Oh, I wasn't even thinking about their career arcs, just their skillsets and approach to the game. I don't see how players can be comped for results before they create them.
I could be misremembering this, but didn't Finley hurt his shoulder leaping for a ball at the wall in his first game as an Oriole and miss a few weeks? The way Finley played with reckless abandon, and speed, and a plus arm while putting up good offensive numbers. That's how I thought they were comparable.