I think that's a reasonable statement, I think you want to challenge people but not put them in totally over their heads. That said, the statement I responded to was that he would've been the O's best third baseman last year...and that's not accurate, as bad as the O's third base situation was...it's better then you would have gotten out of 19yo Gunnar
(now it's distinctly possible, likely even, he is currently our best option)