Jump to content

Top 30 prospects tomorrow


Tony-OH

Recommended Posts

This has got to be one of the hardest lists to put together in years. And there will be major incongruity between other people's lists.

You have top 2 prospects that are injured. A 1B that can go anywhere in the top 10 depending who you talk to. A recent 1st round pick that couldnt hit his own weight. Then you also have guys like Givens, Wright, Drake and Wilson who havent lost their prospect status. Plus the additions of guys in minor trades this year that are actually prospects in our system. Seems like a whole bunch of inseparable blah.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This has got to be one of the hardest lists to put together in years. And there will be major incongruity between other people's lists.

You have top 2 prospects that are injured. A 1B that can go anywhere in the top 10 depending who you talk to. A recent 1st round pick that couldnt hit his own weight. Then you also have guys like Givens, Wright, Drake and Wilson who havent lost their prospect status. Plus the additions of guys in minor trades this year that are actually prospects in our system. Seems like a whole bunch of inseparable blah.

Sent from my LG-D850 using Tapatalk

It is certainly not a strong system.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looking forward to it! I need to see the lists of others before I make my own though. I tend to forget guys after about 15 or so :)

Eh, screw it. I used the MLB.com list as a bit of a template so I may be leaving out some important names here:

1. Reyes

2. Bundy

3. Harvey

4. Sisco

5. Givens

6. Mancini

7. Hess

8. Fenter

9. Stewart

10. Wright

11. Wilson

12. Mountcastle

13. Walker

14. Heim

15. Murphy

16. Gunkel

17. Scott

18. Mullins

19. McKenna

20. Yaz

21. Bridwell

22. Hart

23. Kline

24. Curran

25. Marin

26. Cleavinger

27. Means

28. T. Berry

29. Gonzalez

30. Ferguson

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm leaving Givens, Wright, Wilson off my list because I think they're finished products. But I'm including Garcia. Have fun making sense of that. I'm rolling with...

1. Bundy

2. Harvey

3. Cisco (so here's where the real list starts)

4. Reyes

5. Mancini( Throwing darts time)

6. Jason Garcia-Starting Pitcher

7. Walker

8. Hess

9. Dariel Alvarez

10. Gunkel

11. DJ Stewart

12. Mountcastle

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We will announce our top 30 prospects tomorrow with profiles available to plus members for the top 20 over the next week or so.

So what are your lists? Will there be any under the radar selections this year?

Can antidepressants be included? :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Harvey

2. Bundy

3. Reyes

4. Sisco

5. Givens

6. Mancini

7. Hess

8. Fenter

9. Stewart

10. Wright

11. Wilson

12. Mountcastle

13. Heim

14. Murphy

14A. Dariel Alvarez

14B. Ariel Miranda

14C. Chris Lee

15. Walker

16. Tanner Scott

17. Joe Gunkel

18. Cedric Mullins

19. McKenna

20. Adrian Marin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Even though our system is crappy, I am excited to see the writeups.

The prospect list and scouting reports are what got me hooked on this site in the 15? years ago. That and Paul's game recaps while losing 90 a year. Thanks for the hard work y'all out into this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The prospect list and scouting reports are what got me hooked on this site in the 15? years ago. That and Paul's game recaps while losing 90 a year. Thanks for the hard work y'all out into this.

Tony and Chris do the prospects and a darned good job of it. Amazing the level of contacts and input those two have in compiling these.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Also, the 3-2 pitch to Witt that was called ball four for the first walk had been called a strike all night.  In fact, far worse pitches had been called strikes, especially for the Royals’ pitchers.   And were called strikes afterwards.   
    • I don’t think they need to be only for homegrown guys. Just the right guys! I think Burnes is a right guy. Now if we can’t extend him before he hits free agency and he gets 10 year 30 million per from someone you have to walk away. Id try an extension that has a higher AAV but a shorter term. Say you expect him to get $30 per for 10 in free agency. Then give him 7 years and perhaps an opt out after 4. 
    • You have to find a way to get him on the ML team. 
    • Yeah I was hopeful for him but after seeing last night (where it all caught up to him) I just don't think he has the stuff any more. He used to have an excellent 2 seamer with good velocity and arm side run but that doesn't seem to exist anymore with the velocity drop.
    • Well I was just a peon when I worked there, so it’s not like that experience mattered in my decision. And my view on extensions isn’t you are paying for past years. Hell, I would sign Holliday today and Gunnar is only a year into things. The issue with the extensions is that you are already have the player(s) locked up for most of the years anyway. So, when you sign them to an extension, you are guaranteeing 7-9 years but really all you are gaining is 2-3 years.  It’s a lot of money and guarantees for only a few years. Now, the one thing that I have talked about that is important here is if you don’t extend them, do you look to trade them 1-2 years away from free agency because you don’t want to lose a talent like Gunnar, for example, for nothing.  So, maybe the extension buys you a few additional years on top of what are already getting.  OTOH, you may just decide to go for it with the player and lose them for nothing. I guess you always have the option of going the Tatis route and go 14-15 years but I’m not sure of anyone who is advocating for that or would be ok with that.  As for your business decision point here..I think that’s probably the biggest reason you do it…because players like the commitment and the fans like the commitment and there is value to that.
    • Honestly, I’m much more concerned about Tate than Akin.   91.7 mph avg velocity on the sinker. 11.4% K rate. 11.4% BB rate. 91.8 mph exit velocity. 53.8% hard hit rate. 9.8% whiff rate. 14.5% chase rate. 3.8% swinging strike rate. 4.50 ERA. 5.70 FIP. 5.49 xFIP. 5.06 SIERRA.  6.30 xERA. 84 stuff+ on sinker. 88 location+ on sinker. The ground ball rate is still good, but I’m not sure that’s going to be enough to save him.    
    • Facing Ragans today. Must starts include Rutschman, Mountcastle, and McCann. Must sit is Holliday.   I think Adley might DH today unless Burnes insists on him catching his stuff.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...