Well they gave 200M to two guys who where supposedly sluggers who quickly became non sluggers, and 57M to a picther who spends most of his time on the IL. Is that considered charity?
We should keep Villar. Pay him the 7M or so that arbitration rules. Unless we can get another second baseman with a 4.0 WAR that bats .274 with 24 HR, 33 2B, scores 111 R, and steals 40 bases. Just play him at second not short.
"Who would you not trade?"
If we had a hitter who ended up with a higher batting avg than say Altuve, Betts and Trout...I would keep that guy. Oh wait...we did. ?