I actually think the Gausman deal, compared to the Gray deal isn't as bad as some are saying. yes, the Gray deal had three top 100 guys. But one was trending downward for over a full season and is struggling in AAA(jorge Mateo), an injured high ceiling pitcher who required tommy john and will be 25 for the 2019 season(also don't know how he will bounce back from the injury and hasn't played in 2018), and an outfielder coming off a serious knee injury(for me, he was the centerpiece and has the highest ceiling, currently in the MLB).
We got 2.5 million in international cash, which could be used to sign some quality talent other than VVM.
We dumped a ton of salary which can be reinvested into scouting and analytics.
We might have gotten a prospect with the highest ceiling in the system in Jean Carlos Encarnacion. He will stick at third with a plus arm and solid defense. He has plus raw power. You say he has obvious flaws, I assume that being his K/BB ratio. I'm not concerned, the kid is only 20 and will mature. Look at Mountcastle's stats in low A, they are extremely similar. Nobody is complaining about Mountcastle. And yes Mountcastle is a year younger, but different guys are a bit more/less polished at different ages and thus take differing developmental timelines.
We might have gotten a backend starter in Zimmerman. IMO, Zimmerman has a higher ceiling than most believe. I think he will play up as he has a good low 90s sinker from the left side, has shown the ability to miss bats, and has two solid secondaries along with good command. I think he could play up to be a mid rotation guy even though he has #4/5 stuff.
We got a catcher with a great batting eye, 23 yrs old and now in AA. He might not have a good hit tool, but he has average-above average power. Defense allows him to stick at catcher. He has upside of a starter and a floor of backup catcher.
We also got a MLB-ready reliever dominating in AAA. 23 yrs old, fastball sits at 93-96 with a solid slider. He will be at the very least a cost-controlled middle reliever, with the potential of being a 7th inning guy. That, while uninspiring, is valuable.
The Gausman deal IS uninspiring, but IMO has more value to this organization than the Gray package would have.