Jump to content

Travis Ishikawa called up


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 88
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I don't see any merit to leaving Ishikawa on the roster for any stretch. His bat is so putrid that it's not worth his excellent defense and an occasional start at 1B or serving as a defensive replacement, considering Davis plays solid defense.

Since Buck very recently was terrified of overusing his bullpen to the point of using Strop and costing us a win, we should be calling up a bullpen guy. Don't like this move. Release Ishikawa and move on. He's not a major league player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm excited but puzzled.

I really really like the idea of Ishikawa as a pinch hitter off the bench but I don't see him bringing anything more to the table that Dickerson is doing.

Of course, this could also spell doom for Steve Pearce who is no longer the only backup 1B on the squad. He is, however, the only Right handed OF (besides Adam). If he goes, then it's McLouth or Dickerson vs lefties on a regular basis.

So... I'm puzzled. I'm not quite sure what DD and Buck are thinking here but I'm excited to see what Ishi can do.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My take is that this is just a way to control Ishikawa a bit longer in hopes of packaging him in a trade. I doubt he's on the 25 man for long.

*sniff sniff*

Do I smell trading season in the air?

*sees shadow*

Nope... 6 more weeks before trading begins.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's been hitting very well at Norfolk and has a great glove at 1b. Give him a chance to hit verlander tomorrow as a 1b and DH Davis.

Then after that, who knows.

Perhaps Dickerson or Pearce is outrighted and Ishikawa sticks around.

He's a AAAA player just like Dickerson, Pearce and flaherty.

Of course, most people used to consider Davis a AAAA player too when he was with Texas. Ishikawa has the most potential of Pearce, Dickerson and himself IMO.

His defense at 1st is elite if he figures out hitting he'd be a darn good player. I'd think he's the most valuable of any of those players listed in any potential trade.

I would imagine DD and Buck will be busy the next day or two trying to package Arrieta and maybe Ishikawa with another prospect or two for a pitcher.

Whether anyone will want them is an entirely different story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Is it really a big problem?    Walking guys is only rarely a good strategy.  
    • Some of this year’s struggles with LHP strike me as one of those fluky things that happen in baseball.   Here are some 2021/2022 numbers vs. LHP: Mountcastle .842/.713 Hays .897/.701 Mullins .788/.573 Now Mullins, in his switch hitting days, was weak vs. LHP.   When he switched to hitting from the left side exclusively, he hit them much better last year, but my impression is he did most of his damage in the first half of the season.  So, it may be that LHP have figured out how to attack him and his 2022 numbers are more predictive of the future than 2021.    Mountcastle and Hays, on the other hand, are capable of doing much better than they did this year vs. LHP. Rutschman has a .568 OPS vs. LHP and I feel that’s fluky as well.   He had good splits against LHP in the minors and in college.  My guess is he’ll work on his RH stroke in the offseason and do much better next year.  (Honestly, he doesn’t have much else to work on.) The way OPACY is set up now, it favors LHB and thus LHP figure to do well there.   We’re still facing RHP 70% of the time, so I don’t think we want to load up on RHB and put us at a disadvantage in our own ballpark just to address a problem that exists 30% of the time and may be a one-year anomaly.       
    • Oh he’s going to hit it against us. I just hope it’s off a pitcher that isn’t with us for the long term. Like Lyles, or one of our up/down relievers.    But I want to see our pitchers go at him. We’re about building respect in our franchise back, and building confidence for next year.    Hyde is class, and it’s time we got back to that completely. 
    • Funny thing … Mantle hit 500th and for the Os, the mighty Mark Belanger hit a HR lol … his only one in 1967 and one of 20 career over 18 seasons 
    • Oh we have a history of being part of Yankee lore … Cal breaking Lou’s record, and Stu Miller giving up Mickey’s 500th (when 500 meant something) .. The Yankees were spawned from the 1890s Oriole franchise moved by the fledgling AL to NY as the Highlanders for a season then Yankees pitch to the MFY and strike his butt out four times !!  http://mickeymantle.com/500th-home-run/  
    • True, but it's all the writers that make that vote, not just NY voters.  NY writers vote's don't carry more weight than anyone else's. Agree, I like him, overall.   I'll notice.  You'll notice.  Everyone here will notice.   Poking them in the eye, repeatedly.  Very hard, sharp, quick thrusts. But also, who do you want a record set against?  You or someone else?   True. TLDR   I'm not sure when you joined but I know you've been here awhile.  I'm pretty sure we're all well aware of Judge's history against us. If you need to be reminded, it's a .314/.430/.712 slash line with 35 homers.  That's more homers against any team and by a decent amount.  He's got 28 against the Jays and then the next highest amount is 21 against the Sox.   I've seen how our guys do pitching to him for years now and the results are hardly ever pretty.  He's got 9 homers against us this year, which is more than any other team.  I'm pretty sure I know how this story ends.
    • I thought at the time that Hyde likely was saving Mullins for pinch-running in case he needed some speed for the tying run. 
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...