Jump to content

Melky Cabrera? Really?


Frobby

Recommended Posts

I was skimming down the list of wOBA and OPS leaders this morning, and came across this:

Melky Cabrera, .945 OPS, .406 wOBA.

Slash line: .369/.405/.540

This from a guy with a career .747 OPS and .327 wOBA, who looked like he was toast two years ago.

What's going on here?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I've been watching him a little bit too. He put up an OPS of .809 last year and he is just getting into what are the typical prime years at 27. Although, nothing he has previously done would suggest this sort of breakout was possible. I've got to think it's just an extended hot streak, but ya never know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't seen him much, but he had a pretty good year last year in KC, finally cresting the .300/.800 marks with 201 hits. His wOBA was also a single-season high, though not tremendously higher than other seasons like it is so far this year. He's been away from the eastern divisions the past two years and is hitting the peak years. Walk rate returning to career norms this year. Speed could be a factor - on pace for more SB than last year, and those triples are really helping the SLG and OPS by extension, though he isn't on pace to have more HR/2B/total XBH over last year. I wonder how many infield hits he's legged out. Maybe some things are coming together the right way and he's really having just a good year. That BA is big, though, and it's driving a good portion of the Y-o-Y increase in a lot of the numbers. The BABIP is ridiculous - .409?? Some things must moderate, and the numbers probably won't look quite as good at year's end, but at any rate, compared with '10, he seems to be on a different planet, for sure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

.409 BABIP versus .308 career. ISO is only up 8 points only last year. His GB/FB is 2.31, the highest of his career by a substantial margin. He also has a record HR/FB. LD% is also at his highest ever.

Definitely a strange year for him, but he's certainly turned into a fine player in any case. If this was fantasy baseball I might be selling high though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
I was skimming down the list of wOBA and OPS leaders this morning, and came across this:

Melky Cabrera, .945 OPS, .406 wOBA.

Slash line: .369/.405/.540

This from a guy with a career .747 OPS and .327 wOBA, who looked like he was toast two years ago.

What's going on here?

There's your answer: "50 game suspension for PED's - out for the rest of the season."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yea, testosterone too... not good stuff to play around with.

Really? My former urologist prescribed it for me a few years ago. According to the lab results, my T level was 30 percent low. The doc promised me that I'd "feel like a new man" after 30 days on the stuff.

After a couple months, I got tired of rubbing the 'clear" on my chest, got another urologist, and my regular doc said he didn't think I needed it. I took my remaining prescription to the pharmacist and asked him to dispose of it. I didn't want a trash hauler finding the tubes in my trash and selling it to a high school kid.

Now I'm seeing a lot of ads on TV claiming that testosterone levels decline dramatically in middle age (I'm 65) and touting supplements. Maybe I missed the boat?

However, the one thing of which I'm sure is that not everyone will have the same results from using PEDs. It didn't seem to do Ryan Franklin, Ross Grimsley, or Larry Bigbie much good. Maybe Melkie was an exception.

My enduring memory of Melkie was that great catch he made in the 2006 NLCS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really? My former urologist prescribed it for me a few years ago. According to the lab results, my T level was 30 percent low. The doc promised me that I'd "feel like a new man" after 30 days on the stuff.

After a couple months, I got tired of rubbing the 'clear" on my chest, got another urologist, and my regular doc said he didn't think I needed it. I took my remaining prescription to the pharmacist and asked him to dispose of it. I didn't want a trash hauler finding the tubes in my trash and selling it to a high school kid.

Now I'm seeing a lot of ads on TV claiming that testosterone levels decline dramatically in middle age (I'm 65) and touting supplements. Maybe I missed the boat?

However, the one thing of which I'm sure is that not everyone will have the same results from using PEDs. It didn't seem to do Ryan Franklin, Ross Grimsley, or Larry Bigbie much good. Maybe Melkie was an exception.

My enduring memory of Melkie was that great catch he made in the 2006 NLCS.

The Yankees were in the NLCS?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




  • Posts

    • Yes,  I just wonder if Elias thinks he can trade him for a guy in A ball or the rookie league?   What Elias thinks about that will be the different between him being of the 40 man roster in early December or not.
    • Well, I guarantee you that there is a long list of players in MLB history that have seen a drop off in defense between those ages. And how are defining a drop off? The difference between elite to very good is big but not always discernible to the eye.  But that drop off is enough to where he just isn’t all that valuable. Elite is where he must be to provide value. 
    • Very good point.   Look at Jim Palmer.   He had a pretty low K/9 rate for his career(5.0), but had such an amazing defense behind him, his WHIP was 1.18.     
    • Well, I don’t think his range, arm or ability to time plays are going to change materially from this year to next.  In other words, I expect the fundamentals of his defense to be about the same.  What I think can change from this year to next year are: 1.  Mistakes.   He could make more, he could make less.    2.  Random fluctuations in how defensive plays get measured.  They try to make these stats as objective as they can, but it seems there are always some borderline plays that can be judged one way or another.   In other words, I think if Mateo made the exact same plays in 2023 as in 2022, his metrics wouldn’t necessarily be exactly the same.   Among other things, I think some of these stats are measured relative to the other players in the league, so if one player’s performance is the same as the year before, whereas the performance of other players at that position is a little up or down, it will affect that player’s OAA, DRS, etc.  Also I think the surrounding players make a difference.  If you have a 3B with great range, maybe the SS gets fewer chances than if the 3B has poor range.   If the 2B is poor at turning the DP, maybe the shortstop’s conversion rate on DP’s goes down through no fault of his own.    So in short, I expect Mateo’s defensive skills and performance to be about the same next year as this year.   That doesn’t mean that the defensive stats will assess him the same way.    
    • There should not be a defensive drop off between ages 27 and 28.   Now he could be hurt.  His offense is the question mark for next year IMO.  Not his defense.
    • Watching the highlights, Lamar clearly had enough time before the rush got there to get the ball to Duv and just missed him.
    • Tyler Nevin should probably also come off the 40-man roster. He finally had his first decent minor league season since 2018, but he is 25 and almost certainly can only play first at the big league level and most importantly, is out of options next season. He is someone that can fill in in a pinch, but there is almost no chance that he breaks the Opening Day roster next season, so he will have to come off the 40-man roster at the end of spring training anyway to be sent down.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...