Jump to content

Posada Back in the Yankees Lineup at 7th Spot

CharmCityCrab

By CharmCityCrab
in MLB

Recommended Posts

CharmCityCrab AAA

CharmCityCrab

Posted
Posted

Source: http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=ap-yankees-lineup

Seriously Girardi? The guy throws a hissy fit and refuses to play because you slotted him at 9th in the batting order, and your response is to put him in the order batting two spots higher the next time he plays?

I'm not going to totally trash Posada here. I understand people have bad days, and he apologized the next day, so we can chalk it up to frustration and being an out of character moment. But the correct response on the part of manager is to put him in the lineup right back in that 9th slot, at least the first time back. The way things played out, it looks like Girardi caved to a 39 year old hitting .165 who is too broken down to field his old position on a regular basis.

Again, not jumping on Posada too much -- he apologized and I support the right of any player to keep playing as long as he wants to as long as he is willing to accept the role his performance dictates (i.e. batting lower in the order, maybe having to switch positions, teams, or leagues, etc..). But you can't respond to the guy refusing to play because he was hitting 9th by moving him up in the order. That's just stupid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing


  • Posts

    • Grt 2BA FL Gator
      Ryan Mountcastle 2024

      By Grt 2BA FL Gator · Posted

      I think Mountcastle is the foremost person hurt by Walltimore. I honestly think we need to reconsider what type of right handed batters we throw out there. More Luis Arraez or someone with high OBP. I could see Mountcastle having a revival somewhere else. But not sure it’s really working here anymore, even though he was solid last year. 
    • baltfan
      Where are the pollyannas?

      By baltfan · Posted

      Who is the real MOO bat though?  I can't think of one other than Soto available.  I am all in on Soto, but I don't think the Orioles will even sniff him.  Absent Soto, who do you look to acquire? I agree that it is time to move on from Tony and Mounty, but I do think you are a little harsh on Tony.  He has won a number of games for this team in the clutch.  He is just prone to cold spells.  
    • Aristotelian
      Orioles try to come to grips with another playoff sweep and pending losses within clubhouse

      By Aristotelian · Posted

      OK, there won't be 30 making actual bids but Burnes is free to sign with any team at the highest price. There is one very big reason he won't sign with us, which is money. We do have payroll flexibility but that evaporates if we put $40m/year in one player. I would love this if it happens but my expectations are very low. Even if we are "one of the favorites", say the final four, we only have a 25% chance. Probably lower if any of the others are in larger markets. So I have to agree with Roch's assessment. 
    • waroriole
      Ryan Mountcastle 2024

      By waroriole · Posted

      In that case the question could be do we pay Mountcastle 6-7M or do we pay a AAAA guy league minimum and use his money on RP. The purpose of keeping Mountcastle was the hope he would eventually break out and have a career year. He’s regressing offensively and the odds of that breakout are shrinking. 
    • casadeozo
      Colton Cowser 2024

      By casadeozo · Posted

      With his season now over, curious what happened to the version of Cowser we drafted. looking at his scouting report coming out of Sam Houston State, the concern with him was would his power translate to MLB while his plate discipline and ability to draw walks being a plus. Certainly were concerns about the strikeouts but nowhere near the concerns of someone like Honeycutt.    He finishes the year with 52 walks and 172 strikeouts, with a 30% K rate. He was near the top of the league in strikeouts for most of the year.  is this purely his issues with off speed pitches? Can this be improved or do we accept the awful strikeouts and laud the plus defense.
    • LookitsPuck
      Elias and Hyde address the media today

      By LookitsPuck · Posted

      I want to also address the Harper point. I'm talking about RISP, not "late and close". We can talk about high leverage/late and close in a diff convo, but strictly RISP: Bryce Harper 2023: 272/.803 2024: 331/ 1.122 2023 was a goofy year for Harper coming off of Tommy John. He looked good in April, but was a disaster in May/June before finishing the season on fire that year. I don't think he's a good case study for your example. Besides, I'm not talking singular player performance. I'm talking as a team which is far less susceptible to SSS and "chance". FWIW, I do think luck somewhat plays into this.  But let's look at this as a team. 1,298 AB with RISP for the O's this year. A 251 BA. Last year they hit 287. That's a 36 point difference. Yeah, only 3.6%. But let's look at what 3.6% means with that many AB. That means: 47 extra hits. I don't believe that 47 hits explains "luck" or "chance". Maybe for certain hitters in certain situations. There is an element of BABIP here. In 2024, it was 317. This year? 289. So, if we truly believe 300 is league average, they were a little unlucky this year, and somewhat lucky last year. But we are still talking about a dramatic dropoff. Now, is that because of playing more rookies this year? Because of the injuries? Very possibly. And in a 2 game series that can rear its ugly head. But there was nothing unlucky about yesterday or the day before. They just came up completely empty. Maybe the only unlucky situations were Ramon and Westy rips being caught.
    • turtlebowl
      Where are the pollyannas?

      By turtlebowl · Posted

      I mentioned this once before but if you follow high end D1 softball the game has changed dramatically because the pitching is so dominate.  The theory is, you aren't going to score a bunch of runs by stringing singles together so most top programs only recruit athletes with game changing power or speed.  The speed aspect is important because you can turn a single into a double by stealing so now it only takes 2 hits to score a run instead of 3.   The O's lower minors seem to be stacked with guys that can steal bases so maybe that will be the change in philosophy moving forward.   It is just a thought but maybe the organization see's the pitching trend that is dominating because of the bullpen usage and OBP and runs scored across the board are down.  So stack your team with power and or speed and not much else matters.

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...