Jump to content

Computers should call balls and strikes and baseball is an institution of anachronism

Barnaby Graves

Recommended Posts

With cameras and technology and solid state drives and the transistor radio and penicillin, by this point, it's technologically feasible to track a baseball. It happens all the time. For several years now I have been able to use MLB gameday to see exactly where a pitch was during each millisecond of its life.

So how come umpires can't do that?

Let's pretend every single person in the world has a cell phone tuned through the internet to watch an Orioles game on MLB Gameday. Every single person except the home plate umpire who just happens to be C.B. Bucknor.

So here comes the pitch and it's a strike. It's a strike but the catcher had to move his glove to get the ball. He framed it on the lower outside corner, it came in high and inside but low and behold, according to the rules of baseball, it was a strike.

But C.B. Bucknor saw the catcher move his glove to catch the ball. Therefore the pitcher did not do his job and it was a ball.

Think this is unrealistic? This happens all the time and it's terrible. In fact even if you disagree with my premise you've seen this kind of thing happen and you know I'm not making it up. And it's garbage.

I don't care if one team is winning by 20, or Greg Maddux is pitching to some douchebag rookie, strikes and balls should follow the rigid rules set forth by the rulebook. There should be no room for negotiation. It degrades the integrity of the game to give wiggle room. But before, we could realistically say, it's impossible to call balls and strikes because technology is not there.

But we cannot say that anymore. The only reason not to get things right is laziness. I'm ready for the robots.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's the one Palmer said "isn't a good umpire, and never has been," right?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I remember several years back there was a game (playing the Jays I think?) where Bucknor missed at least 20 pitches per Pitch FX. Like almost 10% of what was thrown in that game. It was absolutely ridiculous.

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • If you’d asked me a few weeks ago, I probably would have told you that I didn’t care if Aaron Judge hit homer 60, 61 or 62 against us.    I’m not sure what’s changed, but in the words of the great Mox from Varsity Blues, “I say, ‘**** that.’”  I do not want to see our guys pitching to him this weekend.    I do not want to see Judge (who, for the record, I don’t have much of a problem with) celebrating at our expense. I don’t want to see his teammates celebrating at our expense. I sure as hell don’t want to see their fans celebrating at our expense.    Nothing would please me more this weekend than seeing Yankee fans crying about how we walked Judge 12-15 times over three games and how they bought tickets to see him hit #62 and blah blah blah.  Nothing would please me more than, after years of seeing Judge destroy our pitching, giving him absolutely nothing to hit and having him stand on first base all weekend while the boos rain down. I want us to be the bad guys. I want us to be the killjoys.  I do not want Hyde to give in. And even if he does have our guys pitch to Judge, I want our guys to be smart and throw everything in the dirt. Or airmail it over the home plate umpire.    I doubt it happens.  I’m sure some poor sap like Baumann or Baker or Krehbiel or  Reed will go down in history as the sucker who grooved a belt high fastball to Judge for #62. He’ll be on replays forever.  And after the game he’ll give some stock answer about “wanting to challenge him” or something which is silly because our pitching hasn’t ever been a challenge for Judge.    So, Hyde and/or Elias, if you’re reading, just walk Judge all weekend long. Make the Yankees and their fans miserable. Be the bad guys. Don’t let anyone have fun at our expense. It’s a new era for Orioles baseball, we’re no longer a laughingstock. No longer a team to set records against. No longer a team to beat up on.  Do not give in.    Milligan, out. 
    • I think it's pretty simple... they like him more than Tyler Nevin as a backup 1B, and they don't trust anyone else on the team to play first base. There were reports of Santander and Gunnar taking reps at first but nothing saying that the results were passable. I'm guessing they didn't like what they saw.
    • Not to mention this was AFTER Hays ruined the chances last night by GIDP against Barnes and like clockwork he repeats the feat. So yea Mullins just might have been a better option there.
    • Well, Chirinos did hit a homer!  
    • I feel like Elias has decided recently that they are out of it, and now its about securing better odds for the draft lottery by putting out lineups like today's.  
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...