Jump to content

Baseball America's Top 100 Prospects (2018)


wildbillhiccup

Recommended Posts

Posted

Mods - If there's another recent Orioles prospect thread feel free to merge this one. 

Baseball America has published its Top 100 Prospects (for 2018). Hays is 21, Sisco is 68, and Mountcastle is 71. I'm posting the top 20 below with a link to the full list. 

https://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/top-100-mlb-prospects-2018/#A1jJamrGhOPSCAeP.97

 

1. Ronald Acuna | OF | Braves ?

2. Shohei Ohtani | RHP | Angels ?

3. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | 3B | Blue Jays ?

4. Eloy Jimenez | OF | White Sox ?

5. Victor Robles | OF | Nationals ?

6. Gleyber Torres | SS | Yankees ?

7. Nick Senzel | 3B | Reds ?

8. Bo Bichette | SS | Blue Jays ?

9. Fernando Tatis Jr | SS | Padres ?

10. Forrest Whitley | RHP | Astros ?

11. Michael Kopech | RHP | White Sox ?

12. Mitch Keller | RHP | Pirates ?

13. Walker Buehler | RHP | Dodgers ?

14. Brent Honeywell | RHP | Rays ?

15. Kyle Tucker | OF | Astros ?

16. J.P. Crawford | SS | Phillies ?

17. Alex Reyes | RHP | Cardinals ?

18. Lewis Brinson | OF | Brewers ?

19. Willy Adames | SS | Rays ?

20. Francisco Mejia | C | Indians ?


Read more at https://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/top-100-mlb-prospects-2018/#7PeHVdtYgl5hYBlI.99

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted
7 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

Acuna over Ohtani?

My top 10, if anyone is interested, goes like this...

Ohtani

Reyes

Guerrero Jr

Acuna

Robles

Tatis Jr

Whitley

Torres

Kopech

Jimenez 

Edit: I posted a slightly different 10 on twitter a couple weeks ago, but my thoughts have evolved a little bit.

Posted

A blurb from the chat on Hunter Harvey.

 

  • J.P. (Springfield, IL): Thanks for chatting, guys. Did Hunter Harvey get any votes, and was his injury history the only factor which led to his omission?


J.J. Cooper: He was in consideration. When you ask if the injury history was the only factor, it depends on how broad you want to make "injury history." Even before he was shut down years ago, we had concerns (which we had heard from scouts) about his build and how durable he could be. He's thrown 144 innings in five pro seasons, so that will remain a concern. The stuff is really impressive, but the combination of a) durability questions b) no time above low Class A yet and c) the fact the stuff truly came together for him again for only a short stint at the end of the 2017 season leaves him off this Top 100. If he has a healthy, impressive season in 2018 I could see him easily cracking next year's list.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Camden_yardbird said:

Lot of Blue Jays on that list...and you would expect them to pick up another name off that list when they trade Donaldson.

They’ve made no noise about trading Donaldson, have they?

Posted
5 minutes ago, Camden_yardbird said:

Lot of Blue Jays on that list...and you would expect them to pick up another name off that list when they trade Donaldson.

Vlad Jr is an absolute stud, he's such a lock to hit that he'd be a top 10 prospect as a DH.

Posted

Did this on my own so not sure how accurate it is. Number of top 100 for AL East teams.

Balt 3

Bost 2

NY 5

Tor 4

TB 6

Based on what the media says about the yankees farm system I thought they would have 20 players on the list.

Posted
13 minutes ago, Fuzzball22 said:

Did this on my own so not sure how accurate it is. Number of top 100 for AL East teams.

Balt 3

Bost 2

NY 5

Tor 4

TB 6

Based on what the media says about the yankees farm system I thought they would have 20 players on the list.

5 is a lot, and you have to remember that Frazier and Judge graduated off that list in 2017.   Also, they’ve got a lot of depth once you get past the top 100 guys.  

Posted
1 hour ago, Can_of_corn said:

Acuna over Ohtani?

Acuna is 3.something years younger and dominated AA and AAA last season - playing CF.    

Posted
1 hour ago, Luke-OH said:

A blurb from the chat on Hunter Harvey.

 

  • J.P. (Springfield, IL): Thanks for chatting, guys. Did Hunter Harvey get any votes, and was his injury history the only factor which led to his omission?


J.J. Cooper: He was in consideration. When you ask if the injury history was the only factor, it depends on how broad you want to make "injury history." Even before he was shut down years ago, we had concerns (which we had heard from scouts) about his build and how durable he could be. He's thrown 144 innings in five pro seasons, so that will remain a concern. The stuff is really impressive, but the combination of a) durability questions b) no time above low Class A yet and c) the fact the stuff truly came together for him again for only a short stint at the end of the 2017 season leaves him off this Top 100. If he has a healthy, impressive season in 2018 I could see him easily cracking next year's list.

I thought BP's Orioles Top 10 nailed it when they pegged his Major League ETA as "the next time he is healthy two months in a row".

Posted

This seems like a big improvement from last year, when the Yankees had 7 players in the top 100 and all we had was Sisco at #99...

 

Austin Hays is going to be one of the most interesting Orioles storylines this year. I hope he puts up a ROY type year.

Posted
1 hour ago, Ruzious said:

Acuna is 3.something years younger and dominated AA and AAA last season - playing CF.    

Still.  From what I have read I am surprised by that ranking.

In no way is that meant as a slight on Acuna.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.



  • Posts

    • Cease would require more than that one would think.
    • 3 years of Kremer at  3m in 2025, Beavers,  and a draft pick for one year of Cease at 14m. Cease will get a QO and O's get draft choice back. Then O's add 4th starter from FA. Padres are considering cutting payroll.  
    • Neither St. Louis or Houston have a history of signing big name FAs.
    • Those 3 teams have no fans and have not won anything in terms of titles. Baltimore doesn’t need nor should it strive to be New York or Los Angeles. But there is nothing wrong with trying to run a model like St. Louis or Houston. The last 20 years of history of MLB have shown that you are not going to win a World Series by not spending in the top half of the league.
    • You literally just listed 3 teams that consistently go to the playoffs as mid-market, or lower, teams. Guess what, friend?  I have a secret for you.   That's exactly what the Orioles should aspire to be. I think some of ya'll are delusional about Baltimore's place in the pecking order.  Baltimore has a hell of a lot more in common with Cleveland or Pittsburgh that it does New York.
    • First, IMO he should be given the entire offseason before being judge or this conversation being had. Second, if this offseason goes the way it appears to be headed, 2025 will probably be too late. This was the offseason for David Rubenstein to prove that things are different. If he fails to do that, I think his brand/business is going to have a serious problem. They already couldn’t sell out playoff games which in some ways shows fan disengagement/disinterest. Now if they were too follow that up by going cheap and bringing back a worse team to begin 2025 after being sold so much hype and promise from all the young players & prospects, I fear by 2025 he will lose even more fans/potential customers attention. And in the day and age we leave in, people are not brand loyal anymore. They may not come back. If the pan of the Orioles are to be the Rays/Guardians/Brewers type franchise which has to survive with a disengaged/disinterested market, they may well be on their way. I really hope this is not the case.
    • I respect the sentiment that you may be agitated or annoyed by other fans/posters expressing complaints, worry, or anxiety. I get it. But the Orioles really can’t afford to alienate any fans or communicate to them through their actions “if you don’t like it, leave”. The already couldn’t sell out playoff games last year. Unless they want to truly become the Rays and be irrelevant in their own market.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...