I still don't get it.
If you have a quality RH hitter without platoon splits how is it worse?
Mullins is better since he stopped switch hitting.
Not many of the really great hitters switch hit. It's not needed.
You did say that, and I mentioned that you did.
My question is why does that make a difference?
How is a switch hitter better than someone who doesn't switch hit but puts up similar numbers? Not everyone has pronounced platoon splits.
The whole best hitter since Eddie thing has been misread.
First off they meant power hitter so Roberts is exempted.
Secondly they were only talking about switch hitters for some reason. I don't get why that would make a difference but this started with someone quoting one of those specific statistical achievements the media likes to foster on us.