Jump to content

Economist: The Cult Of The Genius GM


Recommended Posts


If you believe in the "Moneyball"-inspired Great GM Theory of Baseball, Mr Friedman?s move should foreshadow the apocalypse for competitive balance in the sport. Statistically-minded observers have long encouraged teams to invest in their front offices: earlier this year Benjamin Morris of FiveThirtyEight calculated that Mr Beane had been worth an astonishing $1.4 billion to the Oakland Athletics. Once the news broke of Mr Friedman?s move, Rob Neyer claimed that ?it?s long been obvious that good general managers were massively underpaid? (emphasis in original), and Ken Rosenthal wrote that ?whatever the price, Friedman will be a bargain.? If rich clubs are at last beginning to wield their financial advantage on their brain trusts as well as their players, this argument goes, their poorer rivals will be consigned to the league?s basement for all eternity.
Replacement level can also be extended to assess the relative worth of athletes to GMs. And contrary to Mr Neyer?s and Mr Rosenthal?s assertions, this approach would probably indicate that Mr Friedman, whose salary has not yet been announced, is likely to be over- rather than underpaid.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Yes.  They said they were going to do this. 
    • Looks like Kevin will be doing the Nerdcast of Sunday Night Baseball on ESPN2 for those that have missed his voice.
    • This is the Mayo I see when I watch games.  I used to suggest he would be Devers level with the glove at third.  But honestly he seems worse.  
    • I think Mayo is the guy that gets traded as well.  Been thinking that since the season started.  Painful, but to get a star it has to be painful. 
    • Hyde said postgame he wasn’t available 
    • I have no problem with the Tigers saying they want the moon and the stars.  Its a negotiating position.  The  Tigers GM and Ownership have to know that no trade has ever happened for a pitcher that is as aggressive that they are asking for.  They don't have to trade Skubal so the O's have to motive the Tigers with what that offer could be. The O's offense is #1 in baseball in Homers, Slugging and Runs per game.    They are first in the AL in OPS.  The O's don't want to damage that.  They are 11th in Average and 15th OBP.  They want to improve that. The O's have the #1 Farm System to deal from. They need to keep: 1) Holliday because he will bring the high average and OBP the O's need In the future. 2) Basallo.  It's hard to find catchers that can hit and control the running game.  Him first teaming with Adley and a some point replacing Adley is a game changer. 3) Kjerstad is needed to replace Santander unless, unless, unless the O's are willing to extend him for 4/68m.   Which way will Elias and Rubinstein go with that? ------ Mayo with his incredible talent is someone that can head up a package.   Mayo is BA #25 prospect in 2024.  O's #3 prospect. (O's prospect by MLB.com) Bradfield BA #82 prospect in 2024; #4 O's prospect  and Norby BA #93 prospect in 2023,  #5 Os prospect with a 911 OPS at AAA  currently are two players the Tigers could pick between. McDermott #7 O's prospect; Povich O's #8 prospect:  and Johnson O's #9 prospect are three future starters that  Tigers could pick between. Elias could add one or two more prospects to this list. Looking at the Bedard package I think this package could compares well.    
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...