Jump to content

Orioles' First-Half Recap: Five Things That Went Wrong


PressBoxOnline

Recommended Posts

21 minutes ago, PressBoxOnline said:

While it's easy to point to starting pitching, Rich Dubroff takes a look at five things that went wrong for the Baltimore Orioles during the season's first half.

https://www.pressboxonline.com/2017/07/10/orioles-first-half-recap-five-things-that-went-wrong
 

You have plenty more to look at than just batting average to be unimpressed with Hardy's 2017 performance.

Davis was rather unimpressive as well when he was playing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do think the team has missed Hardy. While I've certainly been critical of his declining offense, and at times amazed by Buck's refusal to PH for him, I do think he's a stabilizing influence out there. I'm not big on the contribution of intangibles to winning games, but it was my experience in team sports that there were certain guys whose presence on the field/court made you more confident, and inspired you to work harder and not do anything stupid. I think Hardy and Jones have been the Orioles' guys like that.

And other than Janish's defense and being more frequently pinch hit for, the guys who have filled in have pretty awful, although Tejada has been a more productive hitter lately.. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, spiritof66 said:

I do think the team has missed Hardy. While I've certainly been critical of his declining offense, and at times amazed by Buck's refusal to PH for him, I do think he's a stabilizing influence out there. I'm not big on the contribution of intangibles to winning games, but it was my experience in team sports that there were certain guys whose presence on the field/court made you more confident, and inspired you to work harder and not do anything stupid. I think Hardy and Jones have been the Orioles' guys like that.

And other than Janish's defense and being more frequently pinch hit for, the guys who have filled in have pretty awful, although Tejada has been a more productive hitter lately.. 

They have problems if a guy in his 10th year, a guy in his sixth year and a guy in his fifth year need a stabilizing influence.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, LookitsPuck said:

Top 5 in order:

1. Gausman huge regression

2. Ubaldo worse than normal (which is bad)

3. Tillman pitching injured and ineffective

4. Miley regression like woah

5. Britton injury

I'd put Jones, Davis, Trumbo and Machado under-performing ahead of Britton.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This season really took a turn after the Friday night game in NY when we blew an enormous lead and our bullpen, which had still been very good even without Britton, really let us down. It started happening more routinely after that, because the starters were burning out the bullpen arms even earlier in the season than normal. Gausman, Miley, Tillman, and Jimenez really gutted them. 

I still see a major run in this team, but if it doesn't happen soon, it won't matter. Plenty of teams go from bubble to contender in July and August. This could be one of those teams - the talent is there. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

I'd put Jones, Davis, Trumbo and Machado under-performing ahead of Britton.

 

I was really just going with single names. Not having Britton for essentially 2 months and then showing the clear lack of impact relief depth in the organization as well as putting more usage on top 3 (Givens, Brach, O'Day) really screwed the pooch on quite a few games. It'd be different if they had any meaningful depth...but look at the sheer number of moves this year relative to last year. It was almost entirely because nobody really stepped up. 

That said, I don't think the guys you mentioned (aside from Machado) have underperformed too off the mark of their last 3 years. Unless you're expecting Trumbo to repeat an obvious outlier/career year. It seems that Jones, Trumbo and Davis are all within 30-50 points of their last 3 years. 

Machado is the biggest problem offensively. A 100 drop in OPS is pretty damn large...and his defense has taken a hit this year, too. So I could see an argument to swap Machado w/ Britton. But the other 3 I'm not too perturbed at considering their age and last 3 years.

  • Jones 2017: .267/.305/.436 - .741 OPS
  • Jones Last 3: .272/.310/.459 - .769 OPS
  • Trumbo 2017: .254/.316/.422 - .738 OPS
  • Trumbo Last 3: .253/.309/.477 - .786 OPS
  • Davis 2017: .226/.320/.461 - .781 OPS
  • Davis Last 3: .228/.334/.481 - .814 OPS
  • Machado 2017: .230/.296/.445 - .741 OPS 
  • Machado Last 3: .288/.346/.500 - .846 OPS
Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, LookitsPuck said:

 

I was really just going with single names. Not having Britton for essentially 2 months and then showing the clear lack of impact relief depth in the organization as well as putting more usage on top 3 (Givens, Brach, O'Day) really screwed the pooch on quite a few games. It'd be different if they had any meaningful depth...but look at the sheer number of moves this year relative to last year. It was almost entirely because nobody really stepped up. 

