Jump to content

Roberto Alomar and fielding


Recommended Posts

So, this whole Robbie Alomar spat got me thinking about his defense. Anecdotally he was one of the best 2B defensively ever to play. Having seen him play with both the Jays and the O's, I'm inclined to agree with this.

Yet Baseball Prospectus has him barely above average over his career (40 runs over average over the course of a 16 year career) and I seem to recall that most other metrics have him at slightly to extremely below average.

Is there any new data to indicate that the fielding metrics were off? A google search surmised that a lack of understanding of the effects of Astroturf may have caused his range-oriented metrics to appear lower than his true fielding ability. Any other ideas?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is there any new data to indicate that the fielding metrics were off?

Has there ever been any to suggest BP's numbers aren't off?

Any other ideas?

Go to this article a click on the link "for the past 21 seasons" under "1987 through 2007." Its a zone based system, not sure if that's what you were alluding to or not but it one of the better estimates of fielding from this time.

Alomar was stud at 2b in Bmore and not horrible in Toronto, and likely better with the turf factored in. He was pretty good in SD.

But he fell off a cliff in his early 30s and was pretty much horrible defensively after leaving the Os.

So yeah, he was a really good secondbaseman and then he turned into a really bad secondbaseman. But he was such a force at the plate it was all good in Cleveland. But not so much thereafter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok, so maybe he isn't regarded as doing so well in 2003/2004 in Toronto by the stats, but he was good with SD and in Bmore and not bad elsewhere in Toronto. Plus the turf factor.

But Robbie won all those gold gloves, which influences the way people perceived his defense. And as we know, if you have a big bat you can win a gold glove.

But we was real bad at D after Bmore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Is it too early (and possibly too crazy) to suggest that they may be a better road team than they are at home?    
    • I'm not very high on Giolito. How much better does he really make us? I would prefer to have a starter who can truly match up with the McClanahans, Coles, deGroms, Ryans, etc of the world. Otherwise, I think we are a long shot at best to win 1 round let alone 3.  In addition, he's an FA at the end of the year so he does nothing to help us solve this problem next year. If we are going to make a trade I would prefer that we don't try to address the gaping hole with a small bandaid, because despite our rich org prospect depth and talent, we don't have the pitching to project to have a talent edge on our competitors next year or beyond. I guess the same thing that applies to Giolito applies to Flahrety and Montgomery from STL IMO. They are not really tangibly better than what we have. I don't want any of those guys as my game 1/7 starter.  With the reserve/over abundance of org talent that we currently posses, I would prefer to fish for the cream of the crop as opposed to closer to the bottom of the barrel. IMO there's no reason to go cheap now in terms of what we are willing to give up to get the true difference making piece for the next few years. 
    • The reds are probably ready to compete next season so i doubt they will want to move a cost controlled top level back end bullpen guy.  The one thing they would want even if he was available would most likely be pitching prospects as they are built like us with young depth in position players.
    • Chapman is one of the last people on the planet I want walking into our clubhouse.  We don't need a cancer like him.
    • Chapman is one of the last people on the planet I want walking into our clubhouse.  We don't need a cancer like him.
    • I think the rotation will do find versus contending team.  It has so far.   I think other then Gibson the O's rotation is inexperienced not untalented.   All pitchers are inexperience before they actually do it on the field.   For every  Cobb that the team does not hit there is a Bieber that they hit well against.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...