Jump to content

BBA early draft preview for 2012 top 100


Recommended Posts

I didn't see this anywhere else. I am by no means any draft expert just want to post some videos that I had seen. Below are the top 10 for quick reference. The link at the bottom provides top 100.

Rk. Player Pos. B/T Ht. Wt. School

1. Mark Appel RHP R-R 6-5 190 Stanford

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDt9i_Zi1XI&feature=related

2. Lucas Giolito RHP R-R 6-6 230 Harvard-Westlake HS, Studio City, Calif.

3. Byron Buxton OF R-R 6-2 175 Appling County HS, Baxley, Ga.

comes in @ 2:29

4. Deven Marrero SS R-R 6-1 194 Arizona State

5. Mike Zunino C R-R 6-2 215 Florida

6. Kevin Gausman RHP L-R 6-4 185 Louisiana State

7. Chris Beck RHP R-R 6-3 220 Georgia Southern

8. Brian Johnson LHP/1B L-L 6-3 225 Florida

9. Victor Roache OF R-R 6-1 225 Georgia Southern

10. David Dahl OF L-R 6-2 185 Oak Mountain HS, Birmingham

Top 100

http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/draft/early-draft-preview/2012/2612884.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know it is very early, but if you suppose for a moment that Appel and Giolito are are gone by the time we pick, who are we looking at with #4? Best player available..., but that may mean we take Zunino © or Marrero (SS). I would be happy with either at this time because we need the quality and the depth for trades or possible position changes down the road. I need to see more of Gausman.

I wonder what Rajisch likes at the top of the draft? Does DD have much to say about the draft?

I am intrigued by David Dahl, Walker Weickel and Gavin Cecchini. I will be checking out Weickel and teammate Jesse Winker a few times this season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know it is very early, but if you suppose for a moment that Appel and Giolito are are gone by the time we pick, who are we looking at with #4? Best player available..., but that may mean we take Zunino © or Marrero (SS). I would be happy with either at this time because we need the quality and the depth for trades or possible position changes down the road. I need to see more of Gausman.

I wonder what Rajisch likes at the top of the draft? Does DD have much to say about the draft?

I am intrigued by David Dahl, Walker Weickel and Gavin Cecchini. I will be checking out Weickel and teammate Jesse Winker a few times this season.

Cecchini is legit, and a favorite of Stotle. It's way too early to really get a feel for who is going to separate to the top of the draft, I think you see Buxton up there too even though he's the kinda prospect I usually stay away from. Everything will change between now and June though, so I wouldn't put too much thought into it.

Marrero was a favorite of mine out of HS, and is a HECK of a defensive SS, he would make a solid INF with Manny at 3B and Schoop at 2B, but with questions about just how much his bat will hold up it could be a risk at #4. Reminds me of Omar Vizquel though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Camden Terp. Nice post to analyze on a snowy morning! I'm leaning towards Zunino, Marrero or Roache at the moment. Will have to watch them closely this season. Enough pitchers for awhile. We need hitters on our first two picks in my opinion unless a pitcher falls to us that has a golden arm.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Comments like this really make me scratch my head when Churchill writes...

10. Mitch Nay, 3B, Hamilton (Chandler, Ariz.)

Nay fits the physical profile of a third baseman as much as anyone on this list. An Arizona State commit, Nay isn't as known to scouts as some other talents, but the physical prowess is there and he'll get a chance to show off his power and arm strength all spring. The hit tool is generally the main concern with prep power bats and Nay falls into that category, too.

