think he's going to be a ~3 win player. I'd be fine with that on a playoff team.
Of course one of the underused advantages of signing a player to this type of contract is that if he ends up as even a 2 win guy you have a lot of excessive value if you want to flip him.
I get what you are saying but at this level of compensation the player doesn't have to be all that skilled to be worth it. As I said earlier this is pretty much the money Schoop has made over the same period of time.
I think a fair bit of it is a marketing problem. I think baseball as a whole has been very poor in this regard and have allowed the individual teams to conduct themselves without an overriding plan.
Owners wanted a draft last time and they settled for the current slotting system instead.
Or did you mean that the Union makes a practice of trading away the rights of non-union members, because yea, they totally do that.
That's easy. They give in on the International draft. That way the players don't actually give up anything, they just screw over some 16 year olds most of whom will never be in the Union.