Jump to content

If we had a time machine and went back to 1927 would our 2024 Orioles dominate the 27 Yankees?


Gurgi

Recommended Posts

4 hours ago, yark14 said:

Equipment is an important factor.  Are we playing with 1927 equipment? (same dirty and scuffed up ball for multiple innings, 50oz bats, crappy gloves). Do both teams have to endure 15+ double headers in a season and travel from city to city on trains?  Even with the primitive sports science and training methods of his day, Lou Gehrig would be the most jacked person on either team.  Imagine him at his peak if he had modern strength & conditioning, nutrition, and medicine. (he still would have died from ALS, but at least he'd likely live longer after being diagnosed)

Sure, pitchers back then maaaaybe topped out at 85-90mph, but if Babe and Lou dropped down from their 50oz bats to 33oz, they'd have no problem catching up to 100mph.  Austin Hays struck out 25% of the time last season, I wonder what the percentage would be if he was facing a pitcher throwing a dirty scuffed up ball?  

If training methods and equipment are equal, the '27 Yankees beat us 4-2 in a 7 game series.

Not to diminish Lou but Bob Meusel likely would be the "most jacked"-at 6'3" he was the Judge of the day but with speed and a much better arm-maybe the original five tool guy.

The Diary of Myles Thomas is some good light reading on the 1927 Yanks

https://1927-the-diary-of-myles-thomas.espn.com/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • My thoughts: - I agree that the Achilles heel is the bullpen and not the offense (especially with Westburg, Mountcastle, Urias, and Kjerstad back). - I also agree that Perez is overused in high leverage situations. This is going to come down to the degree you expect his “clutch” performance to be predictive going forward.  - I second the notion that most good bullpens are built with some degree of dumpster diving.  If you go back to offseason threads, there were not many desired bullpen FA targets (outside of unrealistic ones like Hader) that would have worked out well.  Maybe we haven’t “dumpster dived” well enough as evidenced by the success of Kaleb Ort in Houston. - Jacob Webb hasn’t been sharp since returning from the IL and Bowman has looked shaky his last few times out. - We don’t have a true closer, only a group of mostly effective set-up men in Dominguez, Cano, and Coulombe. - Part of me wishes they would be more aggressive with G-Rod and the Mountain. While we expect the team to continue to contend, you never really know how many times you’ll be back in the playoffs. However, I know in my head they are probably making the right decision. - I also feel like they should be auditioning McDermot, Selby, Young, or Strowd (who has been very good since August after rough Norfolk start). They could option Baker who I think is unlikely to have a path to trusted status after last year’s ALDS performance. This feeling may be mostly driven by dissatisfaction with the current state and wanting something better.  It might be unrealistic to expect options unproven at the MLB level to suddenly step in and be key playoff pieces.
    • Oh if we’re talking about what they will do, I can see it being something stupid like McCann at C and Adley at DH. I do think Mullins has enough veteranosity to outweigh Hyde’s obsession with L/R matchups. 
    • I agree…just not sure the Os will feel that way.  
    • Yeah I can see Rivera at DH. That’s probably a better choice than Kjerstad against Skubal. I’d definitely go with Mullins and Cowser over Slater. Slater has been really bad against LH this year. Only a .543 OPS. He’s actually worse than Cowser against LH and slightly better than Mullins. 
    • Not that it matters, but for some reason I took a lot of heat for suggesting mid season that Basallo would end up #1. It’s all good. We don’t have to agree 100% on everything. 
    • I don’t think he’s gonna be a part of any playoff roster, but kudos for him to rehab all the way back just to be an option for us if needed.  Also, hopefully now he’s shaken the injury and can have a normal offseason and normal fall instructs.  He’s a dude that if he could just be another Dean Kremer, would be huge for this org. 
    • My guess is vs Skubal or Ragans, the Os will go with an IF of Gunnar, Westy, Mounty and Urias.  Rivera will DH. Santander starts in RF. Obviously one of Cowser or Mullins starts but do both of them start?  Would they start Slater? Lefties hit Ragans much better than righties do this year. Everyone is terrible vs Skubal although lefties are worse.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...