Jump to content

Economist: The Cult Of The Genius GM


Can_of_corn

Recommended Posts

http://www.economist.com/blogs/gametheory/2014/10/brains-v-brawn-baseball?fsrc=scn/tw/te/bl/ed/cultofthegeniusgm

If you believe in the "Moneyball"-inspired Great GM Theory of Baseball, Mr Friedman?s move should foreshadow the apocalypse for competitive balance in the sport. Statistically-minded observers have long encouraged teams to invest in their front offices: earlier this year Benjamin Morris of FiveThirtyEight calculated that Mr Beane had been worth an astonishing $1.4 billion to the Oakland Athletics. Once the news broke of Mr Friedman?s move, Rob Neyer claimed that ?it?s long been obvious that good general managers were massively underpaid? (emphasis in original), and Ken Rosenthal wrote that ?whatever the price, Friedman will be a bargain.? If rich clubs are at last beginning to wield their financial advantage on their brain trusts as well as their players, this argument goes, their poorer rivals will be consigned to the league?s basement for all eternity.
Replacement level can also be extended to assess the relative worth of athletes to GMs. And contrary to Mr Neyer?s and Mr Rosenthal?s assertions, this approach would probably indicate that Mr Friedman, whose salary has not yet been announced, is likely to be over- rather than underpaid.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Orioles News and Information

Daily Organizational Boxscores

News

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2022 Top 75 Prospects

Statistics

2022 Orioles Stats

2022 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats



  • Posts

    • I'd love to see the P&L for the Orioles.  We all know Angelos is a liar regarding what the Os can afford and not afford in terms of long-term contracts.  But this thread got me thinking...~2MM people at an avg ticket price of $34 (link to avg ticket price:  https://www.statista.com/statistics/203453/baltimore-orioles-average-ticket-price/) basically pays the entire big league roster by itself.  Sponsorships/Concessions/Concerts etc likely pay the front office staff and other facility/minor league expenses.  So basically Angelos is pocketing close to $100MM annually ($60MM national TV share + $40MM MASN TV share).  Heck, let's say I underestimated the "other expenses" outside of the MLB payroll by $50MM....he's still pocketing $50MM/year.... 
    • He was in like 6th grade. Well on his way!!!!!!!!
    • So I think Povich is on turn today.   Is he getting the ball for the deciding game of the International League championship series?   If so, that’s a huge test for him. He pitched against Durham one other time and had a great outing, allowing one run on one hit in 6 IP.  He’d be going on “only” four days’ rest, so if he’s pitching, it will be interesting to see what he’s got in the tank.  
    • Certainly on of the best "demotion to AAA" success stories I can remember.
    • Not disappointed at all.  It was a rough road for him to start but he's been tremendous since coming back from the minors.  A strong finish (over an extended period of time, too) makes up for how rocky the season started for him. I agree with Froberto Duran.  I will have very high expectations for him next year.
    • Good thread bump.  Even though Rodriguez’s ERA was higher than I expected, because of the way it happened, I am not disappointed.   I wasn’t expecting him to have such serious hiccups early, but his performance after he returned from AAA vastly exceeded my expectations for him. And, he threw more innings (163.1) than I expected, counting his AAA work.  Postseason innings to come. If we do a “Grayson Rodriguez Expectations 2024” thread, my expectations will be pretty damned high.    
    • While I will take it on faith that Gunnar Henderson was extaordinarily talented in his age 11 season, I do not think the Orioles can claim the credit for developing him in 2012. 😎
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...