I like Andy MacPhail's phrase for it: "A snapshot in time."
He said that regarding system rankings but it of course applies to individual prospects as well.
It would devolve into subjective opinion, but I still contend Holliday should be considered the most "talented" as his absolute upside at SS is hightest in the system. IMO.
Let’s revisit this for the millionth time.
Adley was hurt to start the season. Whatcha gonna do? I’m glad he was so good that he finished 2nd in the ROY, but it’s not like there was some plot to keep him off the OD roster.
GRod and Hall are different cases, to be judged on their own merits. I don’t consider either of their cases to start the year in the majors to be clear. They’re judgment calls, to be considered with other players.
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.