Jump to content

The Economist: One Swing Is All You Need


Recommended Posts


Observers familiar with the unreliable nature of baseball statistics over short time frames will surely warn that expectations for Mr Rodriguez need to be kept in check. Robert "Voros" McCracken, an early and influential quantitative analyst of the sport, once memorably wrote that any MLB hitter can do just about anything, good or bad, in a mere 60 at-bats (a little over two weeks of play). Countless players have hit four home runs in a span of 35 at-bats or less, as Mr Rodriguez has so far this year, and gone on to achieve little. In 2006 the long-forgotten Chris Shelton hit nine homers in his first 51 at-bats. He mustered just seven more longballs over his remaining 322 at-bats that season.

However, the sabermetric canon also includes a caveat to "Voros's law" about the volatility of small sample sizes. Although the overwhelming majority of events that can transpire in baseball over a brief time period cannot be distinguished statistically from random variation, a handful of accomplishments are so rare that even a single game can contain impressive predictive power. Bill James, the father of modern baseball analysis, called this principle "signature significance". In one well-known example, of the 14 pitchers who have struck out 18 or more batters in a nine-inning game during the past century, 12 were at least All-Stars, and six are in the Hall of Fame. Mr Rodriguez's mammoth blast might well be a similar case. After all, of the 38,143 homers hit in MLB since 2007 the first year that HitTracker recorded the path of every ball to leave the yard just 25 (0.06%, or one in 1,525) traveled 477 feet or more.

In order to determine how much predictive power a single deep home run can provide, I started with every batter who played between 2007 and 2014. I first discarded all their ground balls and pop-ups, since balls on those trajectories cannot become homers no matter how hard they are hit. I then measured the share of their other batted balls?the line drives and outfield flies?that turned into home runs, a standard measure of a batter?s power. If ultra-long home runs truly have signature significance, then players who hit even one ball as deep as Mr Rodr?guez?s should fare well above average in this category over the course of an entire season.
For each foot beyond the distance of a league-average longball (usually just under 400 feet) that any individual home run travels, an additional 0.06% of that batters' other line drives and outfield fly balls in that season become home runs.
Guys who are washed up just don't hit 477-foot homers. Not even once.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was rather shocked at the distance of the April series HR by A-Rod. I think it hit about two rows deep into the section behind the concrete, past all of the first section of LF seats, just under the overhang. He's clearly able to get good wood on the ball. His batting average was in the low .230s as of this morning. But it's a long year and it'll be interesting to see what unfolds. Just makes me wonder if he'll be healthy all year. I liked him as a Mariner, became less enamored of him as a Ranger and then completely repulsed by him as a Yankee (the swipe at the first base mitt vs. Boston in the ALCS). I admire what talent he had, but a guy so unlikeable with his willingness to throw people under the bus as he's done destroyed any good will there was left for me to offer. I think I'm not alone with this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Taking what I have seen from ST and past performance: 1)  Grayson Rodriguez -  He is not there yet but over the course of 2023 I think he become the staff ace.   I am not even sure he makes the rotation to begin the season but he has the best stuff and makeup to be the O's best starter. 100 IP   3.50 ERA  2) DL Hall -  He is changing from a thrower to a pitchers.  His pitches are off the chart but he has to calm down.  Still has to master his pitches from the stretch.   Begins as AAA but he is likely to find his control early in the season. TOR Starter in the making. 100 IP   3.50 ERA 3) Kyle Bradish  -  Has the pitches and the durability.  Will blow up now and then but overall he has he stuff to beat any team on a given day.   Will be going deep in games soon.  #2 stuff. 170 IP   3.28 ERA (like 2nd half) 4) Dean Kremer -  Growing into a solid starter.   His stuff is there.   #3 Stuff 160 IP  3.23 ERA (like last year) 5) John Means -   Former All Star just need to get healthy.  See him in July.  May be better in 2024 than in 2023.  #3 stuff 75 IP  3.81 ERA (Career ERA) 6) Tyler Wells -  He goes 5 inning and allow 1 run, he could be in the rotation to begin the season.   Average fastball but he has 5 pitches.  #4 starter stuff 130 IP   3.38 ERA  (last year 1st half) 7)   Cole Irvin -  I have enjoyed watching him this spring but he is only facing AAA competition.   I still need to understand  why he had a 5.29 ERA away from Oakland Stadium.   #5  Capable of  180 IP    4.20 ERA 8  Kyle Gibson -  The O's defense, the Wall and Holt/Holmes  coaching will help him but he is only a #5.   Similar to Jordan Lyles. May be traded in July for  a prospect. 100 IP   4.32 ERA 9)  Spenser Watkins -  Good backup starter who pitches better as a starter than a reliever.  Will probably not see a lot of time in the majors.  Capable of 140 IP  4.17 ERA as a starter but will probably not get that opportunity in the majors. 10)  Voth  - Probably a mid/long reliever and swing man.   Had a nice year as a starter for the O's last year.  3.04 ERA  (like last season) 11) Bruce Zimmermann -  Looks better this spring but I really can't place him after last years performance.      
    • "He's a funny guy, that parrot, isn't he?" "He sure is."
    • Wells was very good today. Grayson was great last year in triple a and is obviously a top prospect, but you’d be hard pressed to say he was one of the orioles top 5 starters this spring 
    • Have watched every game that's been on TV, whether by MASN or the other networks.  Currently watching Pittsburgh Sportsnet broadcast.  Have listened to every game but 2, followed the last Grayson Rodriguez game on Gameday which was incredibly tedious, as they didn't note each pitch, only the outcome of each at bat.  Before I met weams, I used to say I'd never meet anyone who'd put up with the amount of baseball I watch -- he was my perfect match, watched just as much as I did!  But then, you guys knew that. 
    • I’m not a huge fan of Mountcastle and I don’t think he’s going to have a great season at all. So because I’m always wrong, I’m betting that it’ll be him! 🤣
    • Yea, I'm just using the song title as an excuse to post more of my new find. Sorry but they are just really good.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...