I think voters these days aren't really looking at W/L record too much unless someone wins 20 which is becoming exceedingly rare.
Pluses: Good ERA, if he can somehow get under 3.00 that would go a long way. Strong WHIP. Pitching like a #1 starter for a team that has strong playoff chances. If he keeps dealing against good teams, that'll help him.
Minuses: Relatively unknown, not enough innings (he's 37th in the AL right now), not enough strikeouts. He's actually got as many strikeouts right now as Felix Bautista does.
I don't think there's a chance he gets into the top 5, but if he received a vote and finished somewhere in the 10-12 range, I could see that happening.