Jump to content

How about an all-MLB team?


Recommended Posts

Posting about Chris Hoiles' career 0 All-Star games when he was almost certainly deserving of one got me thinking about the limited utility of career AS appearances as a way of evaluating players historically.

And the AS game has a lot of weaknesses in this respect: fans' votes are often for sentimental reasons (Cal's last game), managers' picks are sometimes questionable (hello, Cito), every team must have a representative, and the game is played when only about half the season is in the books.

I don't want to change the AS game itself; I think a lot of those rules that make historical numbers tricky are good ones for purposes of the game itself. And loath as I would usually be to suggest borrowing ideas from basketball, I think the NBA does this well: there's an All-Star exhibition game; then, at the end of the season, they select the all-NBA players, 1st team and 2nd team.

Why not do that in baseball as well? Reward the players who were the best at each position. Probably should have either an all-AL and all-NL, maybe 1 team per league, maybe 2. Or could just have 1st team all-MLB and 2nd team all-MLB.

I guess baseball isn't in especially dire need of another set of offseason awards, but people do use # of AS appearances when talking about HoF candidacies etc.


Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • I would be happy with a trade of Cowser and Ortiz for Cease, but I’m not too stuck on Cease.  There are other guys who fit the bill.  But if we end the offseason without a significant pitching addition and could have gotten Cease for those two, I’ll be unhappy about it.   
    • 1. Jackson Holliday SS 2. Samuel Basallo C 3. Coby Mayo 3B 4. Colton Cowser OF 5. Heston Kjerstad OF 6. DL Hall LHP 7. Joey Ortiz SS 8. Connor Norby 2B 9. Enrique Bradfield OF 10. Chayce McDermott RHP
    • Alex Verdugo is up 11-4 on Dean Kremer by rWAR after 2023.     
    • For now. Projected 2027 Lineup Catcher: Adley Rutschman (29) First Base: Ryan Mountcastle (30) Second Base: Jackson Holliday (23) Third Base: Coby Mayo (25) Shortstop: Gunnar Henderson (26) Left Field: Colton Cowser (27) Center Field: Enrique Bradfield Jr. (25) Right Field: Heston Kjerstad (28) Designated Hitter: Samuel Basallo (22) No. 1 Starter: Grayson Rodriguez (27) No. 2 Starter: Kyle Bradish (30) No. 3 Starter: DL Hall (28) No. 4 Starter: Dean Kremer (31) No. 5 Starter: Chayce McDermott (28) Closer: Felix Bautista (32) Listed below are the prospects with the best tools within the organization. To go directly to Baltimore’s Top 10, click here. Best Tools Best Hitter for Average: Jackson Holliday Best Power Hitter: Samuel Basallo Best Strike-Zone Discipline: Jackson Holliday Fastest Baserunner: Enrique Bradfield Jr. Best Athlete: Jackson Holliday Best Fastball: DL Hall Best Curveball: Trace Bright Best Slider: DL Hall Best Changeup: DL Hall Best Control: Alex Pham Best Defensive Catcher: Silas Ardoin Best Defensive Infielder: Joey Ortiz Best Infield Arm: Coby Mayo Best Defensive Outfielder: Enrique Bradfield Jr. Best Outfield Arm: Jud Fabian
    • Probably not the kind I’m talking about.  I’m talking about more guys who are at least the quality of McDermott, Povich and Johnson.   
    • Looks like Nick Martinez is also pulling $13mm AAV - from Cincinnati, 2-years and an opt-out in his case according to early reports. https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/39010979/reds-rhp-nick-martinez-agree-26m-deal-sources-say Severino and Martinez both ~30% above Fangraphs crowdsourced guesses.
    • I think  Elias will trade for minor league pitching depth this off season.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...