I don't even know what this means. Nay was at several BIG events. I guarantee there is no area scout in Nay's region that isn't familiar with him. And I'd also imagine the regional folks and decision makers also have a solid book on him already. I mean, if your region is Arizona, how can you not be familiar with one of the top 5 kids in your state? Someone who participated at some of the most high profile scouting events on the summer circuit?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • It was huge. I wasn't old enough to read it until about the 1980 version, but I'd check it out from the library every few weeks and probably read it cover to cover multiple times. It was there that I found things like Willie Keeler's .432 average in 1897, for the National League Baltimore Orioles, of all things. I think many people don't realize that before the McMillan Encyclopedia there was no single comprehensive source for this information. In many cases no source at all. You mention the Whos Whos in Baseball publications, but they only had active players. And I'm not sure how accurate they were, or how comprehensive. If you wanted to see who won the American League in 1907... I don't know. Or who won the 1922 batting title if you didn't have a stack of old Sporting News or Spalding Guides. There were some earlier books, like one called Daguerreotypes, but they were not well known or widely available or probably very accurate. I think it's true that when Ty Cobb retired he probably didn't know how many hits he actually had. When Babe Ruth started hitting homers some writer had to go dig around old guides and total stuff up to see if he was getting near some career record. The Encyclopedia was the beginning of the end of people who'd tell these long-winded stories of great feats of baseball from decades ago that were mostly not true. End of the Cliff Clavin era.
    • I’d say Tampa.    I don’t want to see Arozarena in a playoff series. Ever. He kills us and I’m sure he’d go off on a big stage.  Their pitching is really good.     
    • There's a new test called the S2 cognition test that is supposedly a better predictor of QB success rates than Wonderlic, which has a lot of high profile misses, Lamar included.  (Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Steve McNair among others.)  With the number of misses on the Wonderlic test  it's hard for me to take the test seriously as a predictor of NFL quarterbacking success.  I also found this study that says the same thing:   https://harvardsportsanalysis.org/2014/04/wondering-about-the-wonderlic-does-it-predict-quarterback-performance/#:~:text=From the various tests we,and Wonderlic scores of quarterbacks.   S2 picked up on Brock Purdy being a possible diamond in the rough.  It started being taken around 2015, so its likely Lamar took it, but his score hasn't been publicized.  People made a big deal about it this past draft cycle because CJ Stroud did terribly on it apparenty.
    • The way I read this, anyone on the 40 man is eligible, even if they are in the minors. Then there are exceptions for players who aren't on the 40an. So yes, I am not expert in roster rules but I believe Grayson, Kjerstad etc could be optioned and still make the postseason roster as long as they stay on the 40 man roster.
    • If we’re just talking internal candidates then I think it’s pretty easy to put something accurate together. Personally, I don’t believe for a second that Holliday has a real chance at breaking OD. I think Urias at 3B, Henderson at SS, and Westburg at 2B is the most likely every day configuration if they’re not adding anyone significant from outside the organization.   If we start talking about potential moves for outside players then this gets a lot more dicey, but fun. Personally, I’d like to see two mid-rotation starters added. Give me something like Jordan Montgomery and Logan Gilbert. Tell me that a rotation of Rodriguez, Bradish, Montgomery, Gilbert, and Means is not one of the most balanced rotations in baseball. Insert similar names for the additions, I’m not particularly hung up on specifics right now. That’d push Wells and Kremer to the BP full time.  Id probably resign both Fuji and Hicks, if he’s interested. That leaves a bullpen with something like Cano, Fuji, Webb, Coulombe, Hall, Wells, Kremer, and Perez. I gotta agree about Bautista, unfortunately.    Big if, but if we are thinking that Holliday is a legit consideration then I’d be moving Urias. Mateo seems like a easy DFA. Ortiz can be the backup infielder. I may even consider moving Urias anyways and slotting Ortiz at SS until Holliday is ready.    Anyways, that’s really just an addition of a couple mid rotation starters (one through FA, one through trade), an okay bullpen addition, and possibly a veteran presence if Hicks is okay with a backup role in the OF. I don’t really feel the veteran presence is totally necessary, but judging by offseasons of the past, Elias finds it very necessary no matter how redundant the piece may be.    Also, there’s no room for all of Hays, Mullins, Santander, Cowser, Kjerstad, and Stowers. I’m thinking at least one of these OF guys can be part of the aforementioned trade for a mid rotation starter. Does something like Kjerstad, Basallo, and Urias get Gilbert? I dunno…getting too specific now. 
    • Adley’s going to reach base 250+ times this season.  Joe Mauer did that 4 times.  Mike Piazza did it twice. Johnny Bench once. Buster Posey never did.  Neither did Carlton Fisk, Gary Carter, Yadier Molina,  Jorge Posada or Ivan Rodriguez.  
    • That would certainly explain why O’Hearn is not allowed to hit against a LHP ever. 
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...