Jump to content

Montanez not playing is a joke

mikezpen

By mikezpen
in Orioles Talk

Recommended Posts

mikezpen Major Leaguer

mikezpen

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Seems like most agree at least in principal. I have nothing against Payton; I think he's an asset if he comes back next year as a fourth outfielder.But you don't play bunch of 36 year-olds with no significant future over a 26 year-old who's hit the way Montanez has, not when you're dead last and going nowhere.Stick Markakis in center a few games and/or juggle the lineup the way Mackus suggests-that's fine.

What you have here is what you have every year in Baltimore. It doesn't matter how lousy the team is or how lousy its players are. The veterans play because they've punched in and drawn a paycheck all year. Merit has absolutely nothing to do with it.Dave Trembley is supposed to be this refreshing new kind of manager-well-all I'm seeing now is another Hargrove.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 158
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Mackus Hangout Grand Counsel

Mackus

Posted
Posted
Sports Guy and somebody else(Hank Scorpio?), have both said that they are hearing Payton is a huge problem in the clubhouse. Evidently he's always whining and complaining.
I haven't heard/seen that at all. The only thing this year is when someone asked him how it was going and he replied with something like "nothing a trade won't fix." Some people flipped out about that, I just took it as an offhand joking comment.

Maybe there is something behind the scenes going on that we don't know about, but he's said everything the right way publicly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Big Mac Veteran All-Star

Big Mac

Posted
Posted
I haven't heard/seen that at all. The only thing this year is when someone asked him how it was going and he replied with something like "nothing a trade won't fix." Some people flipped out about that, I just took it as an offhand joking comment.

Maybe there is something behind the scenes going on that we don't know about, but he's said everything the right way publicly.

http://forum.orioleshangout.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1438781&postcount=153

I've also been to a game this season where he flipped off a fan in my section.

Where there's smoke, there's fire.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
getxstoked Major Leaguer Cup of Coffee

getxstoked

Posted
Posted

Montanez may never even be a 4th OF... but that is to be determined... you know Payton won't even be an Oriole next year... there is no reason to start Payton over Montanez...

Except that Payton is a competent (not good, not great, but serviceable) centerfielder, and they'd rather not have 3 OFs out of position...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
getxstoked Major Leaguer Cup of Coffee

getxstoked

Posted
Posted
Who cares? You are already in last place.... you dont have a ton of youth on your pitching staff anyway, that you have to protect with defense...

And while Payton may be slightly better defensively vs Montanez...... Payton will not be back in 2009... it is a waist of time to give him at-bats...

BTW you have to factor in the fact that Payton has a 654 OPS overall, and a 523 OPS against RHP...

I think you're way off here, Payton is there because he's the best option in CF, and like it or not, Dave Trembley's job is to put the Orioles in the best position to win games, no matter how far out of the pennant race they may be, and at this moment, putting Payton in CF is what he has to do.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jenius AA

Jenius

Posted
Posted
I think you're way off here, Payton is there because he's the best option in CF, and like it or not, Dave Trembley's job is to put the Orioles in the best position to win games, no matter how far out of the pennant race they may be, and at this moment, putting Payton in CF is what he has to do.
This is the most accurate and insightful post in the thread so far, IMO. On a personal level, I'm disappointed Montanez isn't starting tonight...was looking forward to seeing him. Frankly, not many of us as fans WANT to see Payton playing with any regularity. I am certainly in the majority there. But I will concede that Trembley probably feels he has no choice defensively. Montanez and Markakis are both emergency CFs and not guys you really want there for any extended period. Payton, the last time he played full time in CF (for COL in 2004) had the 2nd best Zone Rating among MLB CFs. Granted that was 4 years ago, but I would estimate he's still one of the best fielding LFs in the league and probably average in CF.

Again, his bat is going to hurt us, but IF as I suspect Trembley feels no choice (and I think the frequency with which opposing hitters are putting balls in play against our pitchers is a factor here), then all this discussion about veterans getting too much slack, no commitment to rebuilding, etc. is moot.

Does anyone think Tike Redman would be preferable to Payton in CF? (an honest question...Redman played well for us down the stretch last year then fell off the map when we got Jones)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Big Mac Veteran All-Star

Big Mac

Posted
Posted
...Millar just hit a two-run homerun

And he is a FA after this season, it would be better to see what the kid can do.

For the record, I don't think you have to bench a particular person.

Huff can play first or 3rd every now and then in place of Mora and Millar, this allows Lou to play LF and Scott to DH. You can also give Luke some days off, he is pretty banged up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • OsFanSinceThe80s
      Yesterday's Lineup - Thank You Mike Elias and Sig Mejdal

      By OsFanSinceThe80s · Posted

      And Ramon Urias as well. Urias might eventually get squeezed out or turn into a backup, but he's been a vital part the last few years while we've been waiting on prospects to make their way up the farm system.
    • Frobby
      A philosophical question re offense and defense

      By Frobby · Posted

      I’ll now answer my own question.  Even though these three players are theoretically equivalent from a run differential standpoint, I would not want the player who’s -10 on defense.  That’s because I believe that poor defense bothers pitchers, causes them to try to do too much, and demoralizes them.  So maybe the fielder isn’t “responsible” in a WAR calculation when the rattled pitcher serves up gopher ball or walks the next guy after a poor defensive play, but there’s cause and effect there IMO.  So, give me someone who plays at least decent defense.   And, I think the Orioles feel the same way.  
    • Ohfan67
      Grayson Rodriguez 2024

      By Ohfan67 · Posted

      Really!? It's called baseball? Thanks for letting me know!   They are going to lose more games than they win when the starting pitcher has a sucky night. They can't score ten runs a night. The thread is about discussing Grayson Rodriquez's pitching. Just saying his performance doesn't really matter is incorrect and an uninteresting take. 
    • CaptainRedbeard
      Grayson Rodriguez 2024

      By CaptainRedbeard · Posted

      Exactly. If you go down a list of the leaderboards of velo leaders and note all their injuries, there’s a lot of them. But if you instead just take a list of all 30+ year old pitchers and sort it however you like, I don’t expect it’s going to look all that different. 
    • Say O!
      Cade Povich 2024

      By Say O! · Posted

      Aram loves the pitch metrics on Povich and McDermott. Was effusive in his spring podcast going through Os top prospects. 
    • Frobby
      Yesterday's Lineup - Thank You Mike Elias and Sig Mejdal

      By Frobby · Posted

      Let’s also give the org credit for the O’Hearn pickup.  He was part of last night’s lineup.  For that matter, they picked up Mateo too.  
    • RZNJ
      Jackson Holliday 2024

      By RZNJ · Posted

      Thank you.  Not sure how easy for someone who may have been doing it for years and someone who’s been talented enough to make it work.   Someone posted a video of Freddie Freeman and Holliday to show similarities but, to me, it just showed how different their lead foot was.  Freeman’s was closed and perfectly in line and parallel to his back foot.  Hollidays foot pointed out and the foot towards 2B position.  I questioned it.  Other guys, who admittedly know more, said it was no problem.  Again, he might be able to become a HOF with those mechanics.  I’ve just never seen a good ML hitter hit that way. From that early January thread “I guess it depends on your definition of “step in the bucket”.  His stride foot definitely doesn’t go straight.  Pretty easy to see where his foot is in relation to the batters box and how much further away it is when it lands.  It doesn’t seem to affect him negatively though.  Interestingly enough, Freeman’s stride foot goes perfectly straight.” Edited January 6 by RZNJ

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...