That's fine, like I said McKenna is a doofus. Yes, worse instincts than Hays, too.
I'm not sure how much better Hays is in the field than McKenna. I'll concede that Hays is a better candidate to throw a runner out. He's got a strong, accurate arm.
People can pick their defensive stats that they like, I really don't like investigating with them since they all have inherent flaws, and Hays has way more data to look at in innings, 1195.1 last year compared to McKenna's 78.2 innings. But I don't think McKenna is that far behind him from a defensive (Rtot, Rdrs, rtot/yr rdrs/yr) perspective. I'll concede defense overall but Hays has been so awful with the bat that I'm not sure he makes up for it with the glove.