Jump to content

Who Are YOUR All-Stars?

Spy Fox

Recommended Posts

Everyone always has plenty of critiques of the All Star rosters.

SO, with less than a week until the teams are revealed and the resumes pretty much established, here's a thread to name your own All Star team.

You can use any criteria you like to determine who you think should be headed to Citi Field in two weeks. But if we're assuming the role of the All Star manager, try to follow the MLB rules of having 34 players on the roster, including at least one from each team in the league. If you want you can even make it a bit more realistic by selecting 33 players for guaranteed spots and five more players to be nominated for the Final Vote by fans.

Let the debates begin!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And here are mine:



Lf Mike Trout, LAA

C Joe Mauer, MIN

3b Miguel Cabrera, DET

1b Chris Davis, BAL

Dh Davis Ortiz, BOS

Rf Jose Bautista, TOR

Cf Adam Jones, BAL

Ss Jhonny Peralta, DET

2b Jason Kipnis, CLE

Sp Max Scherzer, DET


C Jason Castro, HOU

C Carlos Santana, CLE

1b Edwin Encarnacion, TOR

2b Dustin Pedroia, BOS

Ss JJ Hardy, BAL

3b Evan Longoria, TBR

3b Manna Machado, BAL

3b Josh Donaldson, OAK

Of Alex Rios, CHW

Of Jacoby Ellsbury, BOS

Of Brett Gardner, NYY

Of Nelson Cruz, TEX

Sp Felix Hernandez, SEA

Sp Chris Sale, CHW

Sp Derek Holland, TEX

Sp Hisashi Iwakuma, SEA

Sp Ervin Santana, KC

Sp Anibal Sanchez, DET

Sp Yu Darvish, TEX

Sp *****

Rp Mariano Rivera, NYY

Rp Joe Nathan, TEX

Rp Greg Holland, KCR

Rp Glen Perkins, MIN

**Final Vote Candidates**

Sp James Shields (KCR), Sp Bartolo Colon (OAK), Sp Alex Cobb (TBR), Sp Hiroki Kuroda (NYY), Sp Doug Fister (DET)



Cf Carlos Gomez, MIL

3b David Wright, NYM

Dh Joey Votto, CIN

Lf Carlos Gonzalez, COL

1b Paul Goldschmidt, ARI

C Buster Posey, SFG

Rf Michael Cuddyer, COL

Ss Jean Segura, MIL

2b Matt Carpenter, STL

Sp Matt Harvey, NYM


C Yadier Molina, STL

C Wilin Rosario, COL

1b Antony Rizzo, CHC

2b Brandon Phillips, CIN

Ss Everth Cabrera, SDP

Ss Ian Desmond, WAS

Of Andrew McCutchen, PIT

Of Shin-Soo Choo, CIN

Of Carlos Beltran, STL

Of Dominic Brown, PHI

Of Dexter Fowler, COL

Sp Adam Wainwright, STL

Sp Cliff Lee, PHI

Sp Jordan Zimmermann, WAS

Sp Patrick Corbin, ARI

Sp Clayton Kershaw, LAD

Sp Mat Latos, CIN

Sp Jose Fernandez, MIA

Sp *****

Rp Jason Grilli, PIT

Rp Craig Kimbrel, ATL

Rp Aroldis Chapman, CIN

Rp Bobby Parnell, NYM

**Final Vote Candidates**

Sp Shelby Miller (STL), Sp Stephen Strasburg (WAS), Sp Jeff Locke (PIT), Sp Mike Leake (CIN), Sp Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hadn't voted once all season long until today. Now I've logged over 750 votes this afternoon for the following:


1B Chris Davis

2B Kipnis

SS Hardy

3B M. Cabrera

C Mauer

DH Ortiz

OF Trout

OF Jones

OF Bautista


1B Goldschmidt

2B Carpenter

SS Segura

3B Wright

C Molina

OF Carlos Gonzalez

OF Carlos Gomez

OF McCutchen

I thought about voting for Manny over Cabrera but I couldn't. If Manny was still ahead of him in WAR and didn't cool off in the month of June then I would have enjoyed voting for him.

Goldschmidt vs Votto took me the longest to choose. I almost took Votto but decided Goldschmidt for really no particular reason.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought about voting for Manny over Cabrera but I couldn't. If Manny was still ahead of him in WAR and didn't cool off in the month of June then I would have enjoyed voting for him.

Baseball reference still has Machado ahead, 5.0 to 4.8.


Nice list Spy Fox, I wouldn't have Jones starting in the AL and I would have Puig in the final four vote in the NL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


C Joe Mauer

1B Chris Davis

2B Dustin Pedroia

SS Jhonny Peralta

3B Miguel Cabrera

LF Mike Trout

CF Jacoby Ellsbury

RF Ben Zobrist

DH David Ortiz





SP Max Scherzer

CL Mariano Rivera


C Yadier Molina

1B Paul Goldschmidt

2B Matt Carpenter

SS Everth Cabrera (Tulo is hurt)

3B David Wright

LF Carlos Gonzalez

CF Andrew McCutchen

RF Carlos Gomez (NL RFers suck so I'm putting a CF there)

DH Buster Posey

Joey Votto

Gerardo Parra

Jean Segura

Russell Martin

SP Matt Harvey

CL Craig Kimbrel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice list Spy Fox, I wouldn't have Jones starting in the AL and I would have Puig in the final four vote in the NL.

Thanks. And yeah Jones is the one place I definitely gave weight to my Orioles fandom.. I'm not convinced that Jones is one of the best three AL outfielders this year, but it's a relatively weak field compared to the NL outfielders and there wasn't anyone who was CLEARLY more deserving than Jones, so I put him in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmm, some questionable home-team selections by the managers. I'd argue that Fielder and Hunter from DET and Bumgarner and Scutaro from SFG are some of the more surprising picks. All of them are having pretty good seasons, but in all four cases there are other candidates from teams that aren't the manager's that are pretty undeniably having better seasons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • This is an Orioles Hangout! It’s important, because it’s the dreaded MFY. The Evil Empire. It’s the #$@!*&@^*! Yankees. All wins are extra glorious, and the beer tastes colder against the pin-stripers and losses are always a wee bit more bitter. Rich against poor, good against evil, and every battle is a chance to make the world a better place.
    • Back to Gunnar Henderson the incredible superstar 22 year-old baseball player, saw this interesting article about short stop rankings. https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/40369915/mlb-shortstop-draft-bobby-witt-jr-gunnar-henderson-corey-seager-no-1-pick
    • I disagree about the Flaherty and Fujinama "acquisitions" (and I use that term VERY LOOSELY) last season. They both represented "unforced errors" and untimely hedging. Many (including myself) questioned the quality of the front part of our rotation beyond Bradish. It was hard to see that we had excellent depth in the starting rotation. But not the kind of quality up top to succeed through multiple rounds of the playoffs. Flaherty was literally one of the worse starting pitchers that was available. I understand that Elias was working on Cease. But you have to have a credible plan B. You can jump from plan A to plan F (break glass in case of emergency). Flaherty was so bad with us (IMO predictably) that he wasn't an option to start a postseason game and Fujinama wasn't even worth considering to appear on the roster.  IMO those were hedging trades that were made trying to be as cheap as possible when the roster was already as lost costing as could be. I understand that spending is inevitably an ownership choice. So, hopefully without the stench of Scrooge McAngelos around this time, Elias won't have such limiting hinderances to deal with.
    • Another step closer as the league now giving 100% run to the option people like better starting next week. https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/40377474/abs-challenge-system-set-used-triple-starting-june-25 Today and next two days sound like end of the line for full ABS withholding some valuable extra strikes on Chayce McDermott's nasty breaking pitches.
    • Jeff Kemp and Brian Holloway were two years behind me in high school.  Also Olympic Gold Medalist Mike Barrowman and Darren Star (Beverly Hills 90210 creator) and a few others.  And me.  
    • First Brooks Robinson and now Gunnar...those O's will never learn. Drafting sketchy players from sketchy high schools.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

  • Create New...