I agree it wasn't kind.
If you aren't kind it means you gutted someone?
They also said " At times, Fernando Tatis Jr. is an absolutely incredible fielder."," The speed, presence of mind, and arm strength needed to turn that ball into an out are simply breathtaking.", " If you needed proof that Tatis is a sparkling defender, there it is.", " Fernando Tatis Jr. is one of the most exciting players in baseball.", and "he’s capable of greatness. His highs are extremely high."
I think the rebuke was fair.