Jump to content

The Albert Pujols Debate


ScottieBaseball

Recommended Posts

I kind of think he's clean as well but think about all of the other players that people had high opinions of but turned out to be liars. I mean Papi, come one, no one saw that one coming.

I know, its sad and you never know what to think. Its kinda almost like having a friend who is doing crack or heroine who persists that they are clean and arent doing it at all even though you can visibly see needle marks in their arms and yellowish green skin complexion. You believe them because they are your friend and you justify the symptoms somehow because their your friend (favorite baseball player) so you give them the benefit of the doubt. Then one morning you get a phone call from jail and its your friend and they got arrested for drugs. It breaks your heart , and even though PEDs arent heroine or crack, it is still a bad drug that will force you to lie and can cause life changing outcomes(Chris Benoit?)....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 46
  • Created
  • Last Reply
... you as a cards fan saying that makes me lose slight confidence in my opinion that hes clean.....

My being a Cardinals fan shouldn't affect your confidence. My comment is general, in that I can't know that anyone is "clean", not specific to anything I know about Pujols personally.

There are clues that he's telling the truth when he says he's never used PEDs, but that doesn't prove anything. It's difficult to prove a negative.

I try to evaluate players I like and admire the same way that I evaluate players I detest. Before the revelations by McNamee (corroborated by Radomski, Pettitte, and Knoblauch), I had already expressed my suspicions about the ability of Roger Clemens to put up the best ERA+ of his career at age 42, but I made a point of emphasizing that it was only my suspicions

Back to Pujols, like I said, there are a few clues.

(1) While Pujols is from the Dominican Republic, by all reports a hotbed of PEDs usage among young ballplayers, he emigrated to the U.S. at the age of 16.

(2) He married a single mom whose daughter has Downs Syndrome. A lot of us wouldn't have taken on that "burden".

(3) His consistency has been absolutely incredible. For one example, his at bats in his first 5 seasons were 590, 590, 591, 592, and 591. Assuming that his BA doesn't slip, he will have hit above .300, with more than 30 home runs and more than 100 RBIs in every one of his 9 seasons. He has also scored over 100 runs in all but one of those seasons, just 99 in 2007.

(4) Each off season, Pujols leads a team of medical personnel to the Dominican Republic to provide medical, dental, and optical care to impoverished families. Albert and his wife participate as translators during the day, then cook up a meal for the team each evening.

(5) On October 23, there will be an "Autumn Prom" held at the Crown Plaza in Clayton (a St. Louis suburb). Attendance will be by invitation only to those with Downs Syndrome, aged 16 and over. (I wonder if that will conflict with any of the post season schedule.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • Thank you.  Not sure how easy for someone who may have been doing it for years and someone who’s been talented enough to make it work.   Someone posted a video of Freddie Freeman and Holliday to show similarities but, to me, it just showed how different their lead foot was.  Freeman’s was closed and perfectly in line and parallel to his back foot.  Hollidays foot pointed out and the foot towards 2B position.  I questioned it.  Other guys, who admittedly know more, said it was no problem.  Again, he might be able to become a HOF with those mechanics.  I’ve just never seen a good ML hitter hit that way. From that early January thread “I guess it depends on your definition of “step in the bucket”.  His stride foot definitely doesn’t go straight.  Pretty easy to see where his foot is in relation to the batters box and how much further away it is when it lands.  It doesn’t seem to affect him negatively though.  Interestingly enough, Freeman’s stride foot goes perfectly straight.” Edited January 6 by RZNJ
    • He allowed only one batted ball over 95 MPH, commanding his cutter particularly well in this one. I think the cutter is the most critical pitch for Povich to take the next step. He’s never had issues getting punch outs, he needs to be able to pitch in the zone without relying too much on his fastball. It’s also a key weapon against RHP - if you don’t have a true plus breaking ball or fastball that can overcome the platoon splits (which I don’t think Povich does), you can only make it as a LHP SP through the strength of your cutter and changeup, which are more reverse/neutral splits.  His changeup is probably not good enough to carry him on its own, so it’s the cutter that brings the whole pitch mix together.  
    • Agree he steps in the bucket. In theory should be a relatively easy fix. 
    • His back or shoulder might give out first. Hardly any talented pitcher retires without some sort of serious injury recorded.
    • Plus Member  30.8k Posted January 24 Aram Leighton from Just Baseball on Holliday “He has the tendency to pull off of the ball a bit with his front side, which can minimize his ability to use the ground and his lower half to generate more power, especially on pitches on the outer half. The move does not impede his ability to consistently make contact thanks to his adjustability and feel for the barrel. Holliday projects as an easy plus hitter with more juice to tap into.“ https://www.justbaseball.com/prospects/baltimore-orioles-top-15-prospects-for-2024/
    • I guess my point is that the difference between 91 and 93 at the MLB level is probably negligible.  I would put significant emphasis on pitch sequencing, command and control, and the ability to land his secondary pitches.  If I am recalling his repertoire correctly his most important pitch is his change up.  And it was his ability to effectively throw a breaking pitch, I think it was a Slider, that really ushered in his pre-injury success.  Now you can make the case that 2 miles per hours of fastball velocity may make the change up an even more effective pitch.  I would not argue with you about that aspect, however I am not certain it explains much about his previous success.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...