Harvey was a first round draft pitcher with strong family pedigree, so his improvement is based on Sisco's catching him? Sorry, I dont really go along with that, but hey, you are welcome to that. Not exactly like you said the world was flat.
I will strongly disagree with you about C defense being over rated.
I dont agree, call me old school, call me an idiot, I dont care. Give me a plus defender at Catcher that can handle the pitchers, set up the correct location for the pitch called for, being the field general out there. making sure his COF isnt in the wrong position.