A++?
A- Davis is still on the roster. Most folks seem to think that's ownership driven. I'd say that Davis being on the roster counts as a "Hint of owner meddling".
B- He made sure Hays held onto his prospect status and drafted 1-1. If as much progress was made in as to give an A++ grade, I would expect to have seen more of a jump in the O's prospect rankings.
C- How much money did he have and not spend last cycle? Yes, yes, I know the reasons but we are talking A++ performance right? No really big names this cycle either keeps me from awarding an A.
D- Dan Straily and Nate Karns keep this from being an A++ effort. He also managed to trade away a guy that put up a 2.8 win season in 107 games.