Jump to content

Creed Willems 2023


Frobby

Recommended Posts

It’s going to be 5 years before we have a clue whether Cowser is better than Lawlar and if Creed Willems is a major leaguer.  So, I don’t feel Elias has been proven right or wrong.  

My overall feeling is that making consistently good picks is more important than getting one pick exactly right.   And, I feel it’s obvious Elias has done that.  
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Can_of_corn said:

They didn't pay either of them slot.  Holliday got like 5K more than Jones.

They paid them the going rate.   Let's not split hairs.   They didn't look to do a Henry Davis deal like the Pirates did.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, RZNJ said:

They paid them the going rate.   Let's not split hairs.   They didn't look to do a Henry Davis deal like the Pirates did.

Witt signed for full slot at 1-2, Jones signed for over slot at 1-2;  Torkelson signed for over slot at at 1-1.

How is underslot the going rate?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

Witt signed for full slot at 1-2, Jones signed for over slot at 1-2;  Torkelson signed for over slot at at 1-1.

How is underslot the going rate?

Most normal posters get what I was saying.     You have issues.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

Witt signed for full slot at 1-2, Jones signed for over slot at 1-2;  Torkelson signed for over slot at at 1-1.

How is underslot the going rate?

Adley and Jackson were slot.  Are you suggesting they should have given them more?  Regardless, I look at your examples and it sheds an even more favorable light on how Elias has handled the draft.  Especially the 1.1 picks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, Frobby said:

It’s going to be 5 years before we have a clue whether Cowser is better than Lawlar and if Creed Willems is a major leaguer.  So, I don’t feel Elias has been proven right or wrong.  

My overall feeling is that making consistently good picks is more important than getting one pick exactly right.   And, I feel it’s obvious Elias has done that.  
 

Agreed.  I prefer to focus on the trends more than individual pick analysis.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Can_of_corn said:

They were not slot.

I have no issue with the picks.  But they were both underslot choices.  Money was saved.

Adley was the record signing bonuses at the time.  I believe Jackson  is only behind Tork’s overpay in the history books.  If it quacks like a slot and swims like a slot…

If we’re asking these questions about our signings, imagine being a Tiger fan!  1.1 don’t really have bargaining power and to still blow the top off the bonus is silly.  Get in the ballpark and they’ll sign.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • Okay, here's my take 1. Something is wrong with coaching/management. You don't see almost every player in your lineup dip below career norms for four months of the season without something being wrong. I have never thought Hyde was the guy. His in game decisions are not always that great. I wonder if it's a clubhouse leadership thing or something. Ben hit on it last night before the broadcast. They needed to score first to take the tension off of them. Hyde managed that last game scared, pulling Efflin after four innings and only one run given up. I bet the players could tell that too.  2. Do everything possible to sign Burnes (or a comparable free agent pitcher) to a long term deal. Definitely make the QO and take the pick if he wants to leave (and I really can't blame him) 3. Make the QO to Santander, but no long term offer. If he takes it, fine, but he comes up short in big situations too often. For some reason, he can only hit well from May-August.  4. We need one more "big", consistent hitter. Target that guy in free agency. Position really doesn't matter because we have alot of position flexibility, but an OF would be preferable. We need a veteran presence that can help these young guys when the going gets tough, especially if they choose to keep Hyde.  5: Keep the Ryans, but make sure they platoon
    • Corbin Burnes hasn't issued an intentional walk since 2018.
    • It can be debated from an analytical perspective if it is better to offensively focus on hitting homeruns or playing small ball or a combination of both.  It cannot be debated that this team offensively is horrible at the fundamentals in pressure situations.   The most basic fundamental in hitting a baseball is getting a good pitch to hit.  This team, routinely swings at horrible pitches, other teams have figured that out and that is what they see, willingly chasing pitches 6 inches outside or below the knees.   Until their inability to lay off of bad switches is corrected, they will struggle offensively.   Having a team of free swinging homerun hitters will not be successful.  They need to add guys who are willing to work the count, take a walk.  They need more speed, and some guys who can play small ball. In the lose to KC, they could not get a sac fly when needed.  They could not hit behind the runner.  They were not willing to bunt to advance a runner.   I don't care what the analytics say, when you strike out, nothing good can happen.  You can't advance the runner via hitting behind a runner, no sac fly, no chance of an error.  All you can say is they didn't hit into a double play.  With analytics, sometimes numbers are just numbers and the nerd analyzing them doesn't understand the context.   Please give me some 70's baseball.      
    • Eh, you’re not wrong, but just  because you can have a pissing match of Burnes vs Witt, doesn’t mean you have to. Same with Cano vs Witt.  Sometimes you literally circle their one good hitter and say he won’t beat us. 
    • Even in a summer where we had, checks notes, Westburg, Urias, Mateo and Mountcastle all on Injured Reserve (an entire starting infield, mind you, I think a lot of teams would be happy to have all four of those guys starting for them), O’Hearn only received 44 total PAs against left-handers, compared to 29 in 2023.  They absolutely try to limit him against LHP, but with those four injured during most of August/September, in the worlds of Hulk Hogan, what’cha gonna do?  
    • And Witt isn't even prime Bonds.  Be it '93 Bonds or roided out of his head 2001 Bonds. Corbin Burnes hasn't issued an intentional walk since 2018. 
    • Yeah it’s been a frustrating season. I get being upset, but to question the mental makeup of the team and say they all can’t perform under pressure is just ridiculously childish nonsense. And then to go after any posters who wanted to think we had any chance at winning anything is just some serious lowlife garbage. It’s embarrassing as a fan of this team to see grown men cry this loudly because we lost. It’s seriously embarrassing to see fans of a team hate on the team and their fellow fans because we lost. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...