Honestly I just wonder how you replace the production.
Is he worth 4/57....no. Would he have been worth say 3/45 to this team? I think so. Looking at it from that perspective its a 10-12 million overpay. If you cant find a way to replace his production, I think your putting your ability to win the division and make a WS run in serious peril. If those things matter to you then why would anyone care if Pete valued them at 10-12 million spread out over 4 years? The idea that the Orioles minus Nelson Cruz are not any worse than they were last year is silly. We have taken a step back, the idea is to push forward. If we are trying to be the cutest most cost efficient team ever then I guess we just scored a coup, if we are trying to capitalize on a narrow window in which teams have to win championships, I think seeing this as anything but a negative is just finding a way to rationalize the decision.