Jump to content

Phillies are scouting Sherrill. What would we want in return?


My O's Face

Recommended Posts

I do not think that the Phillies will trade Taylor (I know that I wouldn't. Kid looks like a monster), but if I could get any player back for Sherill that has been discussed (Bell, Wood, etc.) it would be him. Everything that I have read about him just screams masher at 1B.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 127
  • Created
  • Last Reply
I do not think that the Phillies will trade Taylor (I know that I wouldn't. Kid looks like a monster), but if I could get any player back for Sherill that has been discussed (Bell, Wood, etc.) it would be him. Everything that I have read about him just screams masher at 1B.

If I had my choice between Wood, Bell, and Taylor...

That would be a hard choice, but it would be between Wood and Taylor. As much as I love B. Wood (which I have for years now), I'd go with Taylor. He's younger and can murder the ball.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do not think that the Phillies will trade Taylor (I know that I wouldn't. Kid looks like a monster), but if I could get any player back for Sherill that has been discussed (Bell, Wood, etc.) it would be him. Everything that I have read about him just screams masher at 1B.

Taylor is 24 ...so he's not a young prospect from the article someone else posted here. He's blocked by Howard & thats the main reason hes still in the OF. The Phillies are in a win now mode. Sherrill & Baez/Hendrickson make them better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FYI: RT: @ToddZolecki Carlos Carrasco scratched from today's game in Lehigh Valley. Jason Donald and Lou Marson also out of the lineup.

http://twitter.com/BrentSGambill/status/2910829962

I didn't see a generic trade thread so I just put it here.

This is interesting.

Those are lesser prospects than one would expect in a Halladay trade, but greater than what I would expect in a Sherrill trade. Either way, if those players are on the move, then Sherrill to the Phillies will be dead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Taylor is 24 ...so he's not a young prospect from the article someone else posted here. He's blocked by Howard & thats the main reason hes still in the OF.

In reading all this Taylor talk, I kept asking myself why we'd go after an OF, even knowing how amazing he is. Didn't realize we would move him to 1B. That makes much more sense. Thanks for clearing that up.

But it brings to mind another question. Maybe it deserves it's own thread, but which scenario would you prefer for 2010?

Option 1: Wiggy or Huff @ 1B, Wood/Bell at 3B

Option 2:Taylor @ 1B, Wiggy (Huff probably not an option in this case) @ 3B?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In reading all this Taylor talk, I kept asking myself why we'd go after an OF, even knowing how amazing he is. Didn't realize we would move him to 1B. That makes much more sense. Thanks for clearing that up.

But it brings to mind another question. Maybe it deserves it's own thread, but which scenario would you prefer for 2010?

Option 1: Wiggy or Huff @ 1B, Wood/Bell at 3B

Option 2:Taylor @ 1B, Wiggy (Huff probably not an option in this case) @ 3B?

It would depend on which of the three players is going to be better ...Personally I would pick up Taylor & i'd be ok with Adrian Beltre (Age 30) at 3B for a couple of years until we have a better option.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Taylor doesn't turn 24 until December.

I doubt the Phils will give him up for Sherrill but if they would, Taylor should be the #1 target...I would trade Sherill for him straight up in a heartbeat.

I really like Bell and Wood but Taylor is a surer thing IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally I am glad Donald is gone. I was afraid we would try and get him. Never impressed me at AA, but Taylor is huge. Reminds me of a first baseman in stature vs. an OF. The guy is stacked and hits pure lasers. Talking with some friends I asked do you remember anybody hitting a ball that hard. They all said yes. Guess who? Ryan Howard of course. I have stated numerous times I would do a Taylor straight up for Guthrie or Sherrill. I like him that much. Plus if we get him we can trade Scott for something else if we have a log jam in the OF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally I am glad Donald is gone. I was afraid we would try and get him. Never impressed me at AA, but Taylor is huge. Reminds me of a first baseman in stature vs. an OF. The guy is stacked and hits pure lasers. Talking with some friends I asked do you remember anybody hitting a ball that hard. They all said yes. Guess who? Ryan Howard of course. I have stated numerous times I would do a Taylor straight up for Guthrie or Sherrill. I like him that much. Plus if we get him we can trade Scott for something else if we have a log jam in the OF.

I would hope that they'd switch Reimold or Taylor to 1B if we were to acquire him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




  • Posts

    • The O's often seem to get runners on base but can't drive them in.   They often don't get the big hit that opens up the game.   Yesterday that is just what Lester did.   He got the hit that made the score go from  3-0 to 6-0 (which included a Giant error).    The thing that impressed me about Lester's hit was he did not swing for the fences.   He hit a single to right center with the bases loaded.   So often it seems the  O's take the big swing and fly out to the warning track.    I guess that is how Lester has 50 RBIs in 52 games in AAA.   Lester did what the O's needed.   He drove in the runs.  The O's could use a guy like that. So Coulombe is expected back on Tuesday.   Someone has to be optioned.   Will it be Lester or Vavra?   And if Lester stays where  will that find at bats for him?   Do they give Gunnar more time for his back to heal?   All I have is questions.  No answers.  
    • What a bum! Non-prospect, obviously
    • Haha, I heard that - but ironically she had done the EXACT same thing, either during the Rangers or Indians series, so this time I was prepared for what she meant lol.
    • Not to make excuses for Mountcastle, he hasn't been good, but it still seems to me that he is punished by bad luck. How many balls has he hit hard that in a majority of instances would be base hits / extra bases? I see him attempting to be more selective with the low and away pitches only to be screwed by umpires with an unfavorable call, which often has put him in bad counts forcing him to swing away. I say this not to provide an excuse for the guy, but it's gotta weigh heavily on a player when he's smoking pitches that are continuously finding gloves. Mountcastle is a peculiar case, and who knows what the answer is. At this point maybe just have to except that bad luck is a part of his game, and move on to someone who actually produces instead of waiting on the hope of Mountcastle could be.
    • Absolutely, arguing the merits of the strategy is completely fair. That is very different than the post I responded to, which was trying to psychoanalyze Hyde and some of his players. That gets us into subjective territory rather than evidence based discussion. So far the matchup strategy seems to be working but there may come a point in time it doesn't. I appreciate you called our some concerning trends that we can then track as the season progresses. Based on the track record so far, I am giving Hyde and staff a long leash to see how it plays out. Last year, Baker, Perez, and Bautista were all very strong down the stretch. That being said, using Cano up five was a weird decision.  I can only think that Hyde wanted Cano to get work with an off day coming up. I am quite certain though that it wasn't in reaction to Baumann giving up the walk, as Cano would have been warming up well before that point. 
    • She was terrible on the call for the Sabol homerun yesterday. It went something like “Santander back towards the wall, he turns and it’s off the top of the wall! *5 second pause* The Sabol homerun makes it a 7-2 ball game” I was listening thinking the ball was off the wall and in play, stuff like that just happens far to often with her or Garceau on the radio, where you’re just sitting there wondering what just happened. 
    • Yep, I had that wrong. It was Veen over Kjerstad, and you were not alone. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...