When I was eight or nine they opened a recycling center behind the CVS in our neighborhood (Overlea). Randy Milligan was the special guest. My dad and I walked up and met Randy, and we were just about the only people there. He talked to us for what seemed like an hour (only thing I remember about the conversation is that he told us he likes to hit off of guys who throw hard vs finesse guys [side note: the numbers seem to prove that out too]). Super nice guy, and would have been appreciated as a player much more in this era.
Even though a lot of the backlog is cleared, I think there are still at least ten deserving guys, so I'd vote for the following, if I was able:
A-Rod
Beltre
Beltran
Utley
Andruw Jones
Helton
Sheffield
Abreu
Wagner
Nice play coming in on one last night:
https://www.mlb.com/gameday/orioles-vs-mariners/2022/06/28/662186#game_state=final,lock_state=final,game_tab=videos,game=662186