That said, I don't think the guys you mentioned (aside from Machado) have underperformed too off the mark of their last 3 years. Unless you're expecting Trumbo to repeat an obvious outlier/career year. It seems that Jones, Trumbo and Davis are all within 30-50 points of their last 3 years. 

Machado is the biggest problem offensively. A 100 drop in OPS is pretty damn large...and his defense has taken a hit this year, too. So I could see an argument to swap Machado w/ Britton. But the other 3 I'm not too perturbed at considering their age and last 3 years.

  • Jones 2017: .267/.305/.436 - .741 OPS
  • Jones Last 3: .272/.310/.459 - .769 OPS
  • Trumbo 2017: .254/.316/.422 - .738 OPS
  • Trumbo Last 3: .253/.309/.477 - .786 OPS
  • Davis 2017: .226/.320/.461 - .781 OPS
  • Davis Last 3: .228/.334/.481 - .814 OPS
  • Machado 2017: .230/.296/.445 - .741 OPS 
  • Machado Last 3: .288/.346/.500 - .846 OPS

I think that if Britton is out and O'Day is healthy the overall impact isn't that significant.  The impact of Britton's injury has been magnified by O'Day's issues.  You should be able to go into games with a healthy Brach, O'Day and Givens and feel pretty good about things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

I think that if Britton is out and O'Day is healthy the overall impact isn't that significant.  The impact of Britton's injury has been magnified by O'Day's issues.  You should be able to go into games with a healthy Brach, O'Day and Givens and feel pretty good about things.

You would if you had a rotation that could go 6 innings regularly.  It's bad when you feel good that an Orioles starter made it through 5 full innings.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

I think that if Britton is out and O'Day is healthy the overall impact isn't that significant.  The impact of Britton's injury has been magnified by O'Day's issues.  You should be able to go into games with a healthy Brach, O'Day and Givens and feel pretty good about things.

Probably fair.    Meanwhile, the bullpen has been reasonably effective, as evidenced by its 17-10 record, +2.86 WPA (7th in MLB), and 71% save percentage (tied for 4th in the AL).     That compares to last year's 32-15, 10.22 WPA (1st in MLB) and 79% save percentage (1st in AL).    So, a lesser performance to be sure, but still well above average.    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, spiritof66 said:

Maybe do. But Manny and Jonathan aren't exactly veterans, and you left out Mancini.

I also left out the backup middle infielders.  How many games have the O's had Hardy at SS and Mancini at first?  Can't miss what you never had.

I went with the established starters at each position.

