Jump to content

Jeter broke a pact; no more all-star selections for him, please


Frobby

Recommended Posts

Derek Jeter didn't deserve to be on this year's all star team, but the fans voted him in anyway. Why? Because he's a Hall of Famer and they wanted to see him play. It would have been especially appropriate for the fans to have a chance to give him an ovation on national television to acknowledge his recent milestone.

So how does he thank the fans? By skipping the game, saying he is "emotionally exhuasted."

OK, Derek, you want to skip the game? I guess that is your right. But if the fans vote you to the all star game next year, they should be ashamed of themselves. You broke a pact with your fans, and I hope you pay the consequence.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I truly do not get all the anger about players skipping the AS game. I would *never* play in one. Why? Because winning is more important to me, and recharging or resting is more important than playing in this game (especially if I was a pitcher). Playing in the AS game can only hurt regular season performance, not add to it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sure all those years in his prime playing all those playoff games is finally taking it's toll. Maybe if he didn't play all those November games, he would have the strength to play a few more seasons. :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I truly do not get all the anger about players skipping the AS game. I would *never* play in one. Why? Because winning is more important to me, and recharging or resting is more important than playing in this game (especially if I was a pitcher). Playing in the AS game can only hurt regular season performance, not add to it.

Then cancel the event. But if you are going to play the game, the healthy players should show up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Then cancel the event. But if you are going to play the game, the healthy players should show up.

John Kruk suggested that even the unhealthy players should show up. Wave, sign balls, etc. I think I agree with that. If you're healthy enough to travel with your team, you should be at the game if you're voted in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is he skipping it entirely or is he just not playing? If he is there and announced, he will get the ovation he deserves. The Jeter hate has got to stop at some point. He is an all time great and depending on how skewed you're views are he is either the 2nd or 3rd all time SS or at the very worst a top 5 all time SS. Hes coming off an injury, his team is neck and neck in a battle for 1st place, and this is the All Star BREAK. I do not blame him at all. He should probably show up, but if he doesn't oh well. And as long as he is who the fans want to see on the field the second week of July, the he should be voted on until he retires.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jeter is getting called out on the carpet for skipping by players and the MLB.

Jeter 'wrong' for skipping AS game, by ESPN (yes, that ESPN): (EXCEPT)

Derek Jeter is reportedly being called out by Major League Baseball and a few fellow players for skipping Tuesday's All-Star Game festivities in Phoenix.

The New York Yankees shortstop will not be attending because of "emotional and physical exhaustion" from his pursuit of 3,000 hits, according to a Foxsports.com report.

But an anonymous major league official told the New York Daily News that baseball wanted to celebrate Jeter's accomplishment and isn't happy he's not there. "Derek Jeter has done everything right during his whole career," the official said, according to the newspaper. "He was wrong on this one."

Baseball would have been fine with Jeter appearing on the field for player introductions, tipping his cap and then heading back to New York, the official told the newspaper. "This could have been a celebration of his 3,000th hit," the official said. "He didn't have to play."

I'm actually surprised by this reaction.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

MLB has the ASG set up and promoted as "Fans vote in the All Stars." So basically Jeter is telling the fans "F You, I don't care what you think." That's why the reaction is what it is. Personally, I'm glad he and Rivera and Tex and ARoid and all the rest of the jackrabbits aren't there.

I was hoping that Hardy would get Jeter's spot, but I guess I forgot about the rule that only one Oriole can attend the game. :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is he skipping it entirely or is he just not playing? If he is there and announced, he will get the ovation he deserves. The Jeter hate has got to stop at some point. He is an all time great and depending on how skewed you're views are he is either the 2nd or 3rd all time SS or at the very worst a top 5 all time SS. Hes coming off an injury, his team is neck and neck in a battle for 1st place, and this is the All Star BREAK. I do not blame him at all. He should probably show up, but if he doesn't oh well. And as long as he is who the fans want to see on the field the second week of July, the he should be voted on until he retires.

I don't hate Jeter. I hate his decision not to play in the all star game. My understanding is that he isn't showing up at all.

And to go back to my OP, my main point is that, if he finds it inconvenient to show up for a game in which the fans voted him in, then I hope they don't vote him in again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't hate Jeter. I hate his decision not to play in the all star game. My understanding is that he isn't showing up at all.

And to go back to my OP, my main point is that, if he finds it inconvenient to show up for a game in which the fans voted him in, then I hope they don't vote him in again.

Now, I wasn't necessarily directing it at you. But you know that the majority of the fans who disapprove of the move won't do it because they have thought out a reason like you have. I should have prefaced that, I was more piggybacking off your OP.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

MLB has the ASG set up and promoted as "Fans vote in the All Stars." So basically Jeter is telling the fans "F You, I don't care what you think." That's why the reaction is what it is. Personally, I'm glad he and Rivera and Tex and ARoid and all the rest of the jackrabbits aren't there.

I was hoping that Hardy would get Jeter's spot, but I guess I forgot about the rule that only one Oriole can attend the game. :rolleyes:

Or that Peralta was more deserving than Hardy. :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.



  • Posts

    • Pitchers to cut/leavingFA Anthony Castro Chris Ellis - 60 Day IL Logan Gillaspie Louis Head Jordan Lyles Jake Reed Beau Susler Chris Vallimont Spenser Watkins Cathers, IF Cut/LeavingFA Robinson Chirinos Cam Gallagher Tyler Nevin  Rougned Odor Jesus Aguilar I am going to give a spot to Diaz, its AAA Depth and we can always cut him after ST. With Means coming of the 60 Day, I think that puts us at 12 Open Spots I'm probably only protecting 6 MILB guys, so I would go into my offseason with 6 open spots and start crushing the Waiver Wire (the 5 listed in the original post plus Maverick (I know its slim, but we really have almost no catching depth in the milb and we have to protect it even if its a 1% chance hes selected in the Rule V) There's a part of me that wants to keep a couple of the pitchers listed above, but I believe many would pass through waivers and those that don't can easily be replaced on the waiver wire. That's probably where we could find some more catcher depth too, but I'd use most of those spots on more waiver wire pitching like last year.      
    • This is a huge winter for Mateo.  he should have confidence enough to put in the work to get better for next year.  The Orioles gave him a chance.  He took it.   Now put in the work Mr. Mateo.
    • Well, if you miss on 4th down, you assume they get it at the 2.  The idea that they got it on the 20 changes everything. I don’t mind the decision, after reading more and hearing more explanations.  I still think he should have taken the points but ultimately, I think at best they go into OT if they took the points and more than likely lose in regular time.
    • I mean, I can see being upset that they didn’t play well and blew the playoff chance.  I just don’t get why it matters that it was to division teams.  I’m more upset that they lost to Detroit and Oakland, teams that were far inferior.
    • I expect the lack of a shift to help left-handed hitters.  But  the SS can still be just to the left of 2nd base.  The difference will be the 2nd baseman has to start on the dirt.
    • Because Lamar can pick up 1-2 yards with his feet in his sleep. Odds fall off a cliff when it's from the goal line and he's passing. You obviously take the 3 unless you're at like the one and you're just having Lamar lunge forward. But if you miss on fourth you're giving the game away. It's insane how Harbs keeps doing the same thing to almost justify all the other previous awful game ending decisions he's made.
    • Because we had a very good chance to win the season series against Tampa, Boston and Toronto, and blew our chances against the first two.  If we blew it against Toronto as well, I find that annoying.   It’s not just that we lost these series, it’s that we had a lead in these series and then didn’t play well against these teams in August and September.   
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...