Jump to content

Carmona demoted to Rookie Ball


Recommended Posts


Rather than simply option him to Triple-A, the Indians have decided to send Carmona all the way down rookie-ball, although with the Arizona League still a couple weeks from getting underway it looks like he'll basically just be at extended spring training for a while.

Clearly the Indians feel that his struggles go beyond simply pitching poorly and extend to the erosion of his mechanics or mental state. Or maybe both. While extreme, the move is not totally without precedent. Roy Halladay and Dontrelle Willis are examples of big-name pitchers who were sent to the low minors at the peak of their struggles, with the demotion working wonders for Halladay and, so far at least, doing little for Willis.

Carmona came out of nowhere to finish fourth in the Cy Young balloting two years ago, using his power sinker to go 19-8 with a 3.06 ERA and 137/61 K/BB ratio in 215 innings. Since then he has a 6.10 ERA and 94/111 K/BB ratio in 181 innings, including an MLB-worst 41 walks in 61 frames this season. He's still working at 92-94 miles per hour and still getting tons of ground balls, but just can't throw the ball over the plate consistently (although he's not in Rick Ankiel territory).

The contract extension he got has really backfired for the Indians.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • I don't remember a lot of Hoes clinging.  I was more upset they traded Hader and the draft pick.
    • Absolutely. Think about how much we clung to a guy like LJ Hoes, and Hernaiz is a far better prospect.  It's wild to think that trading Hernaiz hasn't even made so much as a ripple in the farm system. We've come a looooong way. 
    • One stretch-comp deserves another. Had forgot that Syd Thriftism re. EdRod I: "the next Alex Rodriguez." LOFL!
    • Interesting that he and Gibson both crashed at the end of last year. I wonder if somebody found something correctable that caused the crash. 
    • Over the past couple of years I have vacillated between believing in Hall and not believing in him. I currently believe he has the ability to be a bullpen stud, but I really want him to be a starter. It feels like we always get these flamethrowing lefties that a team like the Rays would have no problem turning into their next ace, but they always end up in the bullpen here. That's not even a criticism of our development, really, I'm just complaining about our luck. The sample size of pitchers like Hall are tiny after all. Anyway, furthering my annoyance about Hall is just that I fail to see what the organization's plan is with the kid. Do they know? It seemed like one of the only things Elias and Development Squad weren't sure about last year. But maybe it just seemed that way from the outside. Obviously they have a plan.  There's no room for him on the roster, though, barring injuries. So after all of Elias' talk last year about Hall being so close and the organization "depending" on him, etc... is he really just going back to AAA again? On the one hand, you can't really argue with it. His AAA numbers were pretty weak. On the other hand, it seems kind of brutal to give him the yo-yo last season and then stick him right back in Norfolk.  Clearly the organization believes in him or they wouldn't put out a little documentary. So what's the plan exactly? 
    • This thread is something.  Jorge Mateo has little value anywhere because he can't hit.  Whether he's here, or not here, has little to do with the success of our 2023 season.  Any return in trade will be minimal.  Let's go another 15 pages though!
    • And there is no guarantee that Mateo will come close to that again either.  Or even get close.  If his bat doesn't improve he's likely not playing as much, and therefore not acquiring WAR.  As to the rest, who knows how Ortiz will be in comparison.  All reports say that he is the best defensive prospect of our bunch.  Could he also play gold glove defense?  I don't know, but it doesn't seem outside the realm of possibilities either.  Overall I think too many around here overrate Mateo and sell Ortiz short.  
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

  • Create New...