In my accounting anyone that has reached arbitration counts as a vet. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Maddux got his share of Ks and he had 15 years of a BB rate of 1.5 or lower and his career BB rate was 1.8.  
    • It’s one start. It means nothing, literally nothing. Project those starts out over a longer period of time. Which starter would you expect to be more successful? The one throwing more strikes, missing more bats and getting more Ks or the one who is dependent upon luck?    Most of this is elementary school math that simply can’t be argued against, at least intelligently.
    • With their 96th win last, with 7 games remaining, the 2023 O’s tied the 2014 AL East Champion Orioles for the 12th most wins in Orioles history.   And, that means they are tied for the most wins any Orioles team has had in the last 26 years. Coming on the heels of a slightly disappointing 85-win 2013 season in which the O’s had not played well down the stretch, the Orioles were quiet most of the 2013-14 winter, to the consternation of their fans.  Small moves that proved important later were trading minor leaguer Devin Jones for reliever Brad Brach in December and signing Demon Young as a reserve in January.   Bigger moves came after spring training already was underway.  First the O’s signed Ubaldo Jimenez to a 4-year, $50 mm contract, and then they signed Nelson Cruz to a one year, $8 mm deal.  Nevertheless, the team got off to a slow start.  Manny Machado missed all of April while recovering from 2013 knee surgery, and Matt Wieters’ season ended on May 10 when he tore his UCL, requiring TJ surgery.   The O’s installed rookie Caleb Joseph as the primary catcher and traded for Nick Hundley in late May to solidify the position.   By the end of May, the O’s were still treading water at 27-27.  But in June, they began playing a bit better, reaching 46-39 and tying for the division lead on July 3.   They took sole possession of first place while sweeping a July 5 doubleheader, and never relinquished it the remainder of the season, going 17-8 in July, 19-9 in August, and 17-10 in September, running away with the AL East title at 96-66, 12 games ahead of the second-place Yankees.  Along the way, they won the season series with all four of their AL East rivals, in  what  as a relatively weak year for the division. There were many key contributors to the 2014 Orioles.  Nelson Cruz, on a “prove it” contract after a PED suspension, certainly proved it, hitting 40 homers with 108 RBI.  Adam Jones had his third straight All Star/Gold Glove year, smacking 29 homers and knocking in 96.  JJ Hardy won his third straight Gold Glove, and Nick Markakis won his first.  Steve Pearce, picked up off the waiver wire in 2013, released in late April and then re-signed two days later, had a 5.8 rWAR season and a .930 OPS, seeing time at DH, 1B and both corner OF spots.   The team succeeded even though Wieters missed the final 4.5 months with his TJ surgery, Manny missed half the season (including the first month and the last two) with knee surgeries, and Chris Davis, who was having a down season anyway, suspended through the end of the season in mid-September for using Adderall medication without an exemption.  And the main reason the O’s were able to overcome all that was the pitching.   The starting pitchers were incredibly healthy all year, with 6 starters making all but one start, and the one was the second game of a doubleheader.  Chris Tillman (13-6, 3.34 ERA), Wei Yin Chen (16-6, 3.54), Bud Norris (15-8, 3.65), Miguel Gonzalez (10-9, 3.23) and second-pitcher Kevin Gausman (7-7, 3.57) all were excellent, and only expensive free agent Ubaldo Jimenez (6-9, 4.81) disappointed.   Good as the starters were, the bullpen was even better.  Zach Britton was installed as the closer in May and finished the year with 37 saves in 41 opportunities and a 1.65 ERA, Darren O’Day posted a 1.70 ERA, Tommy Hunter lost the closer job after some early hiccups but finished with A 2.97 ERA, and newcomer Brad Brach became a mainstay at 3.18.  What was already a very good bullpen became utterly dominant when the O’s added Andrew Miller at the trade deadline; he added 20 innings at a 1.35 ERA down the stretch.  Overall, the pitching staff finished 3rd in the AL with a 3.43 ERA, 3.61 for the starters (5th) and 3.10 for the relievers (3rd), and the bullpen had a 74% save rate, 3rd best in the league. Going into the playoffs, the O’s were first-round underdogs to the Tigers and their intimidating Big Three of Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander and David Price, but the O’s swept them in three games, with the signature moment being a three-run pinch hit double by Delmon Young in the 8th inning of Game 2 off a hapless Detroit bullpen, as the Orioles came back from a capping off a rally in which the O's came back from a 6-3 deficit and prevailed 7-6.   With surprising wild card Kansas City knocking off the Angels, who had the best record in the AL that year, the O’s path to the World Series seemed clear.  But alas, the Royals were a team of destiny, and swept the Orioles in 4 games, ending a fantastic season in ignominy that rankles many Orioles fans to this day. After that season, the O’s parted ways with longtime star Nick Markakis, and big 2014 contributors Nelson Cruz and Andrew Miller.   Dan Duquette flirted with a job with the Blue Jays, and his relationship with ownership never seemed the same after that.   There was a little more run left in the Duquette/Showalter O’s, but 2014 was the apex of that regime.
    • You talked about IP..what about the quality of those innings? Gibson had thrown a lot of innings but how much quality has there been?
    • There was this pitcher called Greg Maddux, perhaps you’ve heard of him?
    • I'm not sure what you're trying to argue because you practically supported his point. Under those pitch statistics is the fact that Grayson made it 5 innings. Means made it 7.1 (throwing less pitches). 
    • Nope There is a lot of history here that says that trying to prove anything to you is a waste of time.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...