The only circumstance that dictates it is that he fails as a starter. I get he's in the pen this year, but he's a starter next season. BP arms are a dime a dozen in the off-season. Our two best relievers were scap heap guys.
Even the top 10 have a 45% bust rate and the top 11-20 have a 50% bust rate. Only 35% of the top 10 go on to be superior players, 30% for the top 11-20