Jump to content

3B defense is hurtin'


Frobby

Recommended Posts

Johnson is not a third baseman. Before this year, he had played 16 MLB games at third (all in 2013). The Yankees, out of desperation, tried him there and he was bad. Chris Davis, who has a lot more big-league experience at 3B (87) games, may be as good or better at third. Johnson is adequate at 2B and provides a back-up there when Flaherty is filling in elsewhere. And I guess for shifted defenses against lefties, he's fine as a second 2B. If it were my team, I'd try Walker or Clevenger at 1B and Davis at 3B until Pearce is available or Hardy returns to allow Flaherty to play 3B.

I've learned not to question Duquette's moves. They don't always work, but I almost always can see what he's trying to do even if it sometimes takes me a while. But I'm still scratching my head on why he wanted Kelly Johnson. :confused:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 91
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I've learned not to question Duquette's moves. They don't always work, but I almost always can see what he's trying to do even if it sometimes takes me a while. But I'm still scratching my head on why he wanted Kelly Johnson. :confused:

I think it's as simple as we need a LH bat. He can hit for Schoop/Joseph/Paredes, then somebody else comes in for defense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was told the impact was to be marginal.

Yes Flaherty to third is the correct answer.

Marginal with Paredes playing third, or Marginal with Manny out for the season and whomever replaced him would be a marginal downgrade? The only guy I trust at 3RD on our team right now is Flaherty, Davis is going to play there when Pearce comes back, but I see Davis to be better than Paredes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marginal with Paredes playing third, or Marginal with Manny out for the season and whomever replaced him would be a marginal downgrade? The only guy I trust at 3RD on our team right now is Flaherty, Davis is going to play there when Pearce comes back, but I see Davis to be better than Paredes.

Just giving another poster a hard time since they were insistent that the difference between Manny and Davis was marginal.

SSS but Paredes looks like Reynolds over there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was told the impact was to be marginal.

Yes Flaherty to third is the correct answer.

Marginal with Paredes playing third, or Marginal with Manny out for the season and whomever replaced him would be a marginal downgrade? The only guy I trust at 3RD on our team right now is Flaherty, Davis is going to play there when Pearce comes back, but I see Davis to be better than Paredes.
Just giving another poster a hard time since they were insistent that the difference between Manny and Davis was marginal.

SSS but Paredes looks like Reynolds over there.

Aw, no love for Jimmy Walls? Alright sign me up for Ryan, too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd be fine with Davis back there.

This. The window for Jimmy to prove himself has rapidly closed. Poor guy. Kelly Johnson looked awful. Heck, I might have stopped that ball before it got to the OF (I doubt it because I never could field-ha ha).

I wouldn't be shocked to see Casilla up here as insurance. Someone suggested that in the game thread last night and I though it was a good idea. He is better at SS and 2B, but might work. If anyone has any intel on Casilla at 3b, much appreciated to share.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Slightly mystified as to what Johnson is going to bring to this team. Is he going to pinch hit for Flaherty or Schoop? I kind of doubt it. He's no good on defense. I think he's straight up injury insurance.

I thought that trade made no sense. Still do. I liked Dejesus. He has more value as insurance for Hardy than Kelly Johnson. Both are minimal value. Kelly Johnson blows, he better be able to hit!

I liked Weeks and his ability to get on base. Plus his speed. Again, more value than Kelly Johnson.

Almanzar? Don't get the love for that guy, but whatever. He seemed to be the most valuable piece of the 4 and that isnt' saying a lot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought that trade made no sense. Still do. I liked Dejesus. He has more value as insurance for Hardy than Kelly Johnson. Both are minimal value. Kelly Johnson blows, he better be able to hit!

I liked Weeks and his ability to get on base. Plus his speed. Again, more value than Kelly Johnson.

Almanzar? Don't get the love for that guy, but whatever. He seemed to be the most valuable piece of the 4 and that isnt' saying a lot.

I know they like Almanzar and I suppose De Jesus has limited upside, but I liked him, too. Johnson looks to be strictly an insurance policy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought that trade made no sense. Still do. I liked Dejesus. He has more value as insurance for Hardy than Kelly Johnson. Both are minimal value. Kelly Johnson blows, he better be able to hit!

I liked Weeks and his ability to get on base. Plus his speed. Again, more value than Kelly Johnson.

Almanzar? Don't get the love for that guy, but whatever. He seemed to be the most valuable piece of the 4 and that isnt' saying a lot.

Kelly Johnson rakes in OPACY. If he sees limited action and drives in a couple of runs the deal will be worth it. Also, if Almanzar becomes the next Jose Bautista the deal will be worth it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • I have to admit. I'm an addict. I'm an addict not of booze or drugs. I'm an addict for baseball .... It's still THE game for me and I love almost any team sport. But for me, when it's great, it's still the greatest game of them all. I hate to say it, but when my team wins ...it's like a hit of crack or coke and I have never and will never try those drugs. This one is a better high anyway. It's an adrenaline rush for me. It comes from my heart and soul. Like the other night in Anaheim I sat transfixed on the game. I dont need to look at the silly shell games on a scoreboard, nor hear what the players favorite singer is.. or eat a lot of junk, but I DO have to have my bag of peanuts. The Orioles were clinging to a one run lead, when, with the bases loaded, Mike Trout stepped up to the plate...a single and the game is tied...an extra base hit and the Orioles lose. Our pitcher Craig Kimbrel had to throw a strike to one of the all time greats, and somehow, someway, Trout looked at a third strike and the Orioles won. I lept into the air as if I had a million dollars on the game. I never bet on sports, but this was a better high than winning any bet anyway. Because it is pure and it comes from my deep place of caring when the 'Birds' win. Today in Anaheim, another nail biter, the game was in the ninth with two out and a runner on first. Suddenly the runner broke for second and catcher James McCann threw a strike to second base. Gunnar Henderson covering, made the tag and the ump called the runner out. And the game ended that way. Bang Bang. Personally I thought it was a blown call, but after review the call was upheld and the Orioles won another nail biter. I dont watch many other games, but every night I hit the crack pipe" of baseball. It's my addiction. I also love watching fantastic performers. Mookie Betts is an electric ballplayer . can do anything at the plate and in the field. The Orioles' Henderson is a must see ballplayer like Betts is. On Wednesday he hit a home run, a double, a single, drove in 3 runs got hit by a pitch , stole a base and made two game saving plays in the field. Baseball is a team sport but it's also watching the brilliant, mesmerizing individual performances. It's watching the best players in the world do what I think is the most difficult thing in sports , hit a baseball, throw a baseball, and field a baseball. It's hard to do. Anyway,it's still just April and it's a long, long season. Bryant Gumble once had a great line about the difference between football and baseball. He said "Baseball, is a never ending romance, but football is a one night stand." Yep, I'm an addict, a baseball junkie, and I make no apologies for it. I'll never go to rehab for my baseball addiction. I don't NEED to be cured. And I never will be. Jim Bouton said it best in "Ball Four" his great book. "In all the years you grip a baseball...you suddenly remember, it's really the other way around" Exactly.
    • Especially when you factor in the DL Hall trade too.  Suarez and Wells get bumped to the pen only if Bradish and Means are effective starters a decent part of the season.  Would the O's promote Povich or McDermott to pitch relief?  My guess is not anytime soon, but I dunno. A trade would for one or two arms would be best, but trading for good relief pitching is only harder now because so many teams can make the playoffs.  
    • But O'Hearn's numbers are inflated because he never bats against lefties, plus he's trash in the outfield.  If Santander's hitting does not improve this season of course you don't give him a QO, but that's unlikely.  He'll probably pick it up as the weather heats up.  Plus Tony plays at least a decent RF and can play first base too.   Like others have said, should the O's offer Santander a QO?  Maybe -- it depends on how he performs and how Kjerstad and Stowers perform.  
    • Wait, since when is money no object? It remains to be seen what the budget constraints are going to be with the new ownership, but if Santander is projected to put up 3.0 WAR for $20 million and his replacement (Kjerstad/Cowser/Stowers...) can put up 2.5 WAR for less than a million then that will be factored in.  The goal will never be about being better than the other 29 teams in a payroll vacuum.
    • I think you have a good understanding and I assume you’ve read Ted Williams Science of Hitting.  It’s all about lining up planes of pitch and bat.  Historically with sinkers and low strikes a higher attack angle played and was more in alignment with pitch plane.  In today’s game of spin and high zone fastball an uppercut swing gives you minimal chance and results in top spin grounders and swing & miss. 
    • I'll bow to your expertise even if it seems unlikely to my laymen understanding. 
    • Actually it will.  As you noted.  MLB pitch plane is like 2-3 degrees.  The more your attack angle increased the more you’re hitting a top spin tennis return